The cottage was cozy and very clean. I was very appreciative that our dogs were welcome and the owners were very easy to get in touch with.

This property is very charming on the inside. There is an eclectic collection of lamps all over adding to the quaintness with tea cups and books. In mid May, you can sit on the deck and enjoy the view of the property with the wafting smell of honeysuckle. I will note that the pictures of the property indicating it has a view of Keuka Lake is misleading. You cannot see the lake unless you leave the property and walk down the street. The kitchen is well equipped and one of the bathrooms is large and updated. The beds are comfortable. The couch is saggy and the deck is falling apart, but both are suitable for sitting and catching a movie or sitting outside in the breeze and reading a book. The house is conveniently located to Penn Yan and the Windmill Farm and Craft Market.

Everything was great! There is definitely a musty smell to the house and we found several stink bugs inside. The amenities and cleanliness made it a great place though. We would happily stay again.

The cottage was in sad condition overall on the outside. The yard was overgrown with massive weeds and dead trees everywhere you looked. The porch was dirty and unusable really. Minimal outdoor furniture to utilize and what was there was also dirty. Looked like no one actually cared the yard and deck areas were a mess. Hot tub was ok, too much chlorine was added. The home was clean but lacked in adequate cutlery and cookware. The pots and pans all had flaking Teflon and that's a major disappointment for people who look to rent homes like this to be able to cook for themselves. I'm not asking for upscale, but garbage is another story. Very few of the knives were sharp and we had to rewash all of the silverware. It's rundown, but clean on the inside. Beds were comfortable and rooms very nicely decorated. Upstairs loft is way too hot. The AC didn't work up there and fans didn't do much to help.