The Mermaid & The Alligator - Adult Only

Everything! The hospitality was exceptional from the moment we arrived. They acknowledged our anniversary with a beautiful surprise, and the staff was amazing — warm, attentive and genuinely helpful. The location is 10/10. We could walk almost everywhere, and the complimentary bicycles were one of our favorite perks for exploring Key West. Breakfast was delicious, and we loved having coffee, water, sodas and snacks available throughout the day, plus their afternoon happy hour. They also provided a map and personalized recommendations based on what we wanted to experience. It felt intimate, thoughtful and authentically Key West. We would absolutely stay here again!

Nothing. We had a wonderful experience and would recommend it without hesitation.

Excellent staff and beautiful accommodations

Chickens on site were aggressive. Flying on outdoor tables during breakfast and taking our breakfast.

The landscaping and how it made you feel you were escaping reality

Nothing everything was top-tier

The outdoors natural beauty

The property was once beautiful, well maintained and happily welcoming by the owners/innkeepers. Since it was sold to a corporation, it is now run like one. What they call happy hour consists of cheap wine, 4 slices of cheap cheese, 4 slices of salami and cheap crackers from a dish. A few grapes as well. Truly an embarrassment! The breakfast offered, the same. This is no longer the upscale B&B we are used to visiting. It’s a real loss!