The best rentals from the top sites, all in one place

We believe finding a vacation rental in Kelleys Island should be easy and not take hours of searching and scrolling. We’ve designed VacationRenter from the ground up to help travelers find the perfect rental faster and easier.

Where to stay in Kelleys Island

Vacation rentals in Kelleys Island

There are 27 vacation rentals near Kelleys Island for all manner or mood of travel, availability of time off, and size of budget. So, if you are hoping for an affordable Kelleys Island vacation, you can find 10% rentals under $165/night. Or if you are willing to splurge on a luxury vacation in Kelleys Island, there are 3 between $428 and $500/night. Whether you are sleeping by yourself or with a significant other, or are travelling with a group of 18 there are short term home and apartment rentals in Kelleys Island to fit your vacation needs. The most popular types of short-term rental homes in Kelleys Island are houses and condos. Kelleys Island has been a frequently searched travel destination this year and continues to grow in popularity. VacationRenter offers a wide selection of vacation rental availability from leading travel sites like VRBO (Vacation Rentals By Owner), Homeaway,, and many more. Search your travel dates to find available Kelleys Island vacation homes for your trip.

Where is Kelleys Island

Kelleys Island, OH, is the biggest Lake Erie island, and has a quiet, slow-paced vibe. Its attractions include historic sites, nature parks, golf courses, a winery, marinas, and unique retail stores. Check out these popular places for a great vacation.

Quick Guide to Kelleys Island

Visit the museum to learn about Kelleys Island's history, play miniature golf and mine for gems. In addition to these activities, the following attractions are essential when vacationing here.
  • Glacial Grooves State Memorial: See the incredible 400-foot-long glacial grooves that were naturally carved into the soft limestone. Take a short tour of this geological phenomenon and learn about its history via storyboards.
  • Kelleys Island State Park: Hike and bike along the trails, wander around Horseshoe Lake and visit the two preserves. Rent a kayak at State Park Beach and enjoy views of Pelee Island and Lake Erie from the stone pier.
  • Inscription Rock: Walk along the wooden platform to view the petroglyphs carved into the soft surface of this boulder by Native American tribes.

Home-types in Kelleys Island

Kelleys Island has a variety of property types for you to consider when booking a trip. Here are the most popular property types in Kelleys Island:
- House20 vacation rentals

Points of interests in Kelleys Island

Kelleys Island has several popular points of interest for you to check out when visiting the area. Here are the most popular points of interest in Kelleys Island:
- Kelleys Island: 27 vacation rentals
- Scheele Preserve: 27 vacation rentals
- Inscription Rock: 27 vacation rentals
- Glacial Grooves: 27 vacation rentals
- Kelleys Island State Park: 27 vacation rentals
- Kelleys Island Country Club: 10 vacation rentals
- Memorial Park: 8 vacation rentals
- VFW Post 9908: 7 vacation rentals