The Menhaden

Deluxe Room, 1 King Bed | 1 bedroom, premium bedding, down comforters, memory foam beds

Rainfall showerhead, designer toiletries, hair dryer, bathrobes

1 bedroom, premium bedding, down comforters, memory foam beds

About this hotel

Situated in Greenport, this attractive hotel for $240 per night is a great choice for your next vacation. Comfortable hotel with free breakfast and rooftop terrace Along with a restaurant, this smoke-free hotel has a bar/lounge and a snack bar/deli. Self-serve breakfast is free. Other amenities include a rooftop terrace, a coffee shop/cafe, and a refrigerator in a common area. The Menhaden offers 16 accommodations with complimentary bottled water and bathrobes. Each accommodation is individually furnished and decorated. Memory foam beds feature down comforters and premium bedding. 40-inch Smart televisions come with cable channels and Netflix. Bathrooms include bathtubs or showers with rainfall showerheads, designer toiletries, complimentary toiletries, and hair dryers. Hypo-allergenic bedding and irons/ironing boards can be requested. Housekeeping is provided daily. Recreational amenities at the hotel include complimentary bicycles. The recreational activities listed below are available either on site or nearby; fees may apply.

Amenities

Pool

Air conditioner

Laundry

Map of Greenport, NY

Nearby attractions

Montauk Point State Park

25.24 miles

Mystic Aquarium

28.40 miles

Gillette Castle State Park

22.47 miles

Montauk Lighthouse Museum

26.40 miles

The Menhaden

4.7

Outstanding(91 Reviews)

Hotel in Greenport, NY

3-Star Hotel

Reasons to book

People love it hereGuests give this property a top rating

Includes essentialsPool, Air conditioner, TV and more

Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental

$$$$

About this hotel

Amenities

Pool

Air conditioner

Laundry

Map of Greenport, NY

Nearby attractions

Montauk Point State Park

25.24 miles

Mystic Aquarium

28.40 miles

Gillette Castle State Park

22.47 miles

Montauk Lighthouse Museum

26.40 miles

Reviews

4.7/5.0

Outstanding(91 Reviews)

3.0

Dec 2023

Perfect for a 3 day getaway! Beautiful hotel, helpful and friendly staff, lovely amenities, all in a charming town.

10.0

Nov 2023

Very nice property and in a good location. Great amenities and extras like complimentary snacks and teas and coffees on each floor. There was a bit of street noise that was loud at times, but otherwise a great stay.

3.0

Oct 2023

First class. Clean, extremely helpful, great location.

4.0

Oct 2023

Beautiful hotel, with a B & B vibe. Good privacy. They impose a destination/ amenity fee scam, that is supposed to cover stuff that traditionally would be included in a hotel's advertised price, which makes the hotel very pricey. Our room had no water view, but instead over looked a busy downtown street that was an early morning access road to the ferry. Each floor has a snack station in a hallway alcove, loaded with "complementary" snacks, coffee/tea, yogurt, fruit, candy, and fresh baked chocolate chip cookies. Eat your fill: you pay for it in spades with the silly fees.

5.0

Oct 2023

The property was fantastic The staff was amazing! If I could Nachi, the rest of the staff, and the hotel 6 stars I would.

3.0

Oct 2023

The hotel was great, great location, great vibe, great rooms, and all around very clean. More over the service was above and beyond. I will definitely be going back to this hotel.

5.0

Sep 2023

Really nice stay! Will be repeating!

5.0

Sep 2023

Great walkable modern hotel with an attentive staff!

3.0

Aug 2023

We loved everything about our stay - the staff is unbelievably courteous, helpful and friendly, from the GM Mario who is hands on with an effortless 5-star service mentality all the way down. Every detail of the hotel is thoughtful and elevated in a warm and inviting way - the place is unbelievably charming and welcoming. From the lobby, bar, galleys, room, and rooftop deck - even the stairwell with plush deep blue carpet and skylight is a nice touch that didn’t go unnoticed. Being right in the heart of town, but an easy walk to the dock, was fantastic as Greenport has really grown into its own with nice shops and great restaurants. We can’t wait to return next year!

