House in Islamorada, FL
10 guests · 5 bedrooms · 4 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
Top-tier experienceA high end property in this area
About this house rental
Welcome to Alligator Reef Estate, a gated oceanfront property in Islamorada offering two homes on one beautiful waterfront parcel—perfect for larger families or groups looking to enjoy the Florida Keys together while still having their own space.
The estate includes the Conch Home, a 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom home featuring a private fenced heated and chilled pool, outdoor kitchen and bar area, ping pong table, and bicycles for exploring the area. Just in front of it sits the Lobster Home, a comfortable 2 bedroom, 2 bathroom home that provides additional space for guests.
Together, the property offers 5 bedrooms and 4 bathrooms, making it ideal for group vacations, family gatherings, or multiple families traveling together.
Both homes share the beautiful oceanfront grounds which include a sandy lounging area, fire pit, observation dock, and kayaks and paddleboards for enjoying the clear waters of the Keys. Whether you're relaxing by the pool, gathering around the fire pit at sunset, or launching a paddleboard from the shore, there's something here for everyone.
Alligator Reef Estate offers the perfect balance of privacy, space, and true island living—creating a one-of-a-kind Florida Keys getaway right on the ocean.
VACATION RENTAL LICENSE: 24-0389 Per Islamorada's vacation rental ordinances for weekly rentals 2 people per bedroom are allowed, and 2 additional guests if under the age of 6.
If booking more than a year in advance current prices may not reflect the annual cost of living increase.
Many of our guests' re-book the same property on an annual basis. No reservation is confirmed until you speak with us.
Please note: before proceeding with your booking, kindly review the following information. This property is managed by a local Islamorada rental company, Freewheeler Vacations. Payments for your vacation rental will be made thru Freewheeler Vacations. You will also see a charge from VRBO which covers their booking service fee which is already included in the total cost. We prefer payments via personal check or eCheck. However, if you opt to pay by credit card, a 3% convenience fee will be applied to your rental. You will receive the Freewheeler Vacations Vacation Rental Agreement via email, which must be signed before your arrival. All future correspondence will be made through Freewheeler Vacations.
The estate includes the Conch Home, a 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom home featuring a private fenced heated and chilled pool, outdoor kitchen and bar area, ping pong table, and bicycles for exploring the area. Just in front of it sits the Lobster Home, a comfortable 2 bedroom, 2 bathroom home that provides additional space for guests.
Together, the property offers 5 bedrooms and 4 bathrooms, making it ideal for group vacations, family gatherings, or multiple families traveling together.
Both homes share the beautiful oceanfront grounds which include a sandy lounging area, fire pit, observation dock, and kayaks and paddleboards for enjoying the clear waters of the Keys. Whether you're relaxing by the pool, gathering around the fire pit at sunset, or launching a paddleboard from the shore, there's something here for everyone.
Alligator Reef Estate offers the perfect balance of privacy, space, and true island living—creating a one-of-a-kind Florida Keys getaway right on the ocean.
VACATION RENTAL LICENSE: 24-0389 Per Islamorada's vacation rental ordinances for weekly rentals 2 people per bedroom are allowed, and 2 additional guests if under the age of 6.
If booking more than a year in advance current prices may not reflect the annual cost of living increase.
Many of our guests' re-book the same property on an annual basis. No reservation is confirmed until you speak with us.
Please note: before proceeding with your booking, kindly review the following information. This property is managed by a local Islamorada rental company, Freewheeler Vacations. Payments for your vacation rental will be made thru Freewheeler Vacations. You will also see a charge from VRBO which covers their booking service fee which is already included in the total cost. We prefer payments via personal check or eCheck. However, if you opt to pay by credit card, a 3% convenience fee will be applied to your rental. You will receive the Freewheeler Vacations Vacation Rental Agreement via email, which must be signed before your arrival. All future correspondence will be made through Freewheeler Vacations.
Amenities
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
Map of Islamorada, FL
Ratings and reviews
Summary of reviewsGuests enjoyed the lovely stay, outstanding pool area, kayaks, and the overall perfect vacation. Highly recommend.
10 / 10Outstanding·Oct 2025
This was the ideal spot for our family. We were able to combine a vacation with the wedding we were there to attend and this location was perfect.
8 / 10Excellent·Aug 2025
Various items need to be fixed or addressed to make the home safer and more enjoyable - lightbulbs in multiple locations (like downstairs bathroom), a bedroom fan that barely works, a toilet that barely flushes, a bathtub that struggles to drain, an outlet with exposed wires)
10 / 10Outstanding·Dec 2024
We’ve stayed in a lot of vrbos and this had the most well equipped kitchen we’ve ever had. Lovely home with views of the ocean. A heated pool, kayaks and paddle boards kept us well entertained. Lots of good nearby restaurants (lazy days was our favorite). Our contact Courtney was so quick to respond to any questions we had. All in all a perfect vacation!
6 / 10Average·Jul 2022
We had a very good week at the house. A few issues but we adapted. A lot of small repairs need to be made ask over the house. The grills were filthy and they looked like they haven’t been cleaned in a long time. Shower door rollers are missing and doors are about to fall off. When we arrived the cleaning crew forgot to leave any toilet paper or paper towels anywhere. A/C’s struggled to cool down the houses. Pool is very hot and could use a chiller to make it comfortable. The red kayak has a hole in it and sunk with someone in it about 100 yards offshore. A few other small things need fixing but it is a nice place with a lot of potential just needs a little TLC
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.1Outstanding
(12 Ratings)
Guests enjoyed the lovely stay, outstanding pool area, kayaks, and the overall perfect vacation. Highly recommend.
From real guest reviews summarized by AIDon't miss out! Price and availability may change
