Charming Montauk Beach House off East Lake Drive - Sunset and Water Views
About this house rental
Please Note - A reservation for this property must be approved before it is confirmed Charming Montauk beach house off East Lake Drive. 2 week minimum stay required during July and August. Rentals will be to family groups only (Town of East Hampton Code 255-11-62 prohibits rentals to groups of unrelated adults) The house is set back from the street, with a southwest exposure to enjoy sunset and water views. Our neighborhood is bordered by county and state park woods and beaches. Hiking trails and undeveloped beaches run all the way to Montauk Point. Directions are easy! Drive all the way to the end of Long Island, past the town of Montauk, and take the very last left where the sign says “Outer Beach” The house was built in 2002, with upgrades in 2019 and 2020. Post Modern traditional with cedar shingles, wide plank wood floors, high ceilings, and full length windows for maximum light. It has 4 bedrooms, 2 1/2 baths and comfortably sleeps 10. The Kitchen / Living room with cathedral ceilings opens thru French doors to front deck with water and sunset views. There is a full covered porch with separate seating below. There is an additional grilling deck (extra large grill) thru French doors off kitchen - all designed to prepare large meals for an extended family. An additional Sub Zero fridge was built into the island for beverages. Granite kitchen countertops, marble tops in baths. Large outdoor shower and dressing area. The house is an ‘upside down’ layout as the second floor has the best views. Kitchen/Living Area and half bath are on the second floor. Bedrooms and two full baths are on the first floor. Bedroom Configuration- Large Master Bedroom: king bed, walk-in closet, updated master bath with jacuzzi tub, TV Large Guest Bedroom: 2 queen beds, large closet. TV Large guest bath across hall with heavy duty washer and dryer Bedroom 1: full with additional pullout, TV Bedroom 2: 2 twins with additional pullout, TV A 3 minute drive to either ocean or bay beaches, and a few minutes to the Ranch and Montauk Point Lighthouse. This property comes with private access to Lake Montauk / Montauk Harbor (with kayaks!) Surfing, fishing, hiking, horseback riding, biking, swimming, sailing, kayaking, paddle boarding, wildlife/migratory bird watching/photography are just a few of the featured activities. Price includes premium cable and WiFi, propane, professional landscaping, all linens Comes with use of kayaks, beach chairs, umbrellas, bicycles On-site viewings can be arranged for serious longer-term inquiry. Town of East Hampton Rental Registry Permit: 18-1667 All bookings subject to signing of a standard short term rental lease.
Amenities
Air conditioner
Kitchen / Kitchenette
Internet / Wifi
Fireplace
Parking
Laundry
Balcony / Patio
Dishwasher
TV
Garden
Family friendly
Map of Montauk, NY
House in Montauk, NY
Reasons to book
People love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Includes essentialsGarden, Kitchen / Kitchenette, Air conditioner and more
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
RRRR
Reviews
5.0/5.0
Outstanding(22 Reviews)
5.0
went there for my brothers daughters wedding my family plus my new granddaughter. perfect fit for us Wedding was at Monack down on west lake drive . place was clean and easy thank you
5.0
We have been renting in Montauk for over 15 years. This property was, by far, our best experience. Absolutely everything was perfect! The house was spacious, incredibly clean, beautifully furnished and in the perfect neighborhood. We enjoyed each and every minute of our stay! Would highly recommend this property!
5.0
My wife and I stayed at this lovely home for two weeks with our son and a few friends. The home is charming, bright and airy, immaculately clean, beautifully decorated, and very comfortable, with a modern fully-stocked kitchen and great bathrooms. We spent a lot of time on the the two large decks (upper and lower) which have comfy furniture. The property is very well maintained, and it's in a lovely neighborhood very close to Lake Montauk. Our hosts were extremely welcoming and helpful. We hope to return next year (we wish we could return next week!).
5.0
East Lake Drive
Nuala and John were amazing to work with, they could not have been more cooperative and communicative when needed.
We hope to return soon!
5.0
Wonderful Lake View House
My family and I recently returned from a wonderful Thanksgiving vacation in this beautiful house. The home was equipped with everything you could possibly need. The views are incredible and John and Nuala are the perfect hosts, answering any questions we had immediately. We are hoping to return in the future!
5.0
Our family of 5 rented Nuala and John’s home in Montauk and we had a wonderful time. Their home is beautiful and we loved every minute of our stay. As hosts they were easy to contact, responded right away and were very helpful. It was a pleasure to rent with them and we hope to again! The location is perfect and the house impeccable.
