Elegant New House on One Level, 6 bdrms & 6 baths ~ Hot Tub ~ Firepit & Wineries

Outdoor spa tub
6 bedrooms, WiFi, bed sheets, wheelchair access
TV, stereo
Fridge, microwave, oven, stovetop
Combined shower/tub, hair dryer, towels

About this house rental

Welcome to “Indulgence”! We spent over two years transforming this former hay barn into an exquisite 6-bedroom, 6-bath vacation rental for up to 12 guests. You’d never know from the original art, sweeping 9 and10-foot ceilings, artfully designed kitchen and marble-tiled bathrooms that cows once called “Indulgence” home! Wake up in an ultra-comfortable Queen or King bed. Brew a cup of coffee on the Keurig and head out to an Adirondack chair on the sweeping back deck to watch the sunrise over the natural pond. Spend the day exploring this exquisite area: wine tours, waterfalls, delicious farm-to-table food and much more are at your fingertips. Then come home to your restful retreat to make dinner in the gourmet kitchen and soak in the 7-person hot tub with one last glass of wine. Indulgence is perfect for larger group getaways, from organizations or families to hobby groups and wine trips. Our long-range plan is to also use the space to host pre-apprenticeship training for those interested in a career in the trades, which sorely need new talent. HIGHLIGHTS 5 bedrooms suites + additional Queen bedroom with office - all with blackout curtains for sleeping in. 6 full bathrooms All on one level with barrier-free showers + no stairs anywhere on the property 7-person hot tub on the deck Gorgeous views of rolling countryside, including a natural pond Chef’s kitchen with SubZero fridge and Bertazzoni gas range Natural pond with dock (pond is swimmable if conditions permit) Intimate Library with comfy armchairs, perfect for curling up and conversations with your favorite people “Rec room” with 65” flat-screen smart TV, wet bar, billiards table and game table Individual HVAC systems in each bedroom Plenty of parking for up to eight vehicles Less than 10 minutes from downtown Ithaca WiFi throughout BEDROOMS Indulgence features 5 bedroom suites, each with a Queen or King bed and an attached bath with a custom, spacious barrier-free shower. Two more guests can sleep on the Queen-size bedroom with an office area and use the additional full bath (with a soaker tub/shower combo) in the hallway. Everyone will get a good night’s sleep: the mattresses vary in firmness levels to suit different preferences, and each bedroom has its own mini-split system with individual temperature control. This rental is all on one level—no stairs—and works well for guests with limited mobility. LIVING & DINING On rainy days (or just lazy ones), choose from various hangout spots. The open living area features the original siding from the barn on it's ceiling, comfy sofas and chairs, views of the pond through many windows, and a pair of stunning art deco paintings. Access the back deck, picnic tables and hot tub through glass doors in this space. Grab a book from the Library and settle into one of the cozy armchairs. Or uncork some wine and chat with your friends—the armchairs are arranged in a circle for easy conversation that will likely outlast the wine. (This spot is my personal favorite and guests love it, too!) At the back of the home is the Rec Room. Send kids and husbands here if you need some peace and quiet! This roomy space features a 65” Smart flat-screen, a pool table, a wet bar, a game table for 6, many games and access to the outside. The kitchen is a masterpiece with marble counters, industrial-sized 48" fridge/freezer, and double ovens, including a Bertazzoni gas range. The center island with barstools is great for hors d'oeuvres before dinner. When the meal is ready, the 12-person dining area under 10-foot ceilings is a formal-yet-comfy place to dig in. Or head outside to the picnic tables on the deck for an al fresco dinner. Our future plan is to host pre-apprenticeship training for those looking to begin a career in the building trades. In the meantime, we’re excited to host groups of all kinds, from organizations to families. THE LOCATION Indulgence is set on 8+ acres in the Ithaca countryside, with only one other house in sight—our second vacation rental, Shangri-Lodge, which sleeps 13 people and can be rented in addition to this one (depending on availability). But don’t let the quiet fool you. You are just minutes from the center of the action. Drive 5 minutes to downtown Ithaca, where you’ll find more restaurants per-capita than in NYC! Not to mention tasting rooms, pubs, greasy spoon diners, cocktail lounges, cafes and much more. Then, of course, there’s all the indulgences that this fertile growing region has to offer. Wine trails. Cider trails. Cheese trails. You can even hire a company to drive your own car from winery to winery—there are dozens of them to choose from! Cayuga Wine Trail, the oldest wine trail in the country, is a 10-minute drive from Indulgence. The nearest winery, Bet The Farm is merely 4 miles away. Nature lovers are in their element here. Just minutes away is Taughannock Falls, a spectacular waterfall you can hike to (or view from the parking area). It is also the beginning of the Black Diamond Trail, and 8 mile long gravel trail that will take you down to Cass Park in Ithaca. Buttermilk Falls State Park, just 10-15 minutes away, features dozens of cascading waterfalls and miles of trails to explore, as does Robert Treman State Park. Watkins Glen is about a half hour away; hike the State Park trails through scenic gorges, or lounge on the shores of Seneca Lake. Cayuga Lake—the longest of the Finger Lakes—is also just a few minutes’ drive away. NOTE: Not suitable for large weddings, receptions, parties or gatherings which include outside guests. Property is for the use and enjoyment of registered guests only, unless prior approval from owners is given.

