House in Bahamas
6 guests · 2 bedrooms · 1 bath
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
High-end valueWell priced for this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
Paradise Found: Private Beachfront Escape in Mangrove Cay, Andros Island
Welcome to your private Bahamian retreat in beautiful Mangrove Cay, Andros Island, where adventure, relaxation, and natural beauty come together. Situated on a secluded two-acre beachfront property, this charming two-bedroom getaway offers the ultimate island experience with your own private beach, crystal-clear turquoise waters, and endless opportunities to explore one of the most spectacular marine environments in the world.
Just offshore lies the third-largest barrier reef on the planet, making this a dream destination for snorkeling, spearfishing, lobster diving, and marine life encounters. Swim alongside colorful tropical fish, sea turtles, rays, and vibrant coral reefs in some of the clearest waters you'll ever see.
For anglers, Andros is internationally renowned for its world-class bone fishing, attracting fishing enthusiasts from around the globe. Adventure seekers can also discover the island's legendary Blue Holes, a world-famous natural wonder unique to the Bahamas.
Spend your days paddleboarding, kayaking, beachcombing, or simply relaxing on your private stretch of shoreline. In the evenings, unwind on the spacious outdoor patio, enjoy the ocean breeze, and take in breathtaking sunsets under a canopy of stars.
Conveniently located just 300 yards from Mangrove Cay Airport, arrival couldn't be easier. Taxi service is readily available, and nearby grocery stores provide everything you need for a comfortable stay. The island's friendly and welcoming locals are always eager to help visitors discover the best of Andros.
Whether you're looking for a fishing adventure, an underwater playground, or a peaceful beachfront escape, you'll have all the comforts of home, including reliable Starlink high-speed internet, while surrounded by some of the most untouched beauty in the Caribbean.
Come experience the magic of Andros Island, where turquoise waters, pristine beaches, and unforgettable adventures await right outside your door.
Welcome to your private Bahamian retreat in beautiful Mangrove Cay, Andros Island, where adventure, relaxation, and natural beauty come together. Situated on a secluded two-acre beachfront property, this charming two-bedroom getaway offers the ultimate island experience with your own private beach, crystal-clear turquoise waters, and endless opportunities to explore one of the most spectacular marine environments in the world.
Just offshore lies the third-largest barrier reef on the planet, making this a dream destination for snorkeling, spearfishing, lobster diving, and marine life encounters. Swim alongside colorful tropical fish, sea turtles, rays, and vibrant coral reefs in some of the clearest waters you'll ever see.
For anglers, Andros is internationally renowned for its world-class bone fishing, attracting fishing enthusiasts from around the globe. Adventure seekers can also discover the island's legendary Blue Holes, a world-famous natural wonder unique to the Bahamas.
Spend your days paddleboarding, kayaking, beachcombing, or simply relaxing on your private stretch of shoreline. In the evenings, unwind on the spacious outdoor patio, enjoy the ocean breeze, and take in breathtaking sunsets under a canopy of stars.
Conveniently located just 300 yards from Mangrove Cay Airport, arrival couldn't be easier. Taxi service is readily available, and nearby grocery stores provide everything you need for a comfortable stay. The island's friendly and welcoming locals are always eager to help visitors discover the best of Andros.
Whether you're looking for a fishing adventure, an underwater playground, or a peaceful beachfront escape, you'll have all the comforts of home, including reliable Starlink high-speed internet, while surrounded by some of the most untouched beauty in the Caribbean.
Come experience the magic of Andros Island, where turquoise waters, pristine beaches, and unforgettable adventures await right outside your door.