5.0
Wonderful Experience
Our family of 5 rented Nuala and John’s home in Montauk and we had a wonderful time. Their home is beautiful and we loved every minute of our stay. As hosts they were easy to contact, responded right away and were very helpful. It was a pleasure to rent with them and we hope to again! The location is perfect and the house impeccable.
5.0
Great Escape
Had the best time staying here. The house is in a wonderful spot with a beautiful view of Lake Montauk and a quick drive to town and not far from the Montauk lighthouse for good hiking trails. The house is spacious, comfortable, thoughtfully designed and has everything you could possibly need for vacation. John and Nuala were wonderful, thoughtful and attentive hosts. My favorite was the outdoor shower and enjoying wine on the deck with friends watching the sunset. I feel rested and refreshed after spending five days here - a great escape from the city and perfect set up for reconnecting with family and old friends. We will be back!
5.0
Fantastic House, Great Location
The house was spotless and the location was great! The kitchen was well stocked with everything that we needed to cook all our meals and the basement had the most "beach toys" we've seen for a rental! Any concerns we had were quickly remedied by great communication from John and Nuala. Great house, great hosts.
5.0
As advertised. Excellent communication. Well stocked with amenities. Good kitchen. Lots of beach toys we didn't use because of the season but would be attractive in the summer. Well located.
5.0
family getaway
As advertised. Excellent communication. Well stocked with amenities. Good kitchen. Lots of beach toys we didn't use because of the season but would be attractive in the summer. Well located.
5.0
From the get go, John and Nuala were extremely responsive and welcoming re their property and acting as a resource for any and everything Montauk. The pictures don't do it justice and we highly recommend the home for anything from a quiet getaway to a friends trip! We'll definitely be recommending to our friends and will be back when we return to MTK!
5.0
Such a great time in Montauk!
From the get go, John and Nuala were extremely responsive and welcoming re their property and acting as a resource for any and everything Montauk. The pictures don't do it justice and we highly recommend the home for anything from a quiet getaway to a friends trip! We'll definitely be recommending to our friends and will be back when we return to MTK!
5.0
An Amazing House for Thanksgiving, and a Wonderful Rental Experience
We were looking for a warm, cozy, and comfortable home on the South Fork of Long Island where the four of us - me, my wife, my 9-year old daughter, and my mom - could enjoy a restful and safe holiday week. John and Nuala's home in Montauk was the perfect fit! The house is well-situated in a quiet and scenic area across from Lake Montauk and only minutes from shops, restaurants, and beaches. Everything was incredibly clean and well-prepared for our arrival. I had mentioned that we would be cooking a turkey breast and some pies on Thanksgiving, and the owners had placed a aluminum roasting pan and two pie plates in the oven for us! The kitchen is modern and well-equipped, and we all enjoyed cooking and, for the adults, enjoying wine and cocktails with spectacular nightly views of the sunset. We loved everything about the house - every room is warmly and comfortably furnished, and the grounds are lovely and nicely landscaped. The extra bonus was the warm and welcoming hospitality shown to us by owners John and Nuala. John even stopped by shortly after our arrival to see if we needed anything, or had any questions. We are so very grateful to have found this home and these gracious hosts for our holiday week!
5.0
Great house in a great location! Johan and Nuala were also very attentive - thank you!
5.0
Montauk
Great house in a great location! Johan and Nuala were also very attentive - thank you!
5.0
This Montauk trip was a combination of birthday celebrations and graduation from fellowships for my daughter and her husband. it was amtrying year for everybody and we were grateful to have a chance to get together.John and Nuala's place is a gem. Perfect location for us, be it beaching, golfing, dining out or eating in. Their house is in close proximity to everything and is fully stocked. They are also on top of everything when we needed information or last minute help.Thanks again for an amazing time in Montauk, John and Nuala.We will definitely be back again.
5.0
Family reunion/birthday/graduation
This Montauk trip was a combination of birthday celebrations and graduation from fellowships for my daughter and her husband.
it was amtrying year for everybody and we were grateful to have a chance to get together.
John and Nuala's place is a gem. Perfect location for us, be it beaching, golfing, dining out or eating in. Their house is in close proximity to everything and is fully stocked. They are also on top of everything when we needed information or last minute help.
Thanks again for an amazing time in Montauk, John and Nuala.
We will definitely be back again.
5.0
Wonderful Escape in Montauk
We had an incredible week at John and Nuala’s beautiful home in Montauk. The house is very well stocked and equipped to explore activities both on the property and throughout Montauk. My group of four worked remotely from the house comfortably throughout the week, with high speed WiFi and lots of space in the house and on the two patios. Everything really exceeded our expectations. John and Nuala are also great hosts - attentive and very helpful while not overbearing.
