beach location and amenities, Mermaid restaurant and bar service, space between rooms and buildings gave a feeling of privacy, wonderful staff!

nothing! excellent

The location was beautiful, private and quiet. It was our first trip without our deceased son. We honored his birthday while in St. Croix. The staff and accommodations at The Buccaneer were amazing.

I didn’t like that we had to go home and couldn’t stay longer.

....beautiful pool ...great food....great views....great location.....Staff is Friendly and professional

Nothing

Beautiful beach front however being on a tropical island I would expect to see lush gardens everywhere for that is typical on every other tropical resort that I had visited in the past. Here there was plenty of weeds and the grass on the property was brown from lack of water.

The back door of my room had to be forced open and the molding broke. The staff promptly fixed it.

The beaches are gorgeous, the grotto pool is very nice. The food was decent and the staff was fairly friendly. it wasn’t overcrowded either.

They were under staffed so things like food/drinks took longer than usual and some locations (Grotto) weren’t open at all. We were also given the wrong category of room.

The location was great.

The food was good, but way over priced. The facilities were all closed up, like the place is going out of business.

beautiful location. comfortable accommodations.

Only one of their restaurants was open. They clearly did not have a handle on dinner service at all. when a reservation was made at times they took as long as an hour beyond the scheduled time to seat you. Food was very expensive. I don’t mind paying as long as the service and food quality match the price. It did not. The complimentary breakfast buffet was fair. However with only one restaurant available on-site with very high prices and a major ordeal to be seated we felt a bit of food insecurity as the property is a car ride to any other alternatives offsite. Highly recommend renting a car if you stay here. Other then that it is truly spectacular.

beautiful spot, views; always love the breakfast on the terrace

for the price, needs to be better groomed - grass in better shape, neater, construction materials better hidden

The breakfast and staff were amazing

No microwave in suite

The staff was wonderful and the grounds of the resort were beautiful. The proximity to downtown Christiansted was also very nice.

Kayaks and SUPs were unavailable for use for the entirety of our stay due to swells on the far side of the island. Breakfast is included but the tip is not, so it ended up being more expensive to dine in than go into town. The second evening of the Taste of St Croix occurred on site during our stay but this was not advertised in any way to guests. Reserved a king room but received a bedroom with two queen beds.

The rooms were clean. The beach was beautiful. The much needed rest and relaxation.

The staff was not friendly. Seemed always bothered when providing services. $60 a night in government taxes and another $50 for energy use… Pretty absurd. The complimentary breakfast was valued at $35 a person so for two people it was $70. Breakfast was a buffet so you get your own food. Server brings coffee and you’re expected to tip 20% of $70 ($14) for their server bringing coffee and drinks. Overall, not nice people.

Beautiful property, and really nice private beach. Also, all the staff were incredibly friendly.

1. The hotel did not have many activities that children could enjoy without being accompanied by adults, which was a disappointment. 2. On many occasions, we wanted some food or drink while at the beach, but were told that we had to go up to the Terrace because the beach bar and the Mermaid were not serving during those afternoon hours. Similarly, we often wanted to get a drink up at the lobby area (around the Terrace), but were told that we would have to go all the way down to the Mermaid, even for something simple like a cup of coffee or a glass of soda. This was very irritating, when paying for a hotel at this price point. I would have expected for a 4-star hotel at this price point to be have both bars (the beachside bar, as well as the lobby bar) open and serving minimal snack food and drinks from 10am -midnight 7 days per week. But apparently they only open "one" of those bars at a time, and that was a real nuisance.

The location, Mermaid beach, the food was good, the ambience, the golf, the pool.

Beauregard Bay -entrance to the water was dangerous. The spa was closed and we were not informed of it. We left early on the last day and breakfast was supposed to be open at 7am and was not.

Breakfast ok.

More variety

It was very therapeutic. The beds are glorious, view amazing, the amenities splendid.

The breakfast buffet was ok.

The breakfast is not what it used to be. Very basic .