Amenities
Non-smoking
No pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Bahamas
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Jan 2026
We spent the first week of the New Year on Mangrove Cay at Scott’s house and had an incredible experience. The home is clean, comfortable, and thoughtfully equipped for island living. We were two couples, and although there’s one shared bathroom, the layout allows for plenty of privacy. The kitchen has everything needed for cooking, which mattered to us since we prefer making meals at home. The AC is ice cold, the beds are comfortable, and the sunrise views from the property are stunning. The private beach access made every morning feel special.The house also comes with excellent outdoor gear — paddle boards, a two-person kayak, snorkeling equipment, games, and more — which we used daily.What truly sets this stay apart is Scott. He is the best host we’ve ever had. Before arrival, he scheduled a Zoom call to walk us through the home and the island. During our stay, he checked in regularly and responded instantly to any questions. He even arranged a surprise birthday dinner for one of our group at Swain’s Cay Resort. That level of care is rare.Scott’s property manager Randy is also fantastic — a local fishing guide who took us snorkeling and lobster spearing. He embodies the warmth of the Mangrove Cay community. This island is not touristy — it’s quiet, authentic, and off the beaten path. We saw no other tourists, only friendly locals who made us feel at home.This was a top-tier stay in our travels, and we absolutely plan to return. If you’re looking for a true, private
10 / 10Outstanding·May 2025
Great kitchen, good beds. If you want to lay around in a lovely setting, catch bonefish (with guide), snorkel, spear fish (Hawaiian sling only), eat great Bahamian fish stew (Deanna’s), this is the place. Laid back wonderful community of Bahamians, this location, right on theMiddle Bught of Andros Island, is 15-20 minutes to good bone fishing. The fabulous westside of Andros is only 45 minutes away, unlike the Behring Point-Cargill Creek area, which is an hour and 45 minutes away from the west side by boat. Highly recommended.
10 / 10Outstanding·Apr 2025
Took the family during April break. Scott is a superstar host, excellent communication both before trip (including showing me around via Google maps, giving lots of recs, etc) and checking in during. House is in great shape, excellent location - can walk from airport, but wouldn't know you were near it once at location. Really quiet and peaceful - all you'll hear is wind, waves, and birds. Beach right there - a bit of seagrass in front but can get past easily or wander down to a more open area. On our trip, the weather didn't cooperate as quite windy, which scratched our plans for a lot of snorkling - however we got in a great morning fishing with local guides, and another afternoon paddling out to nearby island. Best part #1 is the locals - people were very friendly and kind to us, really went out of their way to help with meals, directions, etc. Best part #2 (and be aware) is that Middle Cay is NOT touristy at all - aside from people at the small fishing lodges, there were no other tourists to be seen. Dining and grocery options are limited and very small, but food is great (Shine's fresh conch salad, Deanna's Cafe). For us that was perfect. No milk to be had the entire week, so plan accordingly!
10 / 10Outstanding·Apr 2025
I only have accolades for both Scott, our host and our fishing guide / property caretaker Randy. Scott was very helpful, communicative and available for any questions and was super quick to respond! The location of his cottage is in walking distance to the airport, situated right on the water with very friendly neighbors. Always a breeze, sandy walkable beach with a double kayak stand-up paddle boards outfitted for fishing, snorkel equipment and Adirondack chairs to take in the views and beach cruiser bikes for exploring the island.He goes the extra mile by setting up a zoom call prior to arrival to map out all the island highlights including markets for basic needs, liquor stores, restaurants offering to make dinner reservations for us at Swains fishing lodge using Harry for taxi transport during our stay.Randy is not only a local expert fishing guide who knows everything about the island but is a really fun guy to spend time with! Always came with a smile a laugh and catered to our every need.By the time we left, a little over a week stay, we knew everyone on the island and they knew us. We’d just say we’re staying at Scotts and they all welcomed us. Not to be missed is Shines local hangout where you’ll find Rochelle serving up cold beers and the best conch salad. They even cooked up our lobster we caught.Randy will always put you on fish - The little island of Mangrove Cay earned its name as “the bone fishing capItal of the world” we’ll definitely be back !
$$$$
Top rated by guests
10Outstanding
(6 Ratings)
"We spent the first week of the New Year on Mangrove Cay at Scott’s house and had an incredible experience. The home is clean, comfortable, and thoughtfully equipped for island living. We were two coup..."
Sean M.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
