Almost an island in Cayuga Lake! Private & panoramic 650' of level lake frontage
About this house rental
Situated in Cayuga Lake, this attractive house for $1,042 per night is a fantastic choice for your next vacation. Come & enjoy our private retreat! Everyone who visits agrees that this spot is idyllic & incredibly unique. Right at the water's edge at the big bend in Cayuga Lake just north of Ithaca, The Point is located on 1.5 level acres & features unparalleled views, no cliffs/hillsides, & an incredibly rare 650 feet of Cayuga lake frontage. The 3 BR/1.5 Bath, 1700 sq ft fully-insulated 4-season cottage faces 270 degree lake views, plus a private cove at the back of the house that adds to the feeling of being on an island, right in the center of Cayuga Lake! The house is itself is an older (1970's) build, but has been furnished for comfort, and what makes this really special is the unparalleled location and grounds, shoreline, and views! The east shore location means fantastic sunset views, while the location of the south facing point with the lake angle means you also get sunrises! The best of both worlds! Please note that we do not ever rent outside of VRBO so our listing is verified. If you see this property advertised elsewhere, that listing is a scam. INTERIOR AMENITIES: * Window AC units in each bedroom * Well-equipped cook's kitchen: Gas stove, dual electric oven, refrigerator, microwave, dishwasher, toaster, 12-cup drip coffee maker with re-usable filter (paper filters not needed), French press, Moka pot, blender, hand-mixer, waffle-maker, standard pots/pans, dishes/tableware * ROKU TV for streaming (no cable service at the cottage), DVD player w/kid-friendly DVD library * Fantastic collection of family-friendly card & board games & puzzles * Desks for remote working and reliable internet/WiFi with internet speeds sufficient for streaming or remote meetings (Download Speed: 113Mbps, Upload Speed: 11 Mbps) * Professional interior cleaning between each rental with fresh, clean bed sheets & bath towels * Washer/dryer * Eco bonus: All electricity supplied to the property is 100% solar generated, purchased from a nearby solar farm! * Please note that interior fireplaces visible in photos are capped/not operational OUTDOOR AMENITIES: * Outdoor dining on the deck with an ambiance better than any local restaurant! * Panoramic, gorgeous, sunset views * Lakeshore firepits for small bonfires & roasting marshmallows * Weber propane barbecue * Huge, level lawn provides plenty of room for the kids to burn off energy, & they will also enjoy the playground structures at Myers Park, an easy 10 minute walk away * Hot Tub (PLEASE NOTE: the hot tub volume is small; it is optimal for 2 adults at a time, occupancy is limited by the need to avoid water overflow). Operates year-round * Watercraft: 2 adult 12’ sit-in recreational kayaks, 2 kid sit-on-top kayaks (kids 2 weeks away) or within 24 hours of reservation (check in date 2 weeks or less away) * Please note that our cancellation policies are date-specific and vary seasonally, with less flexibility in the very busy summer months. To ensure you see the correct policy for your dates of travel, make sure they are represented in your search. If you have concerns about the potential for last minute weather/illness impacting your travel, we do recommend looking into travel insurance! COMMENCEMENT EVENT BOOKINGS - 3 night minimum. Full refunds in the event of ceremony cancellation.
Amenities
Air conditioner
Pets allowed
Kitchen / Kitchenette
Internet / Wifi
Parking
Laundry
Balcony / Patio
Dishwasher
Hot Tub / Spa
TV
Garden
Family friendly
Map of Cayuga Lake, NY
Reviews
5/5.0
Outstanding(170 Reviews)
5.0
Great property, very quiet and private retreat from people.
5.0
The property is nice, and quaint. It was very quiet and peaceful, at least in Nov. With the Marinas I can imagine it may not be as such doing the season. We enjoyed the stay. The house is well equipped for cooking and staying in. The only complaint I would have is the electric heating system (baseboard) is a bit noisy kicking on and off and would disrupt sleep.
5.0
We really enjoyed our time. The house was wonderful and location was better than I expected. Would recommend.
5.0
We had a lovely stay. The house is so well organized and directions are posted in perfect spots so there’s no questions. Really loved that! Could not be a more idyllic spot, and the outdoors is also set up perfectly. Very beautiful and relaxing.
5.0
This is a wonderful cabin in a beautiful setting. The stay was extremely enjoyable and the property is clearly well taken care of by the owners. The listing and photos are accurate. The house was very well set up to start the stay. There was really nothing we needed that was not already there besides food. It was a fun cabin and we will be back.
