House in Sylvan Beach, NY
8 guests · 3 bedrooms · 1 bath
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
High-end valueWell priced for this area
About this house rental
Spacious 3-bedroom unit in a two-unit beachfront duplex, located directly behind the landlord’s summer home. Enjoy partial lake views, your own designated beachfront patio set, direct beach access, gas grill, picnic table, fully equipped kitchen, smart TV with YouTubeTV, Wi-Fi, and walking distance to local entertainment.
Please note:
Shared property – landlord’s unit is in front and next door for any requests.
Bring your own towels, linens, blankets, pillows, paper products, cleaning supplies, and perishables (linens available upon request for an extra charge before check-in).
Bathroom is on the second level of both units.
Family-friendly atmosphere, ideal for those looking for a lively beach spot (not a secluded or private lot).
Please note:
Shared property – landlord’s unit is in front and next door for any requests.
Bring your own towels, linens, blankets, pillows, paper products, cleaning supplies, and perishables (linens available upon request for an extra charge before check-in).
Bathroom is on the second level of both units.
Family-friendly atmosphere, ideal for those looking for a lively beach spot (not a secluded or private lot).
Amenities
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Sylvan Beach, NY
Ratings and reviews
Summary of reviewsFantastic stay with wonderful hosts and a perfect location close to the beach, great for families with amazing sunsets and clean living spaces.
10 / 10Outstanding·Jun 2026
The best part of this place was the location. I was down there with friends for a volleyball tournament, and having walk-out access to the beach was really convenient (as was the hose by the door to rinse sand off before going in). Sara was easy to communicate with, and worked with me to figure out a convenient check-out time (for an extra fee). The listing was a bit confusing to me, in that your rental isn't right on the beach, but rather behind the owner's house, which is. However, there's a patio area (shared between the owners and the other attached rental) that walks right out on the beach which was great. I always feel it's a bit uncomfortable when the owner is so close to your rental property, like you're being watched all of the time (however, they did absolutely nothing to make us feel that way, so maybe that's just a personal issue I should work on). The listing was clear that there's not much provided besides dishes and utensils, but that does make for a much larger packing list (sheets, pillows, towels, toilet paper, paper towel, garbage bags, etc.). The three upstairs rooms were not big, but were sufficient for our needs, and even had enough room to squeeze in a pack-n-play. The appliances worked, there was a grill outside the door, and the smart-tv and WiFi worked well.
Overall, this property was a bit on the pricey side and didn't come with many amenities, but the owners were nice and easy to deal with, the location was excellent, and we had a great stay.
8 / 10Excellent·May 2026
Great little place by a giant lake, with a cool little carnival (closed for the season at the time we stayed) and restaurants within walking distance. ONE BONE TO PICK would be the absence of linens towels and pillows. While I think it’s a little unusual and have never encountered in my stays elsewhere (who travels with ALL of that stuff? Linens?) and I guess it’s the host’s right to not provide to reduce costs, this element was not made apparent, which I think it needs to be. It’s totally on me for not reading the fine print, but unless I overlooked it elsewhere, this aspect wasn’t mentioned until 2 or 3 pages/clicks in, twds the bottom. This doesn’t take away from how lovely the place and stay was but it was a bit odd and frustrating not to have these things.
10 / 10Outstanding·Sep 2025
We had a wonderful time, and the condo was perfect for our needs. It was very close to everything and a nice set up for a family with a toddler. The host was very responsive to our needs, and it was very family friendly. The sunsets here are to die for! Thank you for a great day!
6 / 10Average·Jul 2021
Cute house with great location. Some amenities were missing. Very steep stairs to keep in mind.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.2Outstanding
(83 Ratings)
Fantastic stay with wonderful hosts and a perfect location close to the beach, great for families with amazing sunsets and clean living spaces.
From real guest reviews summarized by AIDon't miss out! Price and availability may change