Amenities

Air conditioner
Kitchen / Kitchenette
Internet / Wifi
Parking
Laundry
Dishwasher
TV
Wheelchair accessible
Family friendly

Map of Cayuga Lake, NY

House in Cayuga Lake, NY


Reasons to book

People love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Includes essentialsKitchen / Kitchenette, Air conditioner, Internet / Wifi and more
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental

$$$$

Reviews

5.0/5.0
Outstanding(13 Reviews)
5.0
Jan 2024
Our stay was perfect. This was our 2nd time at this beautiful home and everyone wants to come back. They are wonderful to deal with, very responsive to any and all questions. The house was super clean and very well appointed. Anything you need or want is there. Highly recommend staying here with your family/friends. Looking forward to another stay in the future.
5.0
Dec 2023
My family had a wonderful time at Indulgence! The space, the decor, the atmosphere were all stunning. The property is serene and peaceful. We have a big, growing family and we were perfectly accommodated for our holiday during our stay. The house was fully stocked and equipped with all we needed for our Thanksgiving feast! Mitch was a warm, responsive and accommodating host. We are already talking about another stay during the summer! 10 out of 10!
5.0
Nov 2023
The house exceeded our expectations! It was absolutely gorgeous and we were blown away by the extraordinary design and details that were put into it. It was immaculately clean and had everything we needed. We had a lovely weekend and would most definitely return.
5.0
Oct 2023
Our group of 11 had a wonderful long weekend stay! The house was gorgeous with plenty of space for everyone. The owners were extremely accommodating and easy to talk with. We had all we needed and then some. Fantastic!
5.0
Oct 2023
Our stay was wonderful! The home is absolutely beautiful! Nothing bad to say about it. A couple more TV’s would be nice.
5.0
Jul 2023
Beautiful home, impeccably clean. Kitchen was very well stocked, as was the entire home, with multiple games provided by our hosts who seem to have thought of everything. KC and Mitch were pleasant; KC went out of her way to help when one of our group forgot their passports, she accepted the express package at their home and delivered the package personally. The house was completely out of water at 10:00pm on the evening before our departure, with two of the toilets making a high pitched sound. We left messages but were unable to reach KC or Mitch. Fortunately water was fully restored by the next morning. Overall we really enjoyed our stay and would consider returning.
5.0
Jun 2023
Excellent and super responsive hosts. Single level great for disabled person in party. Great large kitchen. Plenty of space for children to play and adults to relax. Minutes to Ithaca but definitely felt rural with working farm next door and plenty of bird song. Only significant issue was first well got low but landlord quickly came over to hook up to second well. Great communications before during and end if stay.
5.0
May 2023
We stayed in this home for Ithaca College graduation weekend. We had a lovely time at this vacation rental. The home and setting was lovely. Beds were comfortable, the kitchen well-stocked and the game room was so much fun! The hosts are communicative and so helpful. One of the nicest, more thoughtfully decorated and supplied homes we have stayed in. Thank you so much for a wonderful stay! Everything was perfect.

FAQs

How much does this house cost compared to others in Cayuga Lake?

The average price for a rental in Cayuga Lake is $527 per night. This rental is $979 above the average.

Is parking included with this house?

Yes, parking is listed as an amenity at Elegant New House on One Level, 6 bdrms & 6 baths ~ Hot Tub ~ Firepit & Wineries. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.

Is there a pool at this house?

We didn’t find pool listed as an amenity for this house. It may be worth double checking if a pool is important for your stay.

Is Elegant New House on One Level, 6 bdrms & 6 baths ~ Hot Tub ~ Firepit & Wineries pet friendly?

Unfortunately, this house is not pet-friendly. Try searching again and filter for "Pets Allowed"

What amenities are available at Elegant New House on One Level, 6 bdrms & 6 baths ~ Hot Tub ~ Firepit & Wineries?

We found 9 amenities for this rental. This includes air conditioner, kitchen / kitchenette, internet / wifi, parking, and laundry.

Cayuga Lake travel inspiration

Read our blog