5.0
Perfect long weekend for the family. Can't believe this place exists. Somehow open to the lake/marina on all sides yet at the same time incredibly private. We did not want to leave and still wish we were there. The grounds were great with the incredible views and peaceful lake/nature vibes. Inside was very comfy and appointed nicely. Couldn't ask for a better few days relaxation for all of us. Plus our 10-yr caught his first fish right off the dock - great memories! P.S. highly recommend Salt Point Brewing.
5.0
The location was amazing and on right on the lake. Plenty of space. The listing was accurate. We enjoyed our time!
5.0
This location is exactly as described. Almost an island of your own, the propery has everything needed to enjoy a secluded lakefront escape. The house is clean and well stocked with games, kayaks, canoes, firepits, and all that you could want if you choose to cook. We were able to use one of the boat companies that was suggested by the owner and had a boat delivered right to the house for our use. I highly recommend and look forward to an opportunity to return time and time again.
5.0
Perfect location to get to our son’s wedding in Stewart Park, Ithaca. Lovely house and property. Very comfortable.
5.0
The property was absolutely lovely. It was great to have access to the canoe, kayaks, and SUP. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay and absolutely would come back again.
5.0
This was a family vacation and it surpassed our expectations in every way. The location private,pristine and beautiful. The house Cosy, we’ll appointment and tastefully done. The hosts were very responsive. A perfect family vacation.
5.0
We had an amazing vacation in the Finger Lakes - primarily due to finding the perfect house/property. We loved the privacy, the ability to swim, kayak, and fish right from the house... without needing to walk up and down lots of steps like so many other lake houses in the area. We also appreciated the wide assortment of seemingly brand new games in the cabinets. The proximity to Ithaca was also a bonus as we went "into town" a few times to enjoy delicious meals. Thanks so much for a great stay! We hope to be back!
4.0
We loved the location being surrounded in so much lakefront. We also loved the amenities such as provided watercraft, the two docks, the hammocks, hot tub, swimming supplies and inside the house the fully equipped kitchen with quality kitchenware, heated towel rack, laundry room and two refrigerators. We enjoyed tying up the small boat we brought and traveling in and out via the nice and very convenient marina. Only reason not 5 star is we wish the deck was screened in because of the bugs getting in the house which is hard to avoid with this and any other lakefront location. Lovely home overall with great beds and bed linens, air conditioning in the bedrooms was just right.
5.0
Our family of four loved the house and location. We rented a pontoon from the marina, and just a short walk to the boat. We were worried about the marina "traffic", but it was completely quiet and not bothersome at all. The house was just as advertised, and we completely enjoyed our stay. The kayaks and SUP were thoroughly enjoyed by all the family, and was great to have the constant access to the boats. The best surprise of all was watching the minks work the shoreline everyday, what a fun delight!
5.0
Loved it
5.0
3 generations traveled from Indiana to stay at this property and were we impressed! Everything we could have wanted or needed in a place away from home was provided! (except food of course) The property has many signs, labels, and documents to explain how things work and what is available to you as a guest. It's worth reading them and exploring the house when you get settled in. We found all of the details very helpful. We had no problem with the drinking/ice water jug replacement. We learned from a local that the co-op near the Ithaca Farmer's Market will let you refill the jugs for 40 cents a gallon instead of the $7 per jug at Tops (grocery store). The sandwich shop down the highway is a quirky place, but they have amazing sandwiches. We were able to enjoy the beautiful yard, lake views, nearby park, and visit with our friends. We attended the Farmer's Market (great little event!), walked to Ithaca Falls, and made the drive around the lake (almost directly across the lake from the property) to Taughannock Falls. We had a wide range of mobility and stamina in the members of our group. If you're not sure about which gorge to traverse, Taughannock is stroller/wheelchair friendly and Ithaca Falls is an easy and short walk to an amazing falls. We traveled with my 3 children, all under 10, and they had just as much fun as my retired in-laws. I hope we're able to stay at this property again when we visit Ithaca in the future! Thank you for a very accommodating stay!
5.0
This place had everything! We could not have asked for better weather and the views of the Lake were stunning! There were 7 adults and we all had plenty of room! Kitchen was fully stocked! I wouldn’t change a thing!
5.0
Although our stay was short and the weather wasn't the greatest, the nice day we did have was amazing. The house is perfectly set up, very organized, and was perfect for our needs. The property is beautiful!! Water views out every window! Hope to be back again one day!
