Instructions were sent with pictures for self check-in. Nice mixture of hotel style and quality rooms and bathrooms and amenities, home-like living room and kitchen. Nice welcome package, and many spices available in the kitchen. Quiet, residential area. Will comfortably fit a family of four.

You really should have a car. There is a large Tesco Extra 15 minutes' walk away. You can probably get around with public transportation, but it does not look very convenient. There is a washing machine but no dryer, and this is humid Scotland so things dry more slowly.

Very spacious and comfortable apartment. It was light and airy. Couldn’t really find much wrong with it. Good value for money.

clean, light and comfortable everything looked as in the photos Kashif is very reactive and the communication for check in and check out was excellent parking place available next to the back door no traffic , just a quiet street plenty of eating options around

there is nothing I can say ‘I did not like’ , but just a couple of comments: 1-the apartment is at the first floor without elevator (to take into account when having luggage) 2-the boiler is in the wall between the kitchen and the twin bedroom and it is quite noisy when it switches on during the nigh

very convenient location. Property is well presented with all required amenities. Very clean. excellent quality linen. one of the best apartments we stayed in the recent past.

Modern, clean and quality amenities.

beautiful property well equipped and perfect location for our stay

all of the above

beautifully appointed bright clean and spacious.

everything was great.

Very roomy, new everything and loaded with amenities. Very hard to fault. It was like living in a 4 star hotel. A great place to take the train into Edinburgh

Bathrooms were well appointed and bed linen was good quality

Entrance area and shared space in poor condition, broken window at Front door. Doors propped open by stones, poor security as a result. Host was very unhelpful when there was an issue with the booking and it was cancelled in error by Booking.com. Did not reply to my phone call as promised and i then had to rebook at the last minute at an inflated cost, very disappointed indeed as he did not honour original booking.