Great food and service. Wait staff was excellent

Incredibly beautiful and quaint hotel, friendly staff and service, convenient location.

Ground floor rooms are a bit dark...

The Hob Knob is a spotless property with lots of beautiful decor and welcoming touches. Everything is like such a wonderful home from home; sumptuous bedding, amazing towels, great breakfast. It was perfect for our trip.

Excellent staff and amenities. I will stay here again and again!

Nothing

The staff was more than accommodating, personable, friendly and with a smile.

Really, could not have eaten all that came on the platter. Liked the variety. Would like to be able to choose what we wanted from the platter so as to not to waste anything. Everything was fixed just right. We did stop at the kitchen the second and third morning and was able to pick from the menu. As I said, all was great.

Breakfast was surprisingly well-prepared, nicely balanced in terms of nutrition and very ample, and the coffee was excellent!!! (Coffee is an under-rated feature at too many lodging and dining spots...I literally write off places where the coffee is really subpar.) The personnel to a person were genuine, courteous, prompt, responsive, and professional. Abby is an all-star!! Having on-site parking so close to the very heart of Edgartown is very key. The public spaces for hanging out...the porch, the garden, the living room, etc., areas, are very very comfortable. My grandchildren adored the chocolate cookies! Water freely dispensed was a nice change from paying for water!! Great to have a fridge in the room. Excellent water pressure in the shower!!! And so close to everywhere in the heart of Edgartown, and yet so quiet and serene!!!

Very small change here...perhaps an on-demand movie feature for the rooms?

Every little detail from the front entry all the way to room was exquisite. The room was very clean and beautiful furnishing. All the comforts of home! Abby and Max were the best staff as well.

The minute we walked in the door the staff was accommodating, kind and helpful. Breakfast is served daily and we were pleasantly surprised to receive a full tray of fresh baked goods and a healthy hearty breakfast.

The property was perfection. The porch is delightful and the staff was so accommodating.

This boutique hotel is lovely and you feel like it's your home away from home. It's decorated beautifully on the inside, with a relaxing porch and beautiful gardens. You get a delicious breakfast every morning which you can choose to eat inside or at the many tables in the garden. I can't begin to say enough about the staff. They all work together to make sure your stay is unbelievable.

The quaint HobKnob Inn was lovely and very comfortable. Our room overlooked a small secluded stone patio. We used the library fireplace room for a nightly glass of wine, and the airy porch was very welcoming each morning as we enjoyed our daily coffee before the delicious homemade breakfasts. The staff eagerly helped with suggestions and recommendations to each and every question we had. Our stay was absolutely fantastic!! We highly recommend the HobKnob Inn!!!

Nothing

I liked that it was quaint and private.

Very pretty, very clean property. Staff is friendly and helpful. Because of COVID, we didn’t hang out on the pretty porch, patio, etc. or use the fitness center or get a spa service, so we didn’t have a full experience there.

Breakfast was ok. Portions were a bit skimpy and food was average.

The staff was fantastic, very friendly and accommodating. The property is in a wonderful location—easy walk to town with the seclusion needed to feel like it’s your own place. The plantings and outside deck are gorgeous. Perfect for drinking coffee and reading a book. It has that has a Southern bed and breakfast vibe. We were fasting so we didn’t ha e an opportunity to have the breakfast. It smelled wonderful.

Light a candle to add some ambiance and fresh scent when you first walk into the lobby.