This home was more than we could ask for! It was clean, well-stocked and had a beautiful outdoor living area. The pool was perfect after long days at the beach. We will definitely be back!

Photos of property are accurate. The kitchen is well stocked and had everything needed to make big family dinners. The outside area and pool were perfect and there was great access to the beach.

Our stay at Peace of Paradise was exactly that - Paradise! The house was clean and well equipped with everything we needed. There were plenty of towels for swimming and showering. Our kids loved the triple bunk room. Plenty of space for our family of 8 to spread out in. The pool area had a very tropical feel with beautiful landscaping. The area is surrounded by trees, making for the perfect amount of privacy for our family. (Highly recommend bug spray!!) The waterfall rock feature into the pool made for a relaxing feel. The 2 golf carts were amazing, and probably our favorite part of our stay. We enjoyed many rides around the island just exploring all the beauty North Captiva has to offer. We did have 2 minor issues with one of our golf carts, but the owner Molly promptly had it serviced, and we were back on the road within hours. (Shout out to Derrick at Pieces of Eight Golf Cart Repair for taking care of us so quickly and professionally). Our experience with Tortuga Properties was good. They assisted us throughout the entire process and efficiently supplied us with anything we needed. We would absolutely recommend Peace of Paradise to anyone looking for a fun, relaxing family vacation on the island. We hope to come back very soon and enjoy it all over again! Thanks again Molly for renting your beautiful home to us. We made memories that will last a lifetime! - Brian & Julie Martin

Great house with lots of amenities. The reverse osmosis drinking water was great. Kitchen, patio, pool were all well furnished and easy and fun to use. It's a beautiful house. Only two drawbacks we found: beach is probably a 10 minute walk but if you're bringing cooler/umbrellas/etc, you need a golf cart... for the price we thought we'd be closer to the beach. Also the walls are thin :)

Great house with lots of amenities. The reverse osmosis drinking water was great. Kitchen, patio, pool were all well furnished and easy and fun to use. It's a beautiful house. Only two drawbacks we found: beach is probably a 10 minute walk but if you're bringing cooler/umbrellas/etc, you need a golf cart... for the price we thought we'd be closer to the beach. Also the walls are thin :)

Peace of Paradise is just that. It is a peaceful, idyllic getaway that allows you rest and relaxation or fun and adventure if you want it. We had a family of 8 (5 adults and 3 kids aged 6 to 11) and it was the perfect size with 4 bedrooms. The house was well equipped and had plenty of spreading out space. The pool was beautiful and always warm. The views from the deck were wonderful and we still miss sitting there every monring to drink our coffee. We saw a lot of North Captiva, including the planes landing at the airstrip and lots of sunsets at the beach. We also took a trip to Cabbage Key, where we saw the Manatees very close up!! Lovely home and island.

Peace of Paradise is just that. It is a peaceful, idyllic getaway that allows you rest and relaxation or fun and adventure if you want it. We had a family of 8 (5 adults and 3 kids aged 6 to 11) and it was the perfect size with 4 bedrooms. The house was well equipped and had plenty of spreading out space. The pool was beautiful and always warm. The views from the deck were wonderful and we still miss sitting there every monring to drink our coffee. We saw a lot of North Captiva, including the planes landing at the airstrip and lots of sunsets at the beach. We also took a trip to Cabbage Key, where we saw the Manatees very close up!! Lovely home and island.

North Captiva is a special place, made all the more enjoyable by having such a lovely home to stay in and attentive property managers to assist you. Tortuga staff were waiting for us at the dock with a trailer for our luggage and groceries, and our two golf carts. We followed Duncan to the house and he pointed out a few areas of interest along the way. We needed nothing during our stay, but I am confident that Tortuga would have handled any issues with ease. They also arrived promptly for our departure. Island Girl Charters is a seamless operation as well. Don't fret about the groceries - you can easily bring whatever you need, and there are options to have more delivered if necessary. We enjoyed a casual dinner at Mainstay and another meal at The Boathouse (reservations needed there.) We would definitely stay at Peace of Paradise again. I am kind of...um...picky...about vacation rentals and will look at pretty much every house and every review, so you can probably trust my judgement on this. I will add a few details though, in case anyone wants to obsess over them. :) Location was perfect. A very quick golf cart (or bike ride) to the beach or the nature preserve. The carts were well maintained. There is no club membership, but we didn't miss it at all, especially with having such a nice pool at the house. There are so many comfortable places to relax. Internet was not great, but all the more reason to unplug and enjoy. We appreciated all the things that you don't want to have to think about bringing: dish pods, laundry pods, soap, shampoo, conditioner. Beds are comfortable, towels are plentiful, appliances are all good. What else can I say? Molly obviously cares about her guests. Did I mention the dolphins, manatees and crazy amount of seashells? Oh, and don't miss sunset on the beach - it's a bit of a thing - everyone goes...