3.0

Jul 2023

We had a wonderful stay in this ultra clean and ultra chic hotel. We had an emergency that required lots of printing, scanning, and notarizing which Mario the manager helped us with all day. He also arranged a great "oyster experience " with Founders Oyster Farm and a last minute late dinner reservation. The hotel is conveniently located for walking around Greenport. They have hot croissants, yogurt, coffee, juice early each morning on each floor. Then later, there are snacks and delicious hot cookies. Tea, coffee, cold drinks also. There is a large bar/hang out area where one can order a drink, or go across the street to the various delis and being a meal in. Also, a lovely coffee shop with all barista choices and charcuterie, cheese, snack.

5.0

Jul 2023

Lovely Boutique hotel in downtown Greenport! I will be back 😊

5.0

Jul 2023

Great spot. Everything was perfect.

3.0

Apr 2023

Fabulous hotel in a great location. Employees were so helpful, Nachi at the front desk was just wonderful. Looking forward to next visit!

5.0

Mar 2023

Loved our room !!

5.0

Jan 2023

This is one of the best hotels I've ever stayed at. Incredibly friendly service, the amenities were second to none, and the location was absolutely perfect.

5.0

Jan 2023

Great

10.0

Jan 2023

Immaculate hotel with kind staff

4.0

Jan 2023

Centrally located boutique hotel with a B&b vibe. Friendly helpful staff.

3.0

Jan 2023

The best hotel experience ever. Mario, John and crew took amazing personal care of every detail. Champagne on arrival. Reservations for dinner. I even forgot my wallet and Mario offered to lend me cash. UNHEARD OF! Thank you guys for a fabulous stay!

2.0

Jan 2023

I rarely post reviews but this is warranted. Menhaden very nice upscale place but they need to address customer service, specifically the issue of a $35 amenity fee. We noticed on our invoice and inquired what it consists of. We were told it covers parking (parking lot was full- parked in street), WiFi (this is free in every hotel I’ve ever stayed in), and access to the galley (we were told at checkin this was complimentary). When we raised these issues we received a surprising amount of push back. Overall it’s a deceptive practice and the hotel should consider how it treats its guests. They eventually offered a $75 gift card in lieu of a credit, do not think we’ll return based on how they treated us.

5.0

Nov 2022

Love the personal touches and staff of this hotel. Beautifully appointed. Great amenities, including rooftop firepit overlooking bay.

2.0

Nov 2022

Horribly overpriced. the final financial insult was the $35 per person ‘amenities’ charge. We were led to believe the ‘galley’ was a supply of ‘complimentary’ coffee and snacks. On top of paying a ridiculous $300 per room, this was a blow.

5.0

Nov 2022

I have never been more impressed than with this hotel. From the fresh croissants to warm cookies at night and to all the details in between.

5.0

Oct 2022

Wonderful stay at the Menhaden! Five star service all around. We can’t wait to come back!

3.0

Aug 2022

Great stay. Clean, new hotel with friendly staff. Tastefully decorated common space with nice rooftop desk. Complimentary pantry on each floor. Quiet and convenient.

2.0

Aug 2022

Zero room amenities for a over priced tiny room.

5.0

Jul 2022

Amazing Hotel, staff, location

4.0

Jul 2022

The Menhaden is a beautiful property with high-end, chic decor. The amenities cost may not reflect the food and beverage choices (which are very nice), but the bicycles and roof deck are very great touches. Unfortunately, our room on the upper floor was quite noisy as we were below the main air handling units. For an "eco-friendly" place it was odd to walk into the common spaces on the main floor which are kept at well under 70 degrees and then to find that the front door remained open, streaming out cold air on a warm summer day. Disconcerting. When we entered our room it was 69 degrees. Prices are on the high side for this area but the hotel is very good overall.

