Friendly staff very clean.

Friendly staff, very comfortable room, decent breakfast selection. Would definitely stay here again if in the area.

Loved the area. Close to Fish Creek and Egg Harbor for shopping and eating. The grounds were nice. Spread out and felt warm. I had emailed the Inn to ask if we could bring a solo stove and set it up in a field so we could have fires at night. I was told the fireplace inside the lobby sitting area would be lit and we could enjoy that. The only time the fireplace was lit was during the day on Friday when we arrived around 2:30. It was disappointing. And it wasn’t for lack of wood. There was tons of wood outside the entrance. We had a gas fireplace in our room, but it barely had any flame. We loved that the windows opened. Kept us from having to put the air on. The carpeting was super dirty. Stains all over the place. For what this place charges a night, everything should be in working order and there should not be stains on the carpeting. For the price, we would not stay here again.

We have nothing but amazing things to stay at this property. We would encourage anyne to stay here. We are already thinking about booking another vacation next year and staying there!!!

Nice place with excellent hostesses. Daily breakfast was a great spread and well stocked. Rooms were quiet and spacious.

There was a soda, big refrigerator, table and fireplace in the room along with a comfortable bed. The massage with Lynn was great. Hiking on the grounds. Great Breakfast. Lovely people.

Liked being able to get fresh towels every day and not have someone in our room. Wish there had been fresh fruit at breakfast. Very nice and quiet; loved the fireplace in our room. Staff were all very nice.

Clothes left in room from previous tenant. No one on duty when we checked in. Window crank broken. Breakfast items not available when I went down.

Great place

Our stay was great. It did have some hiccups, but were addressed quickly and efficiently. We have stayed here before, so we knew what to expect. In fact, they've been providing a friendly, warm for the past 30 years. Handicapped parking is available by the doors.

The only negative is that we could hear the people in the next room talking. Walls are not very sound proof

Thought the bathroom floor could have been cleaner and baseboard really needed it, everything else was great. Maybe I’m too picky 😐

Older resort, but it has a homey feeling to it. Owners are very active with this property. Staff excellent.

Sweet older hotel but kept up and in great shape. Beautiful room with fireplace and kitchenette. Couch and chair so lounging space was nice. Nice size bathroom and large closets. Staff was friendly and the place was so clean. Nice place to sit outside for breakfast and had other outdoor spaces. We didn’t venture to the pool area but based on how well maintained the grounds were I am sure it was great. Great location to see lots of Door County.

Nice room

Beautiful, charming hotel that we loved staying at. Rooms were comfortable and quite large, location was great, staff was all super friendly. This is a hidden gem. Highly recommend.

The Settlement Inn was very quaint, quiet, peaceful, and clean! The only downfall was our TV didn’t work well, which we didn’t use it much but also would have been nice to have it working.

This was a very nice hotel. We had a two bedroom suite with livingroom/ kitchen area. Very nice to have. Very pretty grounds and pool. It could use a few updates but I still highly recommend it. Close to Fish Creek but not right in all the hubbub.... older hotel but really unique. Very nice people and very clean .

The property is really charming on the outside and in a nice location (vineyard/orchard across the street, a few little unique shops next door, 2-3 minutes drive to Fish Creek). The rooms are very dated, I think if the invested in some renovating, keep with the rustic look but a bit more modern it would be wonderful. The rooms have a bit of the old smell, not sure if it’s the carpeting. I do want to point out that everything was super clean and spotless.

I would stay here again. The only thing I would have liked is for them to serve some warm breakfast.

Very clean and quiet place to stay, beautiful property, a short 3 minute drive from downtown Fish Creek and away from the tourist noise! Large room with dining table and fire place. Only draw back: room is advertised and my booking receipt shows the room having 2 queen beds. They are not queen beds, they are double or full sized beds. It worked for us, but may not work for some people. It would have been nice if the business was upfront and honest saying you get full sized beds.

Nice place!

The 2-bedroom suite was Ok, but the second bedroom was tiny with a mattress that had seen better days. The continental breakfast was just serviceable; the only protein options were hard-boiled eggs and Jimmy Dean sandwiches.

We had an enjoyable stay at the Settlement. It's always very comfortable and has all we need to relax and feels like a home away from home. Good location and close to shops and Peninsula Players Theater and the beautiful Edgewood Orchard Galleries where we have been going for years.

Awesome stay

Pleasant stay

Nice location and friendly staff. Good price and continental breakfast. Only complaint is that the walls/floors are thin enough that we had a lower than normal noise level from our neighbors above us. Luckily they didn't stay up late, but pretty loud creaky floor above us.

Great location near Fish Creek, great room size, comfortable bed, love the Settlement Shops next door and Wed. Farmers Market there! But the room was dark! Dark burgandy paint, and very dim lights. It was hard to see and impossible to read in bed! When we moved to another room, the wall color was lighter and the lighting was much better!

Staff was super friendly. The room was really nice! I liked that there was a little kitchenette with plates and silverware.

Everything was Great ! Everyone was very friendly and helpful. We Loved the ambiance of the room and the sitting area and the outside areas! we will definitely come stay again!!!

The location of the property and size of the room was good. Pool was sparkling clean and had nice loungers. While cleanliness was not an issue, the building and rooms could really use some updating.

Very comfortable and homey. Not like normal hotels