5.0
This property is excellent for a quiet and quaint getaway. It is very family friendly with a well stocked kitchen, good wifi, games and activities for indoors and outdoors. Beautiful walk on the marina and waterfront park with a big playground. The best use of the property would be in warmer weather and it is not meant for large groups with only 1 bathroom with tub/shower.
5.0
5th or 6th year for us. Losing track will be back again next year. That should tell you everything you need to know!
5.0
If I could give more stars in every category I would. It is such a special property in an incredible location. In addition, it’s such a comfortable home away from home. You’ll love your stay.
5.0
We really enjoyed our time here! Very comfortable, well cared for home with thoughtful touches throughout. Especially enjoyed watching all types of weather move across the lake.
2.0
Despite its truly unique location and beautiful lake views, we were so uncomfortable at The Point that we chose to forfeit the entire rental amount and find other accommodations. No one in our party wanted to stay. This is an older cabin which is somewhat “off the grid” as far as city services, so understandably there are some special considerations in caring for the property.
However, all of the rules and regulations, having already been spelled out in excruciating detail in the rental agreement, appear yet again in the “handbook” and on signs posted throughout the cabin. The interior is literally papered with notices at every turn. One can’t even see the refrigerator for the pages and pages of endless dos and don’ts.
Having been in the hospitality industry for many years, I can attest that none of this conveys a feeling of welcome. Though the owners seem very friendly and helpful, and the cabin is very clean and organized, all of the rules & regulations had us feeling more like caretakers than guests.
In addition, for the price being charged, it’s unreasonable that one has to purchase and haul 5 gallon jugs of water - this should be taken care of for guests. At least one of the fireplaces should be operational. Our hopes of a relaxing stay with friends around a cheerful fire unfortunately did not come true.
5.0
This was my second time staying and it was as lovely as I remember it. Location is perfect, kitchen is spacious and well stocked, and the furniture was comfortable. We both enjoyed the property and house, and also traveled to nearby wineries and hiking. Excellent location as a home base for exploring the finger lakes. You are very close to Ithaca and any amenity you can need, but also feel restfully private. After many visits to the finger lakes region, this was my first in the fall and it was spectacular. The lake and marina were exceptionally quiet and we enjoyed the wild life.
5.0
Enjoyed our quiet weekend in the finger lakes. Beautiful home in a great location.
5.0
I couldn't find a single thing to criticize with this property. From the well stocked kitchen, to great appliances. The owners thought of everything...from the lake friendly toys in the utility room and the canoes and kayaks.
The living space was comfortable with plenty of comfortable seating even for a large group. The decor was very pleasant and well done. I loved that there was a towel warmer in the bathroom, made for nice warm and dry towels each day.
The most important thing to me is that the bed was comfortable. So many times I've stayed at lovely homes and the beds have been simply horrible. Definitely not the case here, we both slept well the entire week we were there. Other owners should take a note that the beds are as (if not more) important as the rest of the house.
I can't say enough about this property, the wild life, the views, the sunsets, the fire by the lake...all made for a wonderful time. Our whole family was supposed to join, but thanks to illness we got the whole house to ourselves and enjoyed it immensely.
5.0
Great place in a very private setting. Water all around with gorgeous views of sunrise and sunset. Clean a very well stocked home for families. We enjoyed visiting wineries around Cayuga and simply sitting on the dock enjoying the views. Quick ride into Ithaca too. Highly recommend it.
5.0
We had a great time here. It really did feel like we were on our own little island. The house itself was very comfortable and cozy, we had great views of the lake itself, and the owners were very kind and easy to work with. Would definitely recommend, especially since we already booked a return trip.
5.0
One of the very best properties we have ever entered. The only flaw was having to drive through the pothole ridden Marina. But after we made it onto the property - WOW! We were completely blown away. The place is beautifully maintained and has the most well stocked kitchen I have ever seen!!! Whoever decorated this house is genius, such beautiful and interesting furnishings. Stunning views, feels totally private. Loved all of the birds and other wildlife, even saw deer a couple of mornings. Would love to return, and highly recommend.
5.0
We recently stayed at The Point and had the most wonderful time. You just can’t beat the views from this amazing spot on Lake Cayuga. Whether sitting inside the house looking out the large living room or kitchen windows, or out on the large deck, the view of the lake was so relaxing. And at night sitting in the Jacuzzi looking at the stars or lights of Ithaca off in the distance was magical. The house was clean, comfortable and nicely decorated. It was nice to have the market and gas station just minutes away. Ithaca was maybe a 10 minute drive to lots of restaurants and shopping. And the hiking…so many great trails and waterfalls close by. We had everything we needed for a fantastic time. We can’t wait to go back again.
