House in North Eleuthera
17 guests · 7 bedrooms · 6 baths
Reasons to book
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
Top-tier experienceA high end property in this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
Rooms
Bedroom 1
1 King
Bedroom 2
2 Doubles
Bedroom 3
2 Singles
Bedroom 4
1 King
Bedroom 5
1 King
Bedroom 6
2 Doubles
Bedroom 7
1 Bunk, 1 Single
About this house rental
Middle Cay - Luxurious Private Island off Harbour Island - Pool
Live Like a Billionaire on Your Own Private Island! Go all-in with every luxury or keep it simple and serene—the choice is yours. Either way, Middle Cay promises an unforgettable Caribbean holiday.
Welcome to Middle Cay, a private 2-acