Beautiful Oceanfront Pool Home ~ Private Boardwalk ~ Sugar Sand Beach
About this house rental
Large enough to host 2 families, luxurious enough to satisfy even the most demanding vacationer, Peace of Paradise lives up to its name. This recently renovated oceanfront home boasts a huge sparkling heated pool (heater is optional) with deck, 2 living rooms, myriad decks with outstanding views, and a full bathroom for each of its 5 bedrooms. The location alone qualifies the house as idyllic. A private boardwalk takes you from your back door to the pristine beach in seconds. The only thing separating Peace of Paradise from the beach are the dunes. Well, that and the in-ground swimming pool that runs the width of the house. Surrounded by a dazzling deck populated with numerous lounge chairs, the pool rivals that of a private club--and it is all yours! It is surrounded by a baby gate, which will provide parents peace of mind. When you are not sunning yourself on the poolside deck, surfing in the ocean, or searching for shells on the beach--you can relax on the expansive 2nd-story balcony. Gaze out at the Atlantic, looking for dolphins and whales beyond the surf. Or maybe you will want to keep cool beneath one of the ceiling fans of the 1st-floor porch. The rhythmic murmur of the waves is guaranteed to relax you. The interior of Peace of Paradise was designed with relaxation top of mind. The house has not 1 but 2 spacious living rooms, one on each floor. This, along with the wealth of bedrooms (1 with a king-size bed, 3 with queen-size beds, and a 5th with bunk beds), makes the home well suited for multiple families or couples vacationing together: There’s plenty of space for everyone to do his or her own thing as well as for the whole group to gather together. Both living rooms are decorated in soft hues, with a wealth of wonderfully comfortable seating. And with a TV and board games in each, boredom will not be an issue! Go ahead, sprawl out on a sofa, and treat yourself to a well-deserved midday nap. One of the sofas in the upper level living room opens into a bed for 2, should you have unexpected overnight guests. The bedrooms and bathrooms are as roomy, comfortable, and lovingly furnished as the rest of the house. The master suite is particularly fabulous. Not only does it open onto its own private balcony, but it also has in its en suite bath a Jacuzzi next to a one-way mirror, so that you can look out at the ocean as you soak without anyone else being able to see in. The upper-level dining table easily seats 6; there’s room for another 4 at the adjacent breakfast bar. Not to mention a table and chairs on the deck for alfresco dining. A cozy breakfast nook on the 1st floor is just the spot for an intimate meal for 2. Whether you plan to cook three meals a day or simply mix milkshakes and margaritas in the blender, you will love the open, fully equipped kitchen. Stainless-steel appliances, cookware, and prep tools galore, plenty of tableware. The kitchen has it all. That includes generous storage space; you can stock up on groceries at the beginning of your stay and not have to waste additional vacation time at the supermarket! By the way, Peace of Paradise has a 2nd Jacuzzi — talk about luxurious! Among its many other amenities are 2 conveniently located powder rooms, and a washer and dryer. And let us not forget the deck and sitting room by the front of the house. Admire the sunrise over the ocean while sitting on the back balcony, then take in the sunset from the front deck. So much beauty to soak up, and you are perfectly positioned to savor it all! *Pool may be heated for an additional $300/week to a maximum of 84 degrees. Pool heat must be added to your reservation at least 48 hours prior to arrival. Please note that we do not heat the pool Memorial Day- Mid September*
Amenities
Pool
Air conditioner
Kitchen / Kitchenette
Internet / Wifi
Parking
Laundry
Balcony / Patio
Dishwasher
TV
Map of Butler Beach, FL
House in Butler Beach, FL
Reasons to book
People love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Includes essentialsPool, Kitchen / Kitchenette, Air conditioner and more
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
$$$$
Reviews
4.7/5.0
Outstanding(42 Reviews)
5.0
Beautiful house. Had everything we needed
3.0
The place was really nice except there was definintely a bug issue throughout the house. I did call them to let them know that we were getting ready to check out and let them know about the bug issue. They stated next time to call them immediately and the would send someone out to spray the house. I do know that they were sending someone over that day to spray the house.
5.0
Designed to be a family Christmas with people coming together from several locations. Despite the cold spell the house offered great beach access and ocean views. House was spacious offering plenty of room for people to relax and spend time together. Appreciated the cable access in different rooms (and levels), and for food planning with many people very much appreciated the 2nd refrigerator.
Great location to St Augustine and easy enough drive up to Ponte Vedra. Desired location we may return with other families in tre future for beach vacation.
4.0
Location was great and the house sits perfectly on the beach.
5.0
This was the first time that my husband and I, our kids and grandkids shared our vacation together! It was a huge hit! My grandkids want us to "buy the property" because it was "hands down", their favorite Florida vacation ever! We stayed two weeks, and we never ran out of things to do! My kids were amazed at the privacy of our pool and beach areas! We ALL appreciated the beach chairs, boogie surf boards, pool floats and beach towels! So much more was provided than we expected! We were also able to view a rocket launch (from Kennedy Space Center) from our personal walkway one evening! Between that, the sea turtles, the fort in St. Augustine, the tide, the sea "critters" that washed ashore...the kids learned so much!
It was a vacation that none of us will ever forget!
5.0
It was perfect that the house was right on the beach and also had a pool for us to hang out at. Would enjoy staying at again.
5.0
Wonderful family week
Everything was even better then expected. It was wonderful having our own pool right outside our door and the almost private beach just a short walk down our own boardwalk. It was the first time since thanksgiving of 2019 that the 13 of us have been together. Everything was great, the rooms, bathrooms, 5 full, 2 half, were very clean and stocked. The view from the upstairs deck was spectacular. Thank you for everything.
5.0
Fabulous Family Fun
Everyone enjoyed this house and all it’s amenities
5.0
Our family enjoyed vacationing at this property. The house is very nice and well appointed. The beach is absolutely beautiful!
5.0
Great Family Vacation
Our family enjoyed vacationing at this property. The house is very nice and well appointed. The beach is absolutely beautiful!
5.0
Four couples (siblings & spouses), enjoyed the space. Though all of the rooms were nice, There was some of flipping coins, to see who got the best bathrooms. The location and pool are wonderful. We enjoyed watching our friendly tortoise, every day, as we strolled the boardwalk to the beach!
10.0
Four couples (siblings & spouses), enjoyed the space. Though all of the rooms were nice, There was some of flipping coins, to see who got the best bathrooms. The location and pool are wonderful. We enjoyed watching our friendly tortoise, every day, as we strolled the boardwalk to the beach!
5.0
Great location & comfortable house!
Four couples (siblings & spouses), enjoyed the space. Though all of the rooms were nice, There was some of flipping coins, to see who got the best bathrooms. The location and pool are wonderful. We enjoyed watching our friendly tortoise, every day, as we strolled the boardwalk to the beach!
5.0
Great Family Vacation Home
Rented this house with my family and had a wonderful time there. The pool was great and the access to the beach was so convenient. Beautiful view of the ocean from the top floor from inside and outside! Nice quiet neighborhood and great neighbors. Could use some small fixes here and there, but overall a great place to rent!
5.0
Excellent location. Excellent weather. Perfect family time.
5.0
Christmas 2021
Excellent location. Excellent weather. Perfect family time.
5.0
Butler Beach Oceanfront Pool Home
The property is exactly as advertised. Immaculately clean and incredibly spacious. The pictures don't do it justice. Property manager was great to work with. Exceptional, fast communication and the property instructions provided by them were very detailed. Would absolutely book this home again.
5.0
Lots of room for a big group (10) that spanned 4 generations. Nice and clean, with good quality beds/pillows and plenty of extra towels. The swimming pool and private beach walkover were a hit. Ample parking for up to 6 cars. The kitchen was better equipped than other properties I have stayed at. Loved watching the sunrise over the ocean from the second floor. Terrific location and a great place to relax.
1.0
First for the pros - its a nice location and the house has direct access to the beach. The pool is also nice and heated. For the Cons - The house looks good in the pictures but is outdated and needs to be updated. Also, there are rules to the house that are not provided before you book. For instance, they require you to keep the temperature of the house at 72 and say how if its lower the ac unit may freeze. I have booked rooms in Florida, and many other places in the US and never have I seen this rule. Second, they charge a cleaning fee, however, the house is not in a clean condition once you get there, for instance, we found cockroaches in one room. And they require you to do a load in the dishwasher and laundry of the towels. I was also disappointed in that they charge a fee for the use of the heater for the pool. They charged to heat the pool to a temperature of 88. Again, i've stayed in many VRBOs and ABNBs and recently one in Miami and they did not charge for the heated pool. Honestly, there are better new houses, cleaner, and more accommodating then my experience with this house. Just request all the rules upfront before you book. I wouldn't recommend this place.
1.0
Not Worth It
First for the pros - its a nice location and the house has direct access to the beach. The pool is also nice and heated. For the Cons - The house looks good in the pictures but is outdated and needs to be updated. Also, there are rules to the house that are not provided before you book. For instance, they require you to keep the temperature of the house at 72 and say how if its lower the ac unit may freeze. I have booked rooms in Florida, and many other places in the US and never have I seen this rule. Second, they charge a cleaning fee, however, the house is not in a clean condition once you get there, for instance, we found cockroaches in one room. And they require you to do a load in the dishwasher and laundry of the towels. I was also disappointed in that they charge a fee for the use of the heater for the pool. They charged to heat the pool to a temperature of 88. Again, i've stayed in many VRBOs and ABNBs and recently one in Miami and they did not charge for the heated pool. Honestly, there are better new houses, cleaner, and more accommodating then my experience with this house. Just request all the rules upfront before you book. I wouldn't recommend this place.
5.0
Multi-generation Family Vacation
Lots of room for a big group (10) that spanned 4 generations. Nice and clean, with good quality beds/pillows and plenty of extra towels. The swimming pool and private beach walkover were a hit. Ample parking for up to 6 cars. The kitchen was better equipped than other properties I have stayed at. Loved watching the sunrise over the ocean from the second floor. Terrific location and a great place to relax.
5.0
Beautiful Oceanfront Pool Home
5.0
Great place for a family
Beautiful Oceanfront Pool Home
5.0
Paradise by the Sea
One of the best values in the entire area. Everything was clean and done professionally. We enjoyed the views and the closeness to the beach. And I could comfortably sleep the eight people we had. Thanks to the owners!
5.0
Family togetherness
The house was roomy and great, very comfortable. Direct beach access was great and we may not be able to vacation any other way from now on. We practically had the beach to ourselves.
5.0
Turtle Oasis
The house was just perfect for our 2 family vacation to the beach. We enjoyed having a private walk to the beach and seeing the beautiful turtles that lined the boardwalk. The house itself has the usual “beach vacation” rustic charm, and could use a few updates but overall, we were very pleased with it.
5.0
Beautiful Home and Town
Absolutely loved and enjoyed every moment of this property and location. Direct ocean views and extremely clean house!! This was my second rental working with Marty who is wonderful! Will definitely be back.
2.5
This House is very good and it has easy access to Beach that was awesome.
5.0
Perfect Location
The location of this home is ideal and the views are spectacular. The furniture and bedding is, however, tired. The ants around the beautiful pool were problematic. The property could use a refresh, including repainting the interior. Having said all this, we would stay here again.
5.0
Three couples stayed for a long weekend and we had a wonderful time. The house is very comfortable, clean and well-equipped. The view from the second floor is spectacular! The weather was not ideal, but being from Florida, we didn't mind just hanging out on the balcony watching the rough seas, feeling the wind, and enjoying each other's company.
5.0
Wonderful Stay!
Three couples stayed for a long weekend and we had a wonderful time. The house is very comfortable, clean and well-equipped. The view from the second floor is spectacular! The weather was not ideal, but being from Florida, we didn't mind just hanging out on the balcony watching the rough seas, feeling the wind, and enjoying each other's company.
4.0
Girls Beach Trip
The property was fantastic and meet all of our needs - beautiful house, pool, and beach access.
4.0
July 4, 2020
We booked this house last minute due to the pandemic. Overall, the house was good. The kitchen lacked adequate cookware to accommodate cooking meals for a large group, and the appliances could also use updating. The setup of the house was a little odd...no access off back deck to pool or one on the front of the house to garbage cans. The pool was great, except when it rained (which it stormed every day we were there) it got flooded with rain water which brought debris into the pool. Bring bug spray... we all got lots of bug bites! The beach was fantastic! A little pricey for the quality of the house but it was a last minute decision.
5.0
November with college kids and teens
We were visiting from Orlando to celebrate our daughter's 20th birthday. We had a party of 6 with some college kids and teenagers. The property was spotless and just what we were looking for with room to spread out. Even after viewing it on line the actual house was even better. The number of beds and bathrooms, kitchen was well stocked, the view was amazing,plenty of towels, quick access to town. We had a wonderful time and would definitely consider coming back again.
5.0
Paradise Found
We have been coming to St Augustine every summer for years, and have voted this our best trip yet! Large spacious house that had everything you could want, we loved the pool, walkover to the beach, and the beautiful beach itself. Cindy was super accommodating, we had a couple issues our first day and she was on top of it. Susie the pool lady was friendly and knowledgeable, and she took care of our issues right away. Only reason for the 4 star cleanliness rating was the pool deck and patio area could have used a good sweeping and hosing, which we did ourselves-I know, right? It’s OUTSIDE! Loved the house and area and would definitely stay here again.
5.0
Wonderful Beach Delight
Super beach house with large pool and plenty of room for 10+ people with 5 bedrooms, 6 bathrooms, fully-equipped kitchen and plenty of up-front parking room for guests and friends. Only 2 minor points: slow internet (3 mbps) and dining room which only seats 6. Other 4-person kitchen seating around sink island. Biggest negative was outrageous $500 VRBO fee tacked onto house rental.
5.0
Tobundaffer vaca
We all had a wonderful time. Pool at house was great when too hot on beach. The bunk room was a smaller room than expected so only accommodated small children. Rental company worked great for grill. As stated in other reviews the internet just doesn’t work very well.
5.0
Excellent beach house
We’ve been staying in st Augustine for over 15 years and this is by far the best property we’ve had! Nice large pool, plenty of room, stocked full of amenities and my handicapped grandparent could easily enjoy her week with walk in showers and beds on first floor. We even had a partial power outage (something to do with the meter) it was quickly and Efficiently repaired! Great stay!
4.0
Great beach front - horrible internet
Location on beach terrific. Beach very wide and private. Excellent for young children to walk out very far in shallow water. House spacious - acceptable beach house furniture. Internet mostly non existent. We waited several hours for
AT&T technician only to be informed service needs to be upgraded. If you need internet, skip this property.
5.0
Location Location Location
Wow - great home in very good shape with all the extras you need for a beach vacation! Direct access to the beach and a large pool to play in.
FAQs
How much does this house cost compared to others in Butler Beach?
The average price for a rental in Butler Beach is $238 per night. This rental is $846 above the average.
Is parking included with this house?
Yes, parking is listed as an amenity at Beautiful Oceanfront Pool Home ~ Private Boardwalk ~ Sugar Sand Beach. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.
Is there a pool at this house?
Yes, a swimming pool is available for use at Beautiful Oceanfront Pool Home ~ Private Boardwalk ~ Sugar Sand Beach. Enjoy the water!
Is Beautiful Oceanfront Pool Home ~ Private Boardwalk ~ Sugar Sand Beach pet friendly?
Unfortunately, this house is not pet-friendly. Try searching again and filter for "Pets Allowed"
What amenities are available at Beautiful Oceanfront Pool Home ~ Private Boardwalk ~ Sugar Sand Beach?
We found 9 amenities for this rental. This includes pool, air conditioner, kitchen / kitchenette, internet / wifi, and parking.
Butler Beach travel inspiration
Read our blogGuides
Ski Trip Packing List: What to Bring Skiing or Snowboarding
Trends
VacationRenter Holiday Travel Trends 2023
Featured Rentals
Architectural Vacation Rentals: Experience the Beauty of Unique Properties
Featured Rentals
Sustainable and Eco-Friendly Vacation Rentals Around the World
Featured Rentals
Our Favorite Vacation Rentals With Unique Experiences
Featured Rentals
Amazing Cabin Rentals Across the Globe
Featured Rentals
Have You Ever Wanted to Stay in a Dome Rental? Now You Can
Featured Rentals
Jaw Dropping Treehouse Rentals All Over the World