Vacation Rental Property on Keuka Lake

Property grounds
1 bedroom, iron/ironing board, WiFi, bed sheets
Fridge, microwave, oven, stovetop
1 bedroom, iron/ironing board, WiFi, bed sheets
1 bedroom, iron/ironing board, WiFi, bed sheets

About this house rental

Located in Keuka Lake, this lovely house for $856 per night is a great option for your next break. In warm weather we can accommodate up to 14 people. Cold weather, 10 people. 2 night minimum stay. Summer rentals - June, July & August - are strictly WEEKLY from Saturday to Saturday. If you are interested in staying at our property, please send a brief description of your group to John Marshall, the owner. We do not accommodate groups of people in their 20s, thank you. There are 3 levels in this newly renovated Keuka Lake property accommodating up to 14 people in warm weather. The main entrance is right off the upper parking area (3-4 vehicles) which is just 15 feet from the main road. This provides easy access for unloading - 2 short steps up into the upper level apartment. There is an interior staircase down to the lower apartment as well as an outdoor stairway from deck to lower parking area accommodating up to three vehicles - providing easy access to lower apartment. The top level in the main house is air conditioned and has three private bedrooms with a queen bed in the master bedroom and (2 new cozy mattresses) on full beds in the other two newly renovated bedrooms featuring very large 4.5 foot wide side by side windows (with inset top down/bottom up honeycomb style shades) for fantastic views right from the beds! Watch the sun rise across the lake from the large screened in porch which leads out to deck with with a gas grill and umbrella table that seats up to six. The main living/dining room is very large and can easily accommodate your entire group. Full bathrooms – new updated in August, 2022 tub & shower, sink on upper level, sink and new updated shower in lower level and half bathroom (no tub or shower) on the beach. The kitchen on the top floor is fully stocked with a wide variety of cooking and serving dishes, wine glasses, crock pot, microwave, toaster, coffee maker with filters suppied, Keurig Coffee maker, a paper towel roll for starters and new, very quiet dishwasher that can do 14 place settings, One of the double sink faucets is filtered through a very high-quality filter. The main faucet is Penn Yan city water– chlorinated, etc. The kitchen on the lower floor is also fully stocked and has coffee maker. Baby gates are in place to swing closed and hook where needed. The lower level is naturally cool and now also air conditioned and has one private bedroom with a full bed. Two twin beds in the living room area also serve as couches (the kids often claim this area). Both upper and lower apartments have wifi, working fireplaces with limited amount of firewood supplied, bathrooms with showers and new tub upstairs complete kitchens, screened in porches, dining areas, and shared laundry facilities. Around the house, many mural size and smaller photos from late 1800’s to the early 1900s lend a wonderful feeling of Keuka Lake history. Gorgeous shots of the lake also decorate the rooms. In warm weather, the 3rd apartment, 45 steps down to the beach, is the “beach house” which is right down on the lawn of the very large beach, and has a private bedroom with a queen size bed and a couch that converts into a queen bed in the outer area - also a bathroom, hot and cold running water, hotplate, microwave, coffee maker, glasses, some dishes, a new full size refrigerator in the small kitchen area and a screened in porch. The beach house is heated by two small space heaters – good for temperatures as cool as the low to mid 40s. The beach is very large with 80 feet of shoreline and a lawn - plenty large enough for bocce, playing catch, etc. A good sized stone campfire circle (enough firewood supplied for 3/4 campfires) is nestled near the shore and a (new this summer 2022) portable weber gas grill, picnic table, dock, comfy beach furniture, noodles for floating and a 2 person canoe with life vests are all provided. Our dock is recently new and very sturdy. It extends out from shore 40 feet to accommodate boats with bumpers, cleats that fold down for safety on both sides and 4 solar dock lights (photo of lawn shows previous shorter, more narrow dock). You can walk 2 minutes down the lake road to East Bluff Harbor Marina and rent a boat for the day or longer. We suggest that you book your boat rentals far in advance. The Marina can also launch boats and keep your trailer for you. If you rent a boat from the marina they let you dock it at our place while you have it. The property is on the eastern branch of Keuka Lake. Normally especially quiet on weekdays and most weekends, the beach is its own little peninsula lined with a creek on the south side, providing much privacy. The entire place is available weekly in the peak summer season. It is available off peak season for weekends or specific date arrangements year-round. Go to "Rates and Availability" at the top to see seasonal dates and calendar showing which dates are already booked. Ideal for weekend getaways, family reunions, retreats, graduations (2.4 miles from Keuka College). Families with children are most welcome. No pets, guests beyond 14 person limit, or wild parties are allowed. Renters must average in their 30s or older (not including children) to qualify. Weekly guests are greeted and shown around by owner or close friend. The owner always available by phone or text to answer questions. See our reviews! This place is a piece of heaven.