5.0
Montauk Get Away
My family thoroughly enjoyed our stay. The house was immaculate and John and Nuala were extremely hospitable. I would definitely recommend this house!
5.0
Amazing weekend!
We had the best weekend in Montauk at this amazing home. Nuala and John were very accommodating and went above and beyond to make sure we were comfortable and the house was immaculate. I’d definitely rent this property again!
5.0
Fantastic Trip
House better than advertised with an amazing location and great hosts. Recommend to any family looking for a relaxing and enjoyable stay. Comfortably sleeps 8-9 and a short distance from all that Montauk has to offer. Couldn’t have enjoyed it more.
5.0
Wonderful stay
My family visited the house for a week and we enjoyed every moment. The location is perfect. A quick drive past the town of Montauk which makes it easy to access food, the supermarket, and local attractions like various beaches and the lighthouse. The houses in this neighborhood are beautiful and pulling up to our rental, my family could not be more excited. The house has a long driveway with lush landscape leading to a beautiful front porch with outdoor furniture (cushions, pillows, and end tables) looking over the property. Upon entry, every bedroom was pristine, clean and furnished in a relaxing beachy vibe. The master bedroom has large windows and double French doors overlooking the property. The master bath was renovated with a great shower and vanity. I felt instantly at home. The other bedrooms were adorable and my children enjoyed them. One room with two double beds and another room with two full beds. Each bedroom had lovely bedding and were welcoming- the windows brought in lots of light and it had a very airy feel. This floor also has a large guest bath with a huge washer/dryer, perfect for throwing in lots of laundry and getting it done quick. Upstairs is the best part. Large French doors lead to an incredible upper deck with lounge chairs and a long dining table with chairs. This is where I enjoyed many cocktails while watching the beautiful sunset. The views of the water were also a highlight and it was so nice to not have to leave the house to take in the beauty of Montauk - it was all right there. The upper floor also has an open kitchen, dining room, and den. It’s renovated, clean, and wonderful in every respect (plenty of cooking utensils, glasses for any and every beverage, utensils, and kitchenware beyond...) the granite island has an additional refrigerated area as a fun added bonus. There is also a smaller back patio on this level which overlooks a lush green landscape. The owners could not be more helpful. They wanted to make sure my stay was as comfortable as possible and they were so accommodating. I will absolutely be staying here again.
5.0
Beautiful Montauk Home
The owners of the house go above and beyond to ensure the house is perfectly set up for your trip. The house was better then our expectations and we felt perfectly at home during our entire trip. Great open deck with views of lake Montauk, speakers, kayaks, bikes - house has everything you need for a great trip. Highly recommend.
5.0
Great house and a great location!
We had a great weekend stay here. The house is just outside of town where it's super easy to drive/uber in but still on a quiet block to enjoy the beautiful views in peace. The house was beautiful with multiple decks and a perfect open floor plan for everyone to hang out. We loved it!!!
5.0
Great House.
Beautiful and well decorated house. Comes with everything you might need for a beach vacation. Great view from deck. We had a wonderful time.
5.0
AMAZING!
This was a great place to stay and I would stay here again a million times over. It was just like the photos, very cute and clean. We had a large group of colleagues staying here and it was very comfortable. John + Nuala were great and promptly replied to any issues. I highly recommend staying here. Super close to town also.
FAQs
How much does this house cost compared to others in Montauk?
The average price for a rental in Montauk is R 17,914 per night. This rental is R 357 above the average.
Is parking included with this house?
Yes, parking is listed as an amenity at Charming Montauk Beach House off East Lake Drive - Sunset and Water Views. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.
Is there a pool at this house?
We didn’t find pool listed as an amenity for this house. It may be worth double checking if a pool is important for your stay.
Is Charming Montauk Beach House off East Lake Drive - Sunset and Water Views pet friendly?
Unfortunately, this house is not pet-friendly. Try searching again and filter for "Pets Allowed"
What amenities are available at Charming Montauk Beach House off East Lake Drive - Sunset and Water Views?
We found 11 amenities for this rental. This includes air conditioner, kitchen / kitchenette, internet / wifi, fireplace, and parking.
Montauk travel inspiration
Read our blogGuides
Hit the Beach at These 10 Charming Surf Towns in the Northeast U.S.
Guides
25 Best Family Beach Vacations in the U.S.
Guides
40 Most Iconic East Coast Lighthouses