There are 3 cottages on this property. We stayed in the middle one. The only good thing about this property is the beach/waterfront. Otherwise it reminded me of living in a college apartment. Thick dust on all of the ceiling fans/light fixtures. Stains on towels and bedspread. Couch sags/very uncomfortable. And the pull-out mattress was horrible. Even when placed on the floor. Bathroom ceiling fan rattles. Other bathroom has plywood for flooring. We are all sore from a week spent in uncomfortable beds with no comfortable chairs either. We spent as little time as possible inside the cottage. That said, we enjoyed the kayaks around the mangroves and time at the little beach. We didn’t have a boat but the boat slip looked to be in good condition with a nice deck as well as a covered pavilion nearby. We chose to stay here to save some $ by cooking our own meals. Kitchen was barely functional-again, like a college apartment in regards to pots/pans/knives/utensils/dishes. The dishwasher works but tries to tip forward. I would not stay here again despite the location.

A beautiful, little beach with only three cottages made for a perfect family getaway. We felt like we had our own little island in the old Florida Keys. Authentic, beachy, unpretentious. Just what we wanted and needed.

While the house is in need of a few cosmetic updates, it was clean and comfortable. The kayaks are all in need of repair, but we didn't use them much anyway. The island itself...totally worth it. Little Conch island is beautiful, quiet and very biologically diverse. We were lucky enough to have the island to ourselves for a few days and it was Paradise. If you're a lover of nature and peaceful quiet, this is the place.

The location was great as were the water amenities. The view and the location were great. The house left a little to be desired. We had roaches and ants on different occasions. And the maintenance needs upgrades, the hall bathroom floor sags and the deck boards are a trip hazard.

We stayed there 6 nights and had the whole property to ourselfs for the first 2 nights. Great location as it was only about a 5 minute drive into Marathon, 20 minute drive to Islamorada, and a little under an hour to Key West. Nice pool, nice little private beach area, and boat ramp/dock. The house was older and needs a little tlc but all in all it was clean and everything worked as it should and had everything we needed except toilet paper. We had a great time staying there and would definately stay there again.

Looked great in pics, toilets plugged, no hot shower in 2nd bathroom, 2 huge cockroaches cause the doors wouldnt close rite and wouldnt lock, stairs unsafe, no porch light and husband fell going down stairs at night, pool was green when we arrived, pool side had no umbrella, private beach was trashed out. Only thing that worked rite was the air conditioning thankfully Was not worth what I paid!!

We wouldn’t be able to stay again. These would be our must haves… sun blocking window treatments, morning sun made it unbearable. Need a bedroom TV, need dresser or shelves in bedroom/closet for clothes, need some bathroom storage/shelves, need a light under unit to BBQ. It would also be nice if the place was a bit more cared for… pool was not well cared for. Under units and beach are very cluttered. We have a long history of staying at Conch Key Cottages. We feel terrible we can no longer feel comfortable there.

This property was just as listed and expected. The owner was extremely responsive and timely with all communication. The location is great as it’s a midpoint between the keys. The beach area was great for the kids to play on the sand and wade in the water. We also took advantage of the kayaks and paddleboards, it was great that life vests were available for the kids. The pool was perfectly refreshing. The kitchen was furnished with plenty of utensils/dishes/silverware and even coffee! There were enough soaps/shampoo for our 3 night stay. Check-in and out couldn’t be easier