This lovely, immaculate home was very comfortable and was so well equipped. It was near our daughter's vacation home and we enjoyed entertaining our grandchildren as much as they loved being with us! Close to everything.

Nice house, freshly remodeled with modern appliances and fixtures and well decorated. Quiet neighborhood in a convenient location. Excellent communication from the owner.

We highly reccommed this rental. The house was clean, fresh and up to date. We enjoyed nights on the deck grilling. Close to great resturants, ice cream and morning coffee spots. The house is open and spacious. Making it very comportable for our family. We cant wait to come back to the island and stay again.

We had a great weekend at The Heights — the house is comfortable, with a great back yard. We spent mornings on the deck. It's a few minutes drive to some very good restaurants, and a 5-minute walk to ice cream or the beach. We'd be very happy to stay there again.

Everything about this home was top notch. Jake's home is immaculately clean and comfortable --- the furniture and beds were super comfy, kitchen was equipped with everything you need and more which made for fun cooking while being together with my family in the open concept kitchen/living room/dining. All the appliances were brand new and the kitchen flow was ideal for meal prep and clean up. We enjoyed seeing deer, turkeys, rabbits and birds outside while grilling and chilling on the back deck. There's even a fire pit for smores or just hanging out looking at the stars. Jake was quick with communication and left us great instructions for the house, as well as some nice touches to welcome my family. The house is situated in a great location for walks to the beach, just a 5 min walk to great bagels and ice cream. thank you Jake for a lovely stay. We will definitely be back to visit the lovely Shelter Island!

Great house on Shelter Island! We were 4 adults and 2 children under 3 years old and it was the perfect size for us. The property was very well equipped with everything we would need, and also very clean. We loved the living room/dining area and kitchen which is all open-plan and a great place for everyone to hang out. Jared was a wonderful host, super communicative & helpful throughout!