The best rentals from the top sites, all in one place

We believe finding a vacation rental in Fire Island should be easy and not take hours of searching and scrolling. We’ve designed VacationRenter from the ground up to help travelers find the perfect rental faster and easier.

Where to stay in Fire Island

Vacation rentals in Fire Island

There are 816 vacation rentals near Fire Island for all manner or mood of travel, availability of time off, and size of budget. So, if you are hoping for an affordable Fire Island vacation, you can find 10% rentals under $120/night. Or if you are willing to splurge on a luxury vacation in Fire Island, there are 82 between $1,020 and $8,000/night. Whether you are sleeping by yourself or with a significant other, or are travelling with a group of 41 there are short term home and apartment rentals in Fire Island to fit your vacation needs. The most popular types of short-term rental homes in Fire Island are houses, private rooms and condos. Fire Island has been a frequently searched travel destination this year and continues to grow in popularity. VacationRenter offers a wide selection of vacation rental availability from leading travel sites like VRBO (Vacation Rentals By Owner), Homeaway, Booking.com, and many more. Search your travel dates to find available Fire Island vacation homes for your trip.

Where is Fire Island

Located off Long Island's southern shore, Fire Island has stunning beaches, inviting restaurants, a vibrant nightlife, historic sites and landscapes that range from forests to dunes. Whether you're looking for a relaxing stay or the chance to explore, this Atlantic Ocean barrier island has it all.

Quick Guide to Fire Island

When you're not tasting local delights or catching some rays on the beach, visit these attractions for an interesting Fire Island vacation.
  • Sailors' Haven: Visit this tranquil area to see the unusual Sunken Forest, stroll around the marina and relax on the beach. Have lunch in nearby Cherry Grove.
  • Robert Moses State Park: In Long Island's oldest state park, play golf at the pitch-and-putt course, fish from the piers, go boating, enjoy a picnic or swim at one of the beaches.
  • Fire Island Lighthouse: Take a tower tour of this historic lighthouse located in Robert Moses State Park. Still in use today, its flashing light can be seen from 24 miles away.

Home-types in Fire Island

Fire Island has a variety of property types for you to consider when booking a trip. Here are the most popular property types in Fire Island:
- House: 611 vacation rentals
- Private Room: 123 vacation rentals
- Condo: 52 vacation rentals

Points of interests in Fire Island

Fire Island has several popular points of interest for you to check out when visiting the area. Here are the most popular points of interest in Fire Island:
- Fire Island Lighthouse: 439 vacation rentals
- Robert Moses State Park: 439 vacation rentals
- Smith Point Park: 439 vacation rentals
- Fire Island National Seashore: 439 vacation rentals
- Sailors Haven Visitor Center: 439 vacation rentals
- Fire Island: 362 vacation rentals
- Fire Island Pines: 264 vacation rentals
- Barrett Beach Park: 134 vacation rentals

Popular rental amenities

Kitchen

774 rentals

Laundry

745 rentals

Internet

738 rentals

TV

719 rentals

Air Conditioner

678 rentals

Balcony / Patio

505 rentals

Dishwasher

471 rentals

Pool

367 rentals

Pets Allowed

277 rentals

Parking

276 rentals

Price trends in Fire Island

$1200
06/07 - 06/13
$684 per night
Search now
06/14 - 06/20
$697 per night
Search now
06/21 - 06/27
$752 per night
Search now
06/28 - 07/04
$780 per night
Search now
07/05 - 07/11
$880 per night
Search now
07/12 - 07/18
$927 per night
Search now
07/19 - 07/25
$942 per night
Search now
07/26 - 08/01
$952 per night
Search now
08/02 - 08/08
$976 per night
Search now
08/09 - 08/15
$965 per night
Search now
08/16 - 08/22
$988 per night
Search now
08/23 - 08/29
$991 per night
Search now
08/30 - 09/05
$1005 per night
Search now
09/06 - 09/12
$708 per night
Search now
09/13 - 09/19
$475 per night
Search now
09/20 - 09/26
$482 per night
Search now
09/27 - 10/03
$475 per night
Search now
10/04 - 10/10
$424 per night
Search now
10/11 - 10/17
$424 per night
Search now
10/18 - 10/24
$389 per night
Search now
10/25 - 10/31
$404 per night
Search now
11/01 - 11/07
$428 per night
Search now
11/08 - 11/14
$467 per night
Search now
11/15 - 11/21
$497 per night
Search now
11/22 - 11/28
$500 per night
Search now
11/29 - 12/05
$450 per night
Search now
12/06 - 12/12
$457 per night
Search now
12/13 - 12/19
$450 per night
Search now
12/20 - 12/26
$467 per night
Search now
12/27 - 01/02
$450 per night
Search now
01/03 - 01/09
$425 per night
Search now
01/10 - 01/16
$428 per night
Search now
01/17 - 01/23
$433 per night
Search now
01/24 - 01/30
$449 per night
Search now
01/31 - 02/06
$158 per night
Search now
02/07 - 02/13
$595 per night
Search now
02/14 - 02/20
$600 per night
Search now
02/21 - 02/27
$605 per night
Search now
02/28 - 03/06
$643 per night
Search now
03/07 - 03/13
$630 per night
Search now
03/14 - 03/20
$633 per night
Search now
03/21 - 03/27
$641 per night
Search now
03/28 - 04/03
$633 per night
Search now
04/04 - 04/10
$633 per night
Search now
04/11 - 04/17
$633 per night
Search now
04/18 - 04/24
$630 per night
Search now
04/25 - 05/01
$633 per night
Search now
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr

Nearby destinations

Long Island Rockville Centre Hempstead Lido Beach Blue Point Oakdale Baldwin Fire Island Islandia Jericho Patchogue Robbins Rest Bayville Bethpage South Huntington North Babylon Ocean Beach Huntington Bay Port Jefferson Oyster Bay Amityville Compo Beach Saltaire Northport Bellport Sound Beach Carle Place Farmingdale Southport East Norwich Fire Island Pines Fairfield Remsenburg-Speonk Ocean Bay Park Cherry Grove Kismet Fair Harbor Brookhaven Davis Park Mastic Beach

Top destinations in New York

Allegany State Park Baiting Hollow Bellmont Binghamton Brantingham Brantingham Lake Brookhaven Claryville Cleverdale Clifton Copake Lake Cragsmoor Cranberry Lake Davis Park Edwards Ellenville Grand Island Greenwood Lake Hadley Hastings On Hudson Henderson Harbor Ilion Keeseville Lake Luzerne Laurens Little Valley Long Lake Loon Lake Mastic Beach Paradox Lake Parish Prattsville Ripley Sabael Scipio South Jamesport Star Lake Taghkanic Ticonderoga Utica

Top destinations in United States

Arizona Arkansas Connecticut Delaware District of Columbia Florida Keys Hawaii Idaho Illinois Indiana Iowa Kansas Kentucky Louisiana Maine Maryland Massachusetts Michigan Minnesota Mississippi Missouri Montana Nebraska Nevada New Hampshire New Mexico North Dakota Ohio Oklahoma Oregon Pennsylvania Rhode Island South Dakota Utah Vermont Virginia Washington West Virginia Wisconsin Wyoming