Finger Lakes Mission House Family Retreat
About this house rental
Beautiful and historic 1940's home overlooking Hemlock lake and the historic St. Michael's Mission in Conesus. This secluded home is tucked away from it all, and to use an old cliche, is truly off the beaten path. The home was masterfully crafted into the hillside within a wooded area and has a gorgeous view overlooking the other mission buildings, and a stunning back porch vantage point over and across Hemlock lake. It'll take your breath for a moment, and once here you'll surely feel inspired to write home! Home is mission style, brick, modernized, and tastefully restored with a flare for the artistic. There are some original stained glass windows, beautiful paint and woodwork, hardwood floors, and custom baths for that special sort of pampering. Historically the home was used as the nunnery portion of the mission, and while the pictures don't quite tell the story, a personal visit will. * Home is furnished with a basic kitchen setup service for 12, large outdoor bbq grill, TV, microwave, keurig, etc. Basic linens, wifi, electric, water, recycling, and trash are accounted for as well. This unique property with it's deep gorges, sloping landscapes, and tumbling brooks flowing into Hemlock Lake, was also home to the historic St. Micheal's Mission and other various faith based and benevolent organizations since the early 1900's. The history that happened here is only imaginable today although much has been written about it. On site there are 50 picturesque acres to explore, a pavilion for small or large gatherings, and ample parking. Site could be used for events, although at current the property is only being used for residential purposes, so as a visitor here you'll pretty much have the run of the place while you step into the feeling of timelessness. While you're here, visit the Hemlock Canadice State forest with it's 6684 glorious acres within walking distance, and another 150 acre nature conservancy directly across the street. (for those nature lovers who really want to get away from it all). The property may become available for long or short term lease depending on time of year. Could be used for corporate retreats, weddings and wedding parties, or that romantic weekend getaway. Inquire today, you won't be disappointed! As caretakers, we'll work to make your stay here seamless and serene, and of course you'll never forget these views and the hiking on the property.
Amenities
Pets allowed
Kitchen / Kitchenette
Internet / Wifi
Fireplace
Parking
Laundry
Balcony / Patio
Dishwasher
TV
Garden
Map of Finger Lakes, NY
House in Finger Lakes, NY
Reasons to book
People love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Free cancellationFull refund if you change your mind
Great for pets
$$$$
Reviews
4.8/5.0
Outstanding(77 Reviews)
2.0
The ad on VRBO states, “sleeps 16” & details the beds in every room. During my stay 5 people slept there. In the ad under IMPORTANT INFORMATION TO KNOW it states, “Extra person charge MAY apply & varies depending on property policy.” I was unable to locate anything resembling Property Policy in or attached to the ad on VRBO. I am being charged more than $100.00 for an extra person(s)? The host refuses to refund this money to me! WHAT IS THE POLICY?
The host has CHASTISED me for not getting his permission 1st to hold a party in the house prior to doing so. (I held a brunch on a Sunday morning for approx. 25 people.) In his ad he states twice that PARTIES & EVENTS ARE ALLOWED ON SITE AS WELL AS CORPORATE RETREATS, WEDDINGS, ETC.. There is no mention of needing to get permission first. Lastly, when I made my reservation there was a piece in the ad that described a certain level of disinfection they use to clean their high touch areas. That piece is now gone from the ad. Upon arrival it was clear to me that high touch areas were not clean much less disinfected. Thank goodness for CLOROX WIPES, paper plates, aluminum foil, plastic utensils, etc.
Most distressing were the RODENT DROPPINGS everywhere including the eating utensils, pots, pans, dishes, countertops & tabletops in kitchen & living room. Also of large concern was the MOLD. My 2 guests took 1 look at the mold all over the ceiling in the upstairs bathroom & stated that they were quite sure it resembled BLACK MOLD!
4.0
We had a lovely time at this property. Korey was very helpful and quick to respond to any questions we had. The home is definitely older and showing its age in some areas (the one shower only worked sporadically, the oven worked but we couldn't turn it above 350, small things like that), but we had a great time regardless. Unfortunately the weather wasn't the best while we were there so we were unable to fully explore the property but it was in a nice, quiet area and we were all comfortable during our stay. Having 2 families together, we loved that there were 2 rooms with King beds and more than enough room for the children to sleep! It was nice to have extra freezer space with the chest freezer and there were plenty of games for the kids to play with. Overall a nice home and a great visit!
5.0
This place was fantastic. Kory was accommodating to special needs. Friends and family that came in for our daughter's wedding enjoyed their stay and loved the view and amenities that was offered.
5.0
We chose the Mission house for its proximity to the wedding venue. We wanted a larger location for family to stay if needed. It was perfect. We will definitely be looking for another reason to stay again!!!
