The good: The area and inn was quiet and peaceful and clean. The bad: the bed was too soft and lumpy, so we didn't get a good night's rest. Usually, hotel beds are firm. The breakfast was laughable and paltry for the price of the room.

Nice, comfortable property. Great breakfast - close to everything in Edgartown. Friendly, helpful staff.

Hotel is excellent and decor lovely. Staff very helpful and continental breakfast adequate. Lovely courtyard to sit in too. Great location near ferry dock and close to shops and restaurants.

Hotel is excellent and decor lovely. Staff very helpful and continental breakfast adequate. Lovely courtyard to sit in too. Great location near ferry dock and close to shops and restaurants.

Really enjoyed the Edgartown Inn. Would stay there again!

Great location in Edgartown, recently renovated, helpful staff.

very helpful team and beautiful rooms

I cannot in good conscience recommend this hotel. It is pretty - you see the pictures online - but the parking situation was highly problematic and the customer service was abysmal. The hotel does admit on this site that they lack parking, which they justify by saying you don’t need it, you can take the bus. It is true the island has a bus, but during Covid times I am trying to avoid public transportation and anyway how is waiting at a bus stop part of a luxury vacation? So you bring the car. From 6 AM to 11 PM you have to move the car every two hours, and that’s if you can get a spot. There are small squares nearby where you could leave your car from 11 PM to 6 AM if you can find a spot, but how is waking up early to move the car before you’re towed part of a luxury vacation? So you have to leave the car at this lot at the edge of town where the tourist buses park and walk back one full mile to the hotel, through poorly lit streets. Then there’s the customer service problem. This hotel is staffed only during business and they will not offer any assistance before 8 AM or after 6 PM. I wanted to check out early to catch an early ferry and wanted to know if they wanted me to just leave the room unlocked with the key on the table or did they have a drop box. They do not answer phone or text after bankers hours. One number they give is out of service, and the other goes straight to a machine they never check. I checked out early to stay at a legitimate hotel instead.

The staff was excellent. It’s a very nice boutique hotel. I would definitely go back.

The staff are absolutely amazing and so engaged. They appear to genuinely enjoy providing care and assistance and it makes the experience so relaxing and inviting. I can’t wait until next year! Katie was the best!

Customer Service is excellent. Beautiful and clean hotel in the best area of Martha's Vineyard. Katie and all of the team provided me with the best vacation experience in Edgartown. Thanks for helping me celebrate my boyfriend's birthday. He had a memorable birthday!

The staff was very friendly. The room was nicely decorated and welcoming. The complimentary breakfasts and snacks added a nice touch.

Beautiful modern room, extra large shower, comfortable bed and amazing staff.

This hotel is well located. It’s very clean and comfortable. We stayed on room 12 which has a great view of the harbor.

This hotel is well located. It’s very clean and comfortable. We stayed on room 12 which has a great view of the harbor.

Lovely "chain boutique" hotel. I have also stayed at lark sister hotels, The Sydney and The Richard. They are all very well done. The only short-coming at my recent stay at the Edgartown Inn was that on one of the two mornings they ran out of several breakfast items (no juice, only one food item available). On the other day the display area was full, with 3 food items and juice available.

Katie was wonderful and all who worked at this location. Friendly, personal service. Comfortable rooms with modern amenities.

5 star

Amazing stay. Would definitely come back!

We had an amazing stay and will definitely stay again. The entire Inn was recently renovated and it is beautiful. But what really made the experience was the staff. It felt like you were staying with a friend. Special shout out to Katie who really took care of us from the second we arrived. Can’t wait to come back.

We had an amazing stay and will definitely stay again. The entire Inn was recently renovated and it is beautiful. But what really made the experience was the staff. It felt like you were staying with a friend. Special shout out to Katie who really took care of us from the second we arrived. Can’t wait to come back.

The Staff was awesome..accommodations superb. So glad we stayed here for it made our stay at MV perfect!

The Staff was awesome..accommodations superb. So glad we stayed here for it made our stay at MV perfect!

Wonderful, cozy yet modern place with great and attentive staff. And they make fresh baked goods for breakfast and throughout the day!

Wonderful, cozy yet modern place with great and attentive staff. And they make fresh baked goods for breakfast and throughout the day!

Very cute boutique hotel in the center of Edgartown, steps to restaurants and a 10min walk to the lighthouse beach. The room is very clean, our room also had a nice view with a peak at the ocean. We also loved the living area in the hotel, reading a book on the pouch was lovely in a sunny afternoon

Very cute boutique hotel in the center of Edgartown, steps to restaurants and a 10min walk to the lighthouse beach. The room is very clean, our room also had a nice view with a peak at the ocean. We also loved the living area in the hotel, reading a book on the pouch was lovely in a sunny afternoon

Gorgeous hotel within walking distance to shops and lighthouse beach. Tranquil, beautiful setting in the heart of Edgartown. Friendly and helpful staff.

Gorgeous hotel within walking distance to shops and lighthouse beach. Tranquil, beautiful setting in the heart of Edgartown. Friendly and helpful staff.

Nicely decorated. very clean, the staff is awesome. My only complaint was that the room was small. Was hard to maneuver with luggage. Great chocolate chip cookies and a perfect location in Edgartown. We want to come back in the fall.

Updated and modern hotel. Would stay again!

Charming. Beautiful. Friendly. This property is in an ideal location, right in town and the Edgartown Lighthouse.