North Captiva is a special place, made all the more enjoyable by having such a lovely home to stay in and attentive property managers to assist you. Tortuga staff were waiting for us at the dock with a trailer for our luggage and groceries, and our two golf carts. We followed Duncan to the house and he pointed out a few areas of interest along the way. We needed nothing during our stay, but I am confident that Tortuga would have handled any issues with ease. They also arrived promptly for our departure. Island Girl Charters is a seamless operation as well. Don't fret about the groceries - you can easily bring whatever you need, and there are options to have more delivered if necessary. We enjoyed a casual dinner at Mainstay and another meal at The Boathouse (reservations needed there.) We would definitely stay at Peace of Paradise again. I am kind of...um...picky...about vacation rentals and will look at pretty much every house and every review, so you can probably trust my judgement on this. I will add a few details though, in case anyone wants to obsess over them. :) Location was perfect. A very quick golf cart (or bike ride) to the beach or the nature preserve. The carts were well maintained. There is no club membership, but we didn't miss it at all, especially with having such a nice pool at the house. There are so many comfortable places to relax. Internet was not great, but all the more reason to unplug and enjoy. We appreciated all the things that you don't want to have to think about bringing: dish pods, laundry pods, soap, shampoo, conditioner. Beds are comfortable, towels are plentiful, appliances are all good. What else can I say? Molly obviously cares about her guests. Did I mention the dolphins, manatees and crazy amount of seashells? Oh, and don't miss sunset on the beach - it's a bit of a thing - everyone goes...

We had an amazing time in this beautiful home! It had everything we needed! Location is great!

This is a great property with a wonderful outdoor space!! Only thing missing is a minifridge in the Tiki bar!! Adults and kids both had a wonderful relaxing time at Peace of Paradise

This beautiful home had everything we could possibly need! Enjoyed the pool, the good carts and the location! Very secluded little island for a fun getaway. This home has been very well maintained and loved

This is a great property with a wonderful outdoor space!! Only thing missing is a minifridge in the Tiki bar!! Adults and kids both had a wonderful relaxing time at Peace of Paradise

This beautiful home had everything we could possibly need! Enjoyed the pool, the good carts and the location! Very secluded little island for a fun getaway. This home has been very well maintained and loved

Went to the island with my family and extended family and we had a wonderful time! What a unique trip for us first-timers - no cars, only golf carts was quite an experience! The Weather was near perfect (in March) in the 70's, we did some lounging on the beach and a lot of swimming in the pool/ocean and went shelling everyday. Peace of Paradise was lovely! Molly has the property maintained well :-) It felt a little more secluded than some of the other houses on the island which was great for gathering at the pool. We could be found at the downstairs, outside bar/BBQ area most of the time when we weren't at the beach - great use of space! So inviting, the lighting was perfect too. The private outdoor heated pool was a great size for our group of 7 as well. The house itself is round which made for interesting use of space in the bedrooms but not too hard to work around. All the helpful information about getting to the island and ordering groceries was VERY helpful too. We made great use of the reverse-osmosis water filter system in the house too which helps to combat the sulfur taste of the tap water. Tortuga management: we experienced a few slight "glitches" with communication but overall was a good company to work with. Duncan took us on a island tour the first night and helped get us acclimated to North Captiva. We would gladly come back to stay at Peace of Paradise again unless we bring more than 10 people :-)

Went to the island with my family and extended family and we had a wonderful time! What a unique trip for us first-timers - no cars, only golf carts was quite an experience! The Weather was near perfect (in March) in the 70's, we did some lounging on the beach and a lot of swimming in the pool/ocean and went shelling everyday. Peace of Paradise was lovely! Molly has the property maintained well :-) It felt a little more secluded than some of the other houses on the island which was great for gathering at the pool. We could be found at the downstairs, outside bar/BBQ area most of the time when we weren't at the beach - great use of space! So inviting, the lighting was perfect too. The private outdoor heated pool was a great size for our group of 7 as well. The house itself is round which made for interesting use of space in the bedrooms but not too hard to work around. All the helpful information about getting to the island and ordering groceries was VERY helpful too. We made great use of the reverse-osmosis water filter system in the house too which helps to combat the sulfur taste of the tap water. Tortuga management: we experienced a few slight "glitches" with communication but overall was a good company to work with. Duncan took us on a island tour the first night and helped get us acclimated to North Captiva. We would gladly come back to stay at Peace of Paradise again unless we bring more than 10 people :-)

Our stay was great. Staff was on top of any issue or concerns as well as making sure we had great seafood while we were there. The island is beautiful.

