location

stairs

location

could have been cleaner

Pine Cottage is a great place to stay on Mackinac Island. Great location good value and good breakfest. Great views from the room, and great staff.

Breakfast was pretty good. Would have liked the addition of fresh cut fruit. The innkeeper was very friendly and helpful.

Bathtub did not have a soap dish or shelf of some sort to hold soap, shampoo, etc. A shelf of something similar by the bathroom sink for toiletries to sit would have been nice as well.

Breakfast was presented in a good atmosphere as well as hot and tasty

Room could have more table space

great vintage

how clean and kind everyone was.

hot in room. pulled curtain across to block sun when arrived. turned down heater to 64. still hot at 8pm.

great innkeepers..

It was in a good location, the place was very clean and interesting, the Managers were great, the breakfast was great, the Managers were very accommodating holding our luggage for us while we hiked before our departure. It was somewhat difficult to go down the hall to the bathroom.

location is excellent and freakfast is very good

wash room no pad to protect slippy

Pete and Caroline were wonderful hosts. The homemade breakfast meals were delicious, and Pete and Caroline made sure that we were comfortable and were enjoying our stay there.

N/A

Inn keepers were very helpful and friendly! Great cookies. They let us know when our room was ready so we could check in early. Comfortable beds!

Room was small and there was not enough table space to lay things.

We had a great view. The room was very sunny, well decorated and inviting and clean. The breakfast had variety, was plentiful and it was good. The couple managing Pine Cottage are very congenial and helpful.

We needed an extra shelf or vanity in the bathroom near the sink.

Breakfast was awesome! The room was very cute. Shared bathrooms were always open, clean, and stocked. Super quiet neighbors/hotel overall. We will be back! I recommend the queen with shared bathroom for younger couples. Would be nice to have your own bathroom if you're traveling with kids, which this hotel does have, just for more $$.

Charming and comfortable. Everything we needed including very welcoming hosts. Great recommendations for exploring the island.

cozy, clean

very small room. not enough place to hang stack clothes other than floor

They were so friendly! It was really close to everything and the breakfast was really good.

The mattress was pretty hard and the pillows were flat and hard other than that nothing to complain about

Great! A short walk to downtown.

A little pricey like everything else on Mackinac Island

Wonderful breakfast with a lot of variety.

The breakfast was great and the staff was awesome.

The beds were not comfortable and rooms were very small.