5.0
This is truly a special property! Panoramic water views, privacy and a well equipped, cozy home made this a perfect jumping off point for a lake and land adventure. Our pups absolutely loved exploring and chasing each other around the huge yard while we could relax in the water or in the hot tub. Gorgeous sunsets and ideal bass boat docking conditions due to the extremely well protected cove out back. All around an amazing vacation and we owe it all to this amazing location!
5.0
We had a wonderful week at the point! The owners have gone above and beyond to make your stay here as easy as possible. Everything is labeled and all possible questions answered. Beds are super comfortable. The grounds are truly unique and special. The lake is crystal clear. But you do need water shoes for the rocks and zebra mussels. We truly had an amazing week!
5.0
This house was the perfect stay for the 6 of us. The house had everything we needed. It’s a large property with privacy. Back dock worked well for us. Yes I would recommend.
5.0
Best location on the lake for peace and quiet
It's like your own private island. I grew up in the area and was familiar with the property, and it did not disappoint. Owners have made nice upgrades. Will definitely be a return guest.
5.0
Privacy
Great and unique location. You do have privacy with no neighbors, yet it is not far away from Wegmans, restaurants, the Commons, and the colleges. A big plus is that there are no stairs to go down to the lake. The house has everything you would need, both inside and outside. Everything is clearly labeled in the house, which is very helpful. The hosts are very nice and have always gotten back to me very quickly. I would highly recommend this house and these hosts!
5.0
Lovely lake vacation spot
This private location on Cayuga lake is ideal for relaxing, taking in the panoramic lake views, and living very comfortably! We spent our days here outdoors - there is lake access,( kayaks available,) expansive lawns and a large deck with comfortable furniture and a grill. Our dogs loved it, too! The house is has a well-equipped kitchen, comfortable beds, and a wonderful living room with a large leather sectional that has lots of room for everyone. There are many locations close by for fishing, and great hiking as well. We went out for many excellent meals, both very close-by in Lansing and in Ithaca . Very highly recommended.
5.0
This amazingly situated home on the lake is extremely comfortable, offers beautiful views, and endless activities. This very private setting is quiet but close to the towns of the area. Perfect getaway.
5.0
Beautiful property
This amazingly situated home on the lake is extremely comfortable, offers beautiful views, and endless activities. This very private setting is quiet but close to the towns of the area. Perfect getaway.
5.0
Excellent location on lake and easy access to stores and other amenities.
5.0
Cayuga Lake stay
Excellent location on lake and easy access to stores and other amenities.
FAQs
How much does this house cost compared to others in Cayuga Lake?
The average price for a rental in Cayuga Lake is $517 per night. This rental is $525 above the average.
Is parking included with this house?
Yes, parking is listed as an amenity at Almost an island in Cayuga Lake! Private & panoramic 650' of level lake frontage. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.
Is there a pool at this house?
We didn’t find pool listed as an amenity for this house. It may be worth double checking if a pool is important for your stay.
Is Almost an island in Cayuga Lake! Private & panoramic 650' of level lake frontage pet friendly?
Yes! This house is pet-friendly. For more information, we recommend contacting the booking provider about animal policies.
What amenities are available at Almost an island in Cayuga Lake! Private & panoramic 650' of level lake frontage?
We found 12 amenities for this rental. This includes air conditioner, pets allowed, kitchen / kitchenette, internet / wifi, and parking.
Explore similar vacation rentals in Cayuga Lake
Explore all rentals in Cayuga LakeCayuga Lake travel inspiration
Read our blogGuides
Ski Trip Packing List: What to Bring Skiing or Snowboarding
Trends
VacationRenter Holiday Travel Trends 2023
Featured Rentals
Architectural Vacation Rentals: Experience the Beauty of Unique Properties
Featured Rentals
Sustainable and Eco-Friendly Vacation Rentals Around the World
Featured Rentals
Our Favorite Vacation Rentals With Unique Experiences
Featured Rentals
Amazing Cabin Rentals Across the Globe
Featured Rentals
Have You Ever Wanted to Stay in a Dome Rental? Now You Can
Featured Rentals
Jaw Dropping Treehouse Rentals All Over the World