The best rentals from the top sites, all in one place

We believe finding a beachfront vacation rental in Fire Island should be easy and not take hours of searching and scrolling. We’ve designed VacationRenter from the ground up to help travelers find the perfect rental faster and easier.

Where to stay in Fire Island

Beachfront vacation rentals in Fire Island

There are 768 beachfront rentals near Fire Island for all manner or mood of traveling to the shoreline, availability of time off, and size of budget. So, if you are hoping for an affordable Fire Island Beach vacation, you can find 10% of the available rentals under $100/night. Or if you are willing to splurge on a luxury vacation in Fire Island, there are 77 between $950 and $8,000/night. Whether you are sleeping by yourself or with a significant other, or are travelling with a group of 31 there are short term home and apartment rentals in Fire Island near the beach to fit your New York vacation needs. The most popular types of beachfront rentals in Fire Island are houses, private rooms and apartments. Fire Island has been a frequently searched travel destination this year and continues to grow in popularity because of its beaches and other water activities. VacationRenter offers a wide selection of available beach vacation rentals from leading travel sites like VRBO (Vacation Rentals By Owner), Homeaway,, and many more. Search your travel dates to find available Fire Island vacation homes for your beach trip.

More Home-types in Fire Island

Fire Island has a variety of property types for you to consider when booking a trip. Here are the most popular property types in Fire Island:
- Oceanfront768 vacation rentals
- Beach768 vacation rentals
- House570 vacation rentals
- Private Room134 vacation rentals
- Condo52 vacation rentals
- Apartment52 vacation rentals

Points of interests in Fire Island

Fire Island has several popular points of interest for you to check out when visiting the area. Here are the most popular points of interest in Fire Island:
- Fire Island: 362 vacation rentals
- Fire Island Pines: 264 vacation rentals
- Sailors Haven Visitor Center: 119 vacation rentals
- Cherry Grove: 69 vacation rentals
- Sunken Forest: 66 vacation rentals
- Smith Point Park: 65 vacation rentals
- Fire Island Parasail: 64 vacation rentals
- Fire Island Lighthouse: 7 vacation rentals
- Robert Moses State Park: 7 vacation rentals