5.0
Excellent accommodations. House fully stocked with any and all utensils needed. Host Korey Buzzell was always available to address any concerns we had. Rural location nice and stores nearby. Would recommend it to anyone.
Only problem I encountered was the BBQ grills definitely need to be replaced.
Can't wait to return next year.
5.0
What a cool old place in the woods! I took the downstairs bedroom with the comfiest mattress! Our host was friendly and gave us a personal tour of the old Mission in front. We wish we had stayed longer to explore more. The chickens running around were so cute and it added to the country woods charm of this old place! Cool woodwork inside, stained glass windows, a real bargain at twice the price!!
5.0
The Mission was as advertized and all of our guests were pleased with the accomidations.
5.0
We really enjoyed our stay in the old convent house! The property is amazing. We explored the old grotto, hiked down to Hemlock Lake, saw coyotes and deer and snakes, enjoy the fire pit, and played in the grassy yard. It was a great place for our horde of kids to run amok. Korey was gracious enough to give us a tour of the buildings and provide information about the history of the mission. The neighborhood is great for running and biking as well. We are so appreciative of the chance to stay here and would highly recommend to anyone.
5.0
We drove in to see family nearby. The scenery was so beautiful and with the extra room it was a great place to talk with family and close enough to everything that you would need.
The host was fantastic. Very friendly & attentive, I would definitely recommend staying here if you are traveling with a small or large group, we had s very nice time playing the piano and singing as well as enjoying the campfire. It would be perfect for a reunion or just a get together, there’s so much to see just on the property.
Definitely recommend staying there, especially if you enjoy history & are looking for a large place with a reasonable rate. Next time I would recommend reserving for longer! Great time😊
4.0
We stayed in the the old convent. It housed all 12 of us easily. This home is older and has its quirks. It does not have all the amenities of a newer home. It does not have any AC.
The home is on the property of an Old Mission. There are people that reside in the Mission year round and another part that is rented out for short stays. I say that to let you know you are not alone on the property.
The host and people that live there are very accommodating and willing to give you a tour of the Old Mission. The Grotto is in ruins and fun to explore at your own risk.
The winery down the road is amazing and we highly recommend a visit.
This property is very remote and has beautiful scenery. You will be about 20-30 mins away from gas stations/grocery stores.
We enjoyed our time!
4.0
Property was private with plenty of room for our family. 12 plus 2 dogs! Comfortable beds. Convenient for traveling for wedding in Naples. Enjoyed several winery and breweries in area.
5.0
Korey was an excellent host and the mission house was a wonderful, charming, and SPACIOUS location for our family Thanksgiving celebration. The kitchen is large and open, there are several comfortable bathrooms, and there was ample space for board games and meals. Couldn't have asked for more!
5.0
The house was perfect for our needs. We had a big group of 11 adults and some grandchildren and had a great time. The kitchen has no dishwasher but that was no problem. It was spacious and had plenty of all the kitchen things one would need. I was worried the living room might be small but it was fine and very cozy. There was a basement and attic the kids had space, too. One afternoon we drove half an hour to go skating, we enjoyed walks outside too and what an interesting area to hike in. Mostly it was needed for us to hang out, exchange christmas gifts and enjoy a reunion. We also booked a dinner 10 minutes away at the turtle stone grill through emails and they were so accommodating. This place was good for us because it's not pristine and with so many kids you didn't have to worry too much about them bumping into things, etc.. they had games and puzzles available too. Korey was a great host, ready to field and question and very easy going
5.0
Perfect for the extended family to see our daughter play soccer at Geneseo. Plenty of space for everyone! The winery down the block was great as well.
5.0
Having enough room for our group was great! The house had bedrooms with a variety of bed sizes and 2 1/2 bathrooms so everyone was comfortable. We loved the location! Hiking down to the edge of the lake was beautiful and there are many hiking trails nearby. The host was accessible and friendly. We will consider a longer stay in future!
5.0
A unique place to stay - very private and quite. Korey was easy to work with and very responsive.
5.0
excellent as always.. will stay again and again
5.0
Family ranging from 2 to 82 years old (including teenagers!) all were busy, safe and comfortable. Hiking, campfires, lawn games, firefly chasing, stargazing, kite flying and movie watching! The kitchen is very well equipped, the ceiling fan in ever room was much appreciated, the house was very clean, the beds were comfy. Streaming service was put to good use. This was my second stay and I knew if I needed anything Corey was a text away.
