The listing itself was fine. It had the amenities it describes. The check in was fine. I'd probably rate higher on those if things were a bit more updated. A hose attachment for a shower, clean deck chairs to sit in, a non clogged bathtub, etc. The cleanliness was really the major sticking points for my group. It's not well upkept beyond the cleanings in between guests. And even those seemed to be missing a lot of areas. There was a lot of dust and cob webs on the ceiling and a lot of spiders. I understand it's out in the woods but it was clear that it had been a while since anyone dusted the place properly. There was also some kinda gunk all over the pots and pans and the cabinet they were in. It had been there awhile.