19 people...5 families... we had a blast!!! The owners were awesome and went above and beyond to make our stay perfect!!! We will definately look in to this property again should we return to beautiful OIB!!!

Had 18 adults stay for a long weekend in September. Great views and a well-stocked kitchen for cooking. I rented many houses and this had the most coffee, spices, and kitchen supplies I have ever seen. Brian was a great host and communication was easy. Highly recommended.

Overall a very nice stay! The only downfall was the elevator in the house was not working and was hard for some family members to get up all the stairs. We absolutely loved the area and will return again.

The owner was easy to communicate with. There was an issue we caused and the owner immediately took care of it.

The home was clean and the layout was good. They provided several amenities. The views and the location were excellent. The pool area was clean and provided lots of sitting space. The refrigerator on the bottom floor near pool was very convenient and a great addition. We would recommend this home and location.

Papa's Porch is in a great location on the island and has beautiful views on the both the front and back porches. The pool, although a little on the small size, met our needs well. Communication with owners, both before and during the trip, was excellent. All that being said the house was on the disappointing side. From the beginning...the elevator repair people were at the house when we arrived. After working to repair it we were told it wasn't going to happen during our trip. However, on the day before we left the repairmen returned to get the broken part from the elevator. The said they were going to repair it and put it back on the next day so the elevator would be working for the next tenants. Why wasn't this be done for us? We had to contact the maintenance or owner numerous times. 1st floor AC stopped working, lots of burnt of light bulbs, front door handle fell off, 1/2 bath toilet got clogged. The kitchen needs a complete organization. The furniture is worn out. We were given 1 set of towels per person, 2 kitchen towels and crunchy sheets. Papa's Porch could be spectacular, but as is it is just average. No one wants to spend their vacation calling about constant issues and having repair people in and out of their rental.

We have stayed at several beach houses over 30+ years and this has to be in my top 3. The location is number 1 in my books. The island is perfect for the relaxation aspect and just enjoying time with family. The property owner was extremely great at communication and helped with all of our needs and questions. The house fit our family perfectly which included 13 adults and 4 kids. There’s nothing besides clothes and hygiene products that you will need as everything is provided. I would absolutely book this beautiful home again in the future. Thank you for such a wonderful experience.

The house and location are wonderful>