4.0
Delightful experience and some great relax meditative time. We also did some great day trips to Niagara Falls and the small lakes in the area . there was a turning point park that was the most enjoyable walk on a boardwalk along the water. Letchworth state park was a great time and they also have a pool. The place is not a five-star or even a four-star hotel it is a missionary with a great history and needs a lot of work but it’s what you’re looking for a great relaxing experience. We had a wonderful time.
5.0
Eight High School friends got together for a few days to catch up after many years of not seeing one another. The property was the perfect place to do this. There was lots of space, comfortable bedrooms, a good kitchen, and a great firepit for an evening fire. Korey was an excelent host. Highly recommended.
5.0
Excellent stay at the Mission House
Eight High School friends got together for a few days to catch up after many years of not seeing one another. The property was the perfect place to do this. There was lots of space, comfortable bedrooms, a good kitchen, and a great firepit for an evening fire. Korey was an excelent host. Highly recommended.
5.0
we have a yearly weekend, first day of trout fishing. usually, 8-10 0f us. This place accommodated all of us comfortably
.
5.0
perfect for us
we have a yearly weekend, first day of trout fishing. usually, 8-10 0f us. This place accommodated all of us comfortably
.
5.0
Perfect Weekend Getaway
This home is perfect for a family getaway. We were 13 people total and the house was of great size to support us all. Being it was during off season I was concerned about not having much to do, but the weathered cooperated and everyone had a great weekend exploring the property. Korey, was absolutely wonderful. He brought us farm fresh eggs from their chickens and gave us a tour of the buildings.
When I found this booking, I honestly thought it was too good to be true, but it was exactly as it states and even better than I imagined. Everyone who came is excited to book again in the summer, but for a week next time!
Thanks again Korey!
5.0
I have to start by saying this location might not be for everyone. If you're looking for a fancy pampered experience, you might not find it here. But, if you are looking for a TRUE EXPERIENCE, then you should not let this gem slip away.
The mission buildings are an ongoing restoration project. We did not choose a single room rental, but instead went with the full rental of the nunnery.
Creaky wooden floors and Good vibes for the people who used to call this home. Deer in the yard EVERY morning, chickens on your walk down to the grotto's. Ahhh, I want to go back now.
The coolest and rarest experience was to explore those grottos. It's not deemed safe but you are allowed to enter at your own risk.
This means, no tour guides, just you exploring ancient ruins. Okay, I think it has to be more than a hundred years old to be called ancient, but you can tell yourself whatever you want as you carefully explore these caves. I imagined I was playing tomb raider or uncharted 😁
Korey was ready for any questions we had ( yes the grottos are posted, but it's on the mission grounds and you're a guest) and I would absolutely book again because there is so much in the area that deserves a lot more attention than we were able to give it in five days.
5.0
I've been favoring short-term rentals for The last 5 years and this is my favorite so far.
I have to start by saying this location might not be for everyone. If you're looking for a fancy pampered experience, you might not find it here. But, if you are looking for a TRUE EXPERIENCE, then you should not let this gem slip away.
The mission buildings are an ongoing restoration project. We did not choose a single room rental, but instead went with the full rental of the nunnery.
Creaky wooden floors and Good vibes for the people who used to call this home. Deer in the yard EVERY morning, chickens on your walk down to the grotto's. Ahhh, I want to go back now.
The coolest and rarest experience was to explore those grottos. It's not deemed safe but you are allowed to enter at your own risk.
This means, no tour guides, just you exploring ancient ruins. Okay, I think it has to be more than a hundred years old to be called ancient, but you can tell yourself whatever you want as you carefully explore these caves. I imagined I was playing tomb raider or uncharted 😁
Korey was ready for any questions we had ( yes the grottos are posted, but it's on the mission grounds and you're a guest) and I would absolutely book again because there is so much in the area that deserves a lot more attention than we were able to give it in five days.
5.0
It was well located, everything needed for our stay was provided
5.0
We all loved this house!!
It was well located, everything needed for our stay was provided
5.0
Our family thoroughly enjoyed our stay in the former nunnery on the mission grounds. It had all that we needed, and then some, in terms of space to spread out or enjoy being together. There is a beautiful view and space to sit on the front porch along with a ready to go fire pit (though we didn't use it.) We used four of the eleven beds and all of them provided a very comfortable night's sleep. A 20 minute walk/hike will reward you with a tranquil rocky beach on the edge of Hemlock Lake, one of two undeveloped lakeshores in the Finger Lakes. The "pay it forward" kitchen system was great for cooking more than I planned because of spices, seasonings, and condiments. Plenty of cooking equipment as well. You're in the middle of the woods with assorted critters - deer, fox, raccoons, and turkey among others. Think of the nunnery as something akin to lovely farmhouse with beautiful hardwood floors and lots of wood trim. Korey was kind enough to take us through parts of the mission building and chapel, many of which have been out consistent use for 50 years. We enjoyed imagining what it would have been like for the residents, students, and church attenders who would have used the space. Note that the mission is shown in the listing, but the separate home that you stay in is located behind and beside the long sprawling building. We hope to visit again.
