One of the most romantic hotels I have stayed in! The public rooms, the outdoor terrace for breakfast (superb!), the carriage house, the grounds-gorgeous. And the staff, ALL of them, where delightful and extremely helpful. If you are looking for an alternative to spare/modern/ikea like furnishings…this is the place. Can’t wait to go back. Will opt for next room size up however…

Room size was a bit tight.

Great location. Beautiful setting. Breakfast excellent. Staff great. Parking passes to the beach. East Hampton shopping close.

Rooms on the main road can have traffic noise. Either bring ear plugs if light sleeper or request rooms in carriage house

A wonderful time with the family. There are no traditional hotels in East Hampton, so the Baker House is a great choice as an upscale B&B. The house a grounds are immaculate. Staff was awesome. We are a black family of four. The accommodations and service for us were great from start to finish. My daughter left an ear ring and they called to let us know and sent it to my home free of charge. This is a well-deserved perfect rating.

Immaculate grounds and well maintained buildings. Loved the carriage house and it's upscale decor/design.

Bed in the carriage house room was hard and both my and my wife's back hurt in the mornings. They hosted a private yoga event one morning and we couldn't use the pool and lounge chairs. We thought a notice about this event slid under the door the night before, for example would have been nice. Breakfast wait staff needs to be on same page and ask if you want cream with your coffee as we had to wait on two occasions until much after the coffee was brought to the table.

Beautiful room although not as quiet as expected due to facing main road. Breakfast was good and service at breakfast was exceptional with friendly staff.