5.0

Jul 2022

There is only 16 rooms in this boutique hotel making it intermit and charming. The hotel manager, Mario, and staff Colin were off the chart great. I especially like the homemade cookies by the rooftop deck with a view of the water and firepits. Each floor has a well stocked galley. This will now be a yearly stop for me! P.S. did I mention the Renovation Hardware furnishings in the rooms. Classy

5.0

May 2022

This cute boutique hotel is centrally located in Greenport. You can walk to restaurants, brewery, shops and local attractions! It has a beautiful rooftop overlooking the water, where you can relax during the day or at night by fire pit. The manager, Mario, was just terrific. He went out of his way to make sure we got a tour of the hotel and that all our needs were met. The staff is very friendly and very accommodating as well!!! Would highly recommend staying at the Menhaden:)

5.0

May 2022

Amazing Time

5.0

Apr 2022

We visited menhaden this past wknd. The hotel is very clean and comfortable. They have a galley kitchen in the hallway that has a lot of “ goodies” for you to grab and go. Mario at the front desk is extremely helpful and pleasant. We would always get a huge hello and he would ask us what are plans were for the day. Extremely helpful in recommendations. The hotel is located near shops, bars and restaurants- very walkable. Wineries are a bit farther away. I would recommend this hotel and we will certainly be back!!

5.0

Mar 2022

This is a quiet, beautiful hotel right in the center of Greenport village. The staff is personable and helpful. There are restaurants bars and shops right on the same block. The ferry and a park over looking the peconic and shelter island are also steps away. I would definitely stay here again

5.0

Nov 2021

Excellent, responsive staff. Beautiful property. Especially likely the rooftop sunset views with the fire pits.

3.0

Sep 2021

Quick anniversary night get away! Location was great, rooftop was amazing, and staff was super helpful! Made our stay special and memorable! Cant wait to go back for 2 nights!! Or more!

4.0

Aug 2021

Quite a charming place, comfy bed and nice touches. I was disappointed that there was no exhaust fan in the bathroom though. Would expect that with a higher end hotel.

4.0

Aug 2021

Quite a charming place, comfy bed and nice touches. I was disappointed that there was no exhaust fan in the bathroom though. Would expect that with a higher end hotel.

4.0

Jul 2021

The room and service was great. I loved getting coffee in the Galley. I wish there was a pool

5.0

Jul 2021

This hotel was incredible. By far the best on the North Fork. A must for anyone looking for an upscale lodging experience

5.0

Jul 2021

This hotel was incredible. By far the best on the North Fork. A must for anyone looking for an upscale lodging experience

FAQs

How much does this hotel cost compared to others in Greenport?

The average price for a rental in Greenport is $386 per night. This rental is $146 less expensive than the average.

Is parking included with this hotel?

Parking is not specified as an available amenity at The Menhaden. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.

Is there a pool at this hotel?

Yes, a swimming pool is available for use at The Menhaden. Enjoy the water!

Is The Menhaden pet friendly?

Unfortunately, this hotel is not pet-friendly. Try searching again and filter for "Pets Allowed"

What amenities are available at The Menhaden?

We found 4 amenities for this rental. This includes pool, air conditioner, laundry, and tv.

Explore similar vacation rentals in Greenport

Explore all rentals in Greenport

4.7

Outstanding(115 Reviews)

The Menhaden

About this hotel

Amenities

Map of Greenport, NY

Nearby attractions

The Menhaden

Hotel in Greenport, NY

Reasons to book

About this hotel

Amenities

Map of Greenport, NY

Nearby attractions

Reviews

FAQs

How much does this hotel cost compared to others in Greenport?

Is parking included with this hotel?

Is there a pool at this hotel?

Is The Menhaden pet friendly?

What amenities are available at The Menhaden?

Explore similar vacation rentals in Greenport

Greenport travel inspiration

Related vacation destinations

Keep exploring