5.0
Beauty, serenity, and history - with comfy beds
Our family thoroughly enjoyed our stay in the former nunnery on the mission grounds. It had all that we needed, and then some, in terms of space to spread out or enjoy being together. There is a beautiful view and space to sit on the front porch along with a ready to go fire pit (though we didn't use it.) We used four of the eleven beds and all of them provided a very comfortable night's sleep. A 20 minute walk/hike will reward you with a tranquil rocky beach on the edge of Hemlock Lake, one of two undeveloped lakeshores in the Finger Lakes. The "pay it forward" kitchen system was great for cooking more than I planned because of spices, seasonings, and condiments. Plenty of cooking equipment as well. You're in the middle of the woods with assorted critters - deer, fox, raccoons, and turkey among others. Think of the nunnery as something akin to lovely farmhouse with beautiful hardwood floors and lots of wood trim. Korey was kind enough to take us through parts of the mission building and chapel, many of which have been out consistent use for 50 years. We enjoyed imagining what it would have been like for the residents, students, and church attenders who would have used the space. Note that the mission is shown in the listing, but the separate home that you stay in is located behind and beside the long sprawling building. We hope to visit again.
4.0
Great location for a quiet weekend getaway! Secluded but had all the modern amenities to keep kids busy while adults grill and socialize.
5.0
It was a great time , but the only draw back was the weather, we canceled one full day of activity because it rained but we compensated with letting the kids play out in the rain because there is plenty of room for activities and they, I'm sure, enjoyed doing that as much as going somewhere that would have cost a bunch to do the same thing run around and play games. The mission house was the perfect size for our group and having a fire pit made the evenings a great time to catch up on things all and all it was a fun time for everyone
5.0
My stay
It was a great time , but the only draw back was the weather, we canceled one full day of activity because it rained but we compensated with letting the kids play out in the rain because there is plenty of room for activities and they, I'm sure, enjoyed doing that as much as going somewhere that would have cost a bunch to do the same thing run around and play games. The mission house was the perfect size for our group and having a fire pit made the evenings a great time to catch up on things all and all it was a fun time for everyone
4.0
Great location for a quiet getaway!
Great location for a quiet weekend getaway! Secluded but had all the modern amenities to keep kids busy while adults grill and socialize.
5.0
The property was drop dead gorgeous featuring such a historic home. Korey went above and beyond to assist us. When inconveniences presented themselves, he was more than understanding and helpful. The scenery was stunning and Korey was a very easy going, kind host. We hope to visit again soon!
5.0
Kindest Host, Beautiful House
The property was drop dead gorgeous featuring such a historic home. Korey went above and beyond to assist us. When inconveniences presented themselves, he was more than understanding and helpful. The scenery was stunning and Korey was a very easy going, kind host. We hope to visit again soon!
5.0
Great Stay as Always
Great Stay as Always, been here 3 to 4 times now over the past 4 years.
Love the peace and quiet.
3.0
This is the 3rd visit to the Mission House because it’s secluded and adventurous. With the virus that is so easily spread, this was a good choice. The house is spacious and the linens were clean. However, we were disappointed with the cleanliness of the place and the lack of decent hot water pressure.
3.0
Adventurous and fun
This is the 3rd visit to the Mission House because it’s secluded and adventurous. With the virus that is so easily spread, this was a good choice. The house is spacious and the linens were clean. However, we were disappointed with the cleanliness of the place and the lack of decent hot water pressure.
5.0
Great Family Vacation Spot
My wife and I, along with children and grandchildren found this to be a great spot to enjoy. There is ample room inside, a nice side yard, wonderful porch, great views and plenty of places to hike and sight see.
FAQs
How much does this house cost compared to others in Finger Lakes?
The average price for a rental in Finger Lakes is $464 per night. This rental is $225 less expensive than the average.
Is parking included with this house?
Yes, parking is listed as an amenity at Finger Lakes Mission House Family Retreat. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.
Is there a pool at this house?
We didn’t find pool listed as an amenity for this house. It may be worth double checking if a pool is important for your stay.
Is Finger Lakes Mission House Family Retreat pet friendly?
Yes! This house is pet-friendly. For more information, we recommend contacting the booking provider about animal policies.
What amenities are available at Finger Lakes Mission House Family Retreat?
We found 10 amenities for this rental. This includes pets allowed, kitchen / kitchenette, internet / wifi, fireplace, and parking.