We really enjoyed our stay. The staff was super helpful and welcoming. It’s in a great location - so many different restaurants and bars within walking distance. Big plus that it was pet friendly, and they were so welcoming to our pup.

We enjoyed everything!

Great location. Cool old building

Street people noise at night. Dinner meal was excessive use of oil

loved the historic status and atmosphere - beautiful architecture & design. beds very comfortable! breakfast was homemade pastries and amazing!!

location is up and coming but hotel was safe and very comfortable

Right near the waterfront and right downtown. It is a wonderful old hotel with some great classic features and a ballroom.

There is the potential for some noise from the activities in the ballroom but we were on the top floor and it was quiet.

The hotel is in a great location relative to the downtown area. Very friendly staff. Everyone in the town is friendly and approachable. Just love the residents!

Hit and miss on the staff. Some knew the local activities and restaurants and others knew nothing. There was a plumbing problem with the tub drain that the hotel could not resolve until after my 3 days stay. Ended up standing in 6 inches of water with each shower. Hotel needs some deferred maintenance addressed. Will not recommend this hotel to friends. Additionally, there is a growing skid row issue with the vagrants, alcoholics, and drug addicts right at the corner of the parking lot with two of the three-night stay having individuals yelling throughout the night. The local town government needs to address this issue as it not only impacts the hotel but all the local businesses. I have been coming to Eureka every 5 years but will not make this a destination until the town supports the local merchants more on this front.

Breakfast was delicious! Victoria was great!

Lighting in bathroom. Noisy. Not enough pillows!—just joking!

Beautiful decor

The blanket was too thin, leaving me cold at night.

We loved the history and making preservation a priority of the old hotel. Our rooms were spacious and we used a couple of the common rooms to play cards at night. Parking was free and easy. Some of the furniture was truly lovely. Nice light breakfast in the mornings. The staff was very accommodating!

Unfortunately the location is right on the edge of a grittier area and our room was on the street overlooking this. Could have used a curtain on the window between the room and a little hallway to lessen the light in the AM and the hot sun in the afternoon.