Track prices
66 Vacation Rentals in Fire Island, NY, USA
Located off Long Island's southern shore, Fire Island has striking beaches, inviting restaurants, a vibrant nightlife, historic sites and landscapes that range from forests to sand dunes. Whether you're looking for a relaxing stay or the chance to explore, this Atlantic Ocean barrier island has it all.
Add your trip dates to find the best results
DatesShowing results 1-30 of 66 rentals
Highest rated vacation rentals in Fire Island
Pet-friendly stays in Fire Island
Hotel
Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex
3-Star Hotel · Booking.com
$134
Details
Great Deals in Fire Island
Vacations in Fire Island
About Fire Island
When you're not tasting local delights or sunning yourself on a beach, visit these attractions for an interesting Fire Island vacation.
- Sailors' Haven: Visit this tranquil area to see the unusual Sunken Forest, stroll around the marina and relax on the beach. Have lunch in nearby Cherry Grove.
- Robert Moses State Park: In Long Island's oldest state park, play golf at the pitch-and-putt course, fish from the piers, go boating, enjoy a picnic or swim at one of the beaches.
- Fire Island Lighthouse: Take a tower tour of this historic lighthouse located in Robert Moses State Park. Still in use today, its flashing light can be seen from 24 miles away.
How many rentals are available in Fire Island?
There are about 66 short term rentals available in Fire Island across several booking partners. The types of rentals available include:
- Houses
- RVs
- Hotels
- Condos
- Bed and Breakfasts
Average price for rentals in Fire Island
The average price for vacation rentals in Fire Island is $422. You can book a stay here for as low as $70.
Most popular type of vacation rental in Fire Island
Houses are the top rental type in Fire Island.
Top neighborhoods
Some of the most popular neighborhoods and places to visit in Fire Island include:
- Planting Fields Arboretum
- Sunken Meadow State Park
- Old Westbury Gardens
- Wantagh Park
- Adventureland
Things to do in Fire Island
Fire Island has several popular points of interest for you to check out when visiting the area. Here are the most popular points of interest in Fire Island.
Planting Fields Arboretum
Sunken Meadow State Park
Old Westbury Gardens
Wantagh Park
Adventureland
Long Island Aquarium
Top vacation cities in New York
Nearby destinations
Top cities in the United States
© 2022 VacationRenter, a Wilbur Labs company.