Amenities

Air conditioner
Kitchen / Kitchenette
Internet / Wifi
Fireplace
Parking
Laundry
Balcony / Patio
Dishwasher
TV
Garden
Family friendly

Map of Keuka Lake, NY

Reviews

4.8/5.0
Outstanding(78 Reviews)
5.0
Nov 2023
With the craziness of summer we postponed having a family get together until fall. The property was absolutely splendid with an awesome view of the lake and fall colors. The facilities were just what was needed for our now adult children and significant others. Thanks for such a wonderful place.
5.0
Oct 2023
Every fall I coordinate a ladies weekend. This year I choose to spend it in the Finger Lakes. The house was perfect! Cozy, great views and fit 7 of us! Would definitely recommend!
5.0
Oct 2023
A group of six 60+ women enjoyed hiking, paddling and touring on an autumn weekend in the Finger Lakes region. This property was a most comfortable and convenient base for all activities.
5.0
Sep 2023
John and Rose's home is beautiful, functional and one of the best cottages that we have stayed at on Lake Keuka. It has all the modern conveniences yet has some older charm with the historic photos, hard wood floors and screened porches. The online description matched the actual home. The cottage is separated into 2 apartments and a beach house on the lake. It was perfect for our extended family as we could get together on the main level, yet have some secluded moments-- especially great for little ones that need naps. The lakefront is gorgeous. I really thought the solar lights on the dock was clever. It made my husband happy as he could easily do some night fishing. The property manager, Michael, met us and was friendly & explained the home. There were written instructions as well which was extremely helpful with a large group so we could have something to refer to. Thanks, again, John and Rose, for sharing your beautiful home with us! We hope to rent the home again in the future!
5.0
Aug 2023
The listing very accurately describes the property. My family had a wonderful stay! The lakeside is absolutely beautiful and proximity to the marina was very convenient. Take all that you need for the day down to the beach house or you will definitely get your steps in and them some!! The owner and property manager were wonderful to deal with. Highly recommend unless there are mobility issues in your group.
4.0
star 5 empty
Aug 2023
Overall our family enjoyed the property, especially the privacy of the beach front, large grassy play area for games and the convenience of having a bathroom down at the beach area. The main house was large enough for our entire family to stay comfortably. Thank you John, we all had a great time.
5.0
Aug 2023
Upstairs, downstairs and beach house allowed family members to join us for short times. Neighborhood and lake amazingly quiet. Beautiful sunrises from bedroom windows and porch.
4.0
star 5 empty
Aug 2023
Not enough space to write all the details but the weird layout is typical of a lake house and was fine for us. The large amount of steps were manageable for our whole party- older folks just took them slowly. The response of the kind owner was swift (though he showed up unannounced) to view our issues. What issues? Broken door handle, sink not draining, and spiders and large ants everywhere, including the kitchen. He was able to spray for bugs and sent someone to repair the other two things the day before we left. We hadn’t told him the issues until mid-week, though, so that’s fair. Location and parking were perfect. Neighbors were great! The only major complaint was the cleanliness. The cleaning people got a D- from us. They did the bare minimum & it wasn’t enough. We found underwear and a pillow under the bed, both covered in dust, as well as a wedding ring in plain sight. When we mopped, the mop was black. We had to rearrange sleeping arrangements when some of the party discovered an enormous amount of dead bugs in the pull out couch in the guest cottage. Dishes were dirty…you get the idea. With new cleaning people, and maybe a reduction of “things” in the home, the place is great! It is perfect for a large party like ours and we were happy to have that time together!

FAQs

How much does this house cost compared to others in Keuka Lake?

The average price for a rental in Keuka Lake is $515 per night. This rental is $341 above the average.

Is parking included with this house?

Yes, parking is listed as an amenity at Vacation Rental Property on Keuka Lake. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.

Is there a pool at this house?

We didn’t find pool listed as an amenity for this house. It may be worth double checking if a pool is important for your stay.

Is Vacation Rental Property on Keuka Lake pet friendly?

Unfortunately, this house is not pet-friendly. Try searching again and filter for "Pets Allowed"

What amenities are available at Vacation Rental Property on Keuka Lake?

We found 11 amenities for this rental. This includes air conditioner, kitchen / kitchenette, internet / wifi, fireplace, and parking.

Explore similar vacation rentals in Keuka Lake

Explore all rentals in Keuka Lake

Keuka Lake travel inspiration

Read our blog