This rental is truly special: clean, beautiful and well-cared for. Duncan, Valerie and the team provided excellent support before, during and at the end of our trip. Peace of Paradise certainly lives up to its name. We will definitely be back!

First time on the island. The mgt and the process information were very helpful. I would do it again!

First time on the island. The mgt and the process information were very helpful. I would do it again!

Great house and property managers!

Great house and property managers!

What a beautiful home!! We felt so comfortable there. This house is so kid friendly it was hard to lure them off the property! I’m not even kidding!! From the sandbox to the hammocks, pool with the toys and outdoor living areas there wasn’t really a reason to leave…except the beach, of course!! We maxed out at 10 people (4 adults/6 kids (9months-11yrs) for half the time but it never once felt crowded. There were plenty of beds, dishes, towels and space! When we first booked it I was a little nervous about the white couch and kids but Laurie with Tortuga assured me this was a kid loving home and to just enjoy. She was right! The kids loved it and everything looked as it did when we arrived. This place made our yearly relaxing vacation even more so!! We will be back!

Wonderful accommodations, location was perfect, close to where we needed to go, beach, etc. perfect size for our family. Kids loved the pool area. Outdoor shower was a must.

Great time with all accommodations to rest and relax!

As advertised. Beautifully appointed. Easily accommodated 11, considering the bunks in the 4th bedroom. Super pool, golf carts, and bikes. Only drawback was the lack of closet space. Would rent again in the future.

Wonderful accommodations, location was perfect, close to where we needed to go, beach, etc. perfect size for our family. Kids loved the pool area. Outdoor shower was a must.

House was lovely. Spacious enough for our family of 8, even to watch movies, or to eat a family meal at the table. Kitchen was well equipped for a family of 8. TV's available in many rooms, so in evening adults could watch movie in spacious living area, while little ones could watch Disney-ish movies in one of the bedrooms. Lots of DVD's available with movies for little ones, as well as Netflix for all. First floor outside spacious and well equipped. Our 5-year old grandchild was enamored with the sandbox. Two golf carts, and 5 bicycles were all terrific. Beach chairs also good. No complaints about anything. Both Molly and Tortuga were terrific.

House was lovely. Spacious enough for our family of 8, even to watch movies, or to eat a family meal at the table. Kitchen was well equipped for a family of 8. TV's available in many rooms, so in evening adults could watch movie in spacious living area, while little ones could watch Disney-ish movies in one of the bedrooms. Lots of DVD's available with movies for little ones, as well as Netflix for all. First floor outside spacious and well equipped. Our 5-year old grandchild was enamored with the sandbox. Two golf carts, and 5 bicycles were all terrific. Beach chairs also good. No complaints about anything. Both Molly and Tortuga were terrific.

Peace of Paradise is a perfect name for this gem of a house on this gem of an island. The house is perfect with its beautiful pool and awesome outside areas. The information given on the house and island was accurate and helpful. Having property managers at your disposal during the stay is key since there is no easy way to get new items. My daughter got an ear infection while we were there and they were able to help me find a super awesome lady who picked up prescription from Pine Island and drop it to the ferry. I would def recommended this house. Great location!

Visited the property for a bachelorette for 10 girls and we had a blast. House is beautiful. We never wanted to leave the house because it had everything. A heated pool, hammocks, corn hole, etc… downstairs was the perfect place to entertain everyone. Only thing I will say is you must take all groceries, etc. Because getting on the ferry. The island is limited and extremely expensive for groceries (example: bag of ice is $8). However the refrigerator makes some. We loves our stay and would definitely recommend.

Visited the property for a bachelorette for 10 girls and we had a blast. House is beautiful. We never wanted to leave the house because it had everything. A heated pool, hammocks, corn hole, etc… downstairs was the perfect place to entertain everyone. Only thing I will say is you must take all groceries, etc. Because getting on the ferry. The island is limited and extremely expensive for groceries (example: bag of ice is $8). However the refrigerator makes some. We loves our stay and would definitely recommend.