San Pier Novello in Oltrarno

Room was spacious, linens and towels good quality and hot water very hot.

I don't know, maybe I was just tired, but I was a little underwhelmed by the place. When you're paying over $300/night for a room, should you really have to lug your bag upstairs? (I guess in Italy, and to be fair, the gentleman working there did carry one of my two bags, but told me to carry the other, after a very long day of travel.) The check-in felt rushed, like he was in a hurry to get out of there, and as though there were a few too many rules, (reasonable ones, but still... a lot of admonitions upon arrival of what not to do). It just didn't feel very welcoming or relaxing. Breakfast was nothing special, typical Continental, no hot food, pastries and juice not especially fresh. And finally, the room was dark. I am honestly a bit perplexed by all the raves for this place, and think there are better places to stay in Florence for the money. I moved from this hotel to another that charged less, and offered much more in terms of warmth, helpfulness and accommodation.

Lovely historical property in Oltrarno with hundreds-years-old frescoes on the wall, trompe l’oeiel ceilings, and a charming community/breakfast room with kitchen. Hosts Martina and Jacob were fabulous; laid out a varied and high quality breakfast daily including home-baked tarts and quiches, cheesecake, yogurts, fresh fruit, charcuterie, toast with butter/honey/jam options, juices, coffee’s and teas made to order. Just lovely! Ten minute walk to Ponte del Vecchio bridge, 25 minutes from central Florence. A few excellent restaurants a short stroll away, yet quiet at night. Great place - HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!

Nothing. Great all-around.

Lovely central location with a helpful and friendly host!

A little noisy at nighttime.

We had such a lovely time at this property. Martina and her family are so wonderful and welcoming and provide a great recommendations for our stay. Waking up and looking at the fresco in our room was just magical! The bed was super comfortable and everything was well appointed. We didn’t really need the air-conditioning much while we were there, but it worked well. Great location, just out of all of the craziness in the center, but easy to walk right over to the Ponte Vecchio. Highly recommend staying here!

Nothing