House in New York
10 guests · 5 bedrooms · 5 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Top-tier experienceA high end property in this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
Captain's Lookout, locally owned and operated by Cooperstown Baseball Rentals, is a spacious 5-bedroom, 5-bath waterfront home overlooking Goodyear Lake. Sleeping up to 10 guests, it offers beautiful lake views, multiple outdoor living areas, and plenty of space for families traveling together.
Conveniently located between Cooperstown and Oneonta, the home is 10.6 miles from Cooperstown Dreams Park and 11.3 miles from Cooperstown All Star Village — making it a great choice for tournament families who want to combine baseball with a relaxing lake vacation.
The 2,125-square-foot home is arranged over two levels, providing families with room to spread out. The main level features a spacious open living area, fully equipped kitchen, dining area, wet bar with quartz countertop, two queen bedrooms with private bathrooms, and an additional full bathroom with a whirlpool tub.
The lower level offers additional living and recreation space, including two king bedrooms, a twin bedroom, game area with foosball, summer kitchen, and laundry facilities. With five full bathrooms and multiple living areas, Captain's Lookout works especially well for two or three families sharing a home.
Outside, a series of multi-tiered decks overlook Goodyear Lake, with space for outdoor dining, grilling, morning coffee, or simply enjoying the view. At the private waterfront, guests can enjoy two kayaks, a fire pit, fishing poles, and the peaceful lake setting.
Additional conveniences include central air conditioning, high-speed Wi-Fi, Smart Roku TVs throughout the home, heated bathroom floors, laundry facilities on both levels, a Weber gas grill, and parking for 4–5 vehicles.
Captain's Lookout offers the best of both worlds — convenient access to the area's baseball tournaments with the space, scenery, and private waterfront setting to make the rest of your family's trip feel like a vacation.
Conveniently located between Cooperstown and Oneonta, the home is 10.6 miles from Cooperstown Dreams Park and 11.3 miles from Cooperstown All Star Village — making it a great choice for tournament families who want to combine baseball with a relaxing lake vacation.
The 2,125-square-foot home is arranged over two levels, providing families with room to spread out. The main level features a spacious open living area, fully equipped kitchen, dining area, wet bar with quartz countertop, two queen bedrooms with private bathrooms, and an additional full bathroom with a whirlpool tub.
The lower level offers additional living and recreation space, including two king bedrooms, a twin bedroom, game area with foosball, summer kitchen, and laundry facilities. With five full bathrooms and multiple living areas, Captain's Lookout works especially well for two or three families sharing a home.
Outside, a series of multi-tiered decks overlook Goodyear Lake, with space for outdoor dining, grilling, morning coffee, or simply enjoying the view. At the private waterfront, guests can enjoy two kayaks, a fire pit, fishing poles, and the peaceful lake setting.
Additional conveniences include central air conditioning, high-speed Wi-Fi, Smart Roku TVs throughout the home, heated bathroom floors, laundry facilities on both levels, a Weber gas grill, and parking for 4–5 vehicles.
Captain's Lookout offers the best of both worlds — convenient access to the area's baseball tournaments with the space, scenery, and private waterfront setting to make the rest of your family's trip feel like a vacation.
Amenities
Non-smoking
No pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of New York
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Aug 2025
This property was perfect for our Cooperstown Dreams Park stay. We stayed with two other families. Each bedroom has its own bathroom which is ideal for multiple families staying together. The property was clean, air-conditioned, Wi-Fi enabled, and on the water. Towels and bedsheets were provided. We chose not to swim in the lake but did use the kayaks that the property offered. I would definitely look to stay at this property again when I come back to Cooperstown with my younger son in two years.
10 / 10Outstanding·Sep 2024
The house was great for families. Easy drive to All Star Village. Loved the fact the house had kayaks and tubes available to use for guests. Had two problems and they were addressed immediately by owner. Sent a text and he responded very quickly and fixed issue. Would definitely stay there again.
10 / 10Outstanding·Jun 2024
The house was a perfect fit for our group of 10. Enough space for everyone to spread out, but also come together and hang out. The property management was very responsive when we had a problem or question. Would definitely recommend this company and stay here again!
10 / 10Outstanding·Aug 2023
Everyone in our group had a great time here. We were here for Cooperstown Dream Park. It was so nice to spend time on the lake when we were not at the ball park. We fished and kayaked on the lake. The house was very large allowing us to spread out. The property is very well taken care of. Jerry's team makes sure that you have a good time and you can tell that this is a very well run business. We plan to stay here again in two years if my other grandson plays ball here.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
10Outstanding
(11 Ratings)
"This property was perfect for our Cooperstown Dreams Park stay. We stayed with two other families. Each bedroom has its own bathroom which is ideal for multiple families staying together. The prope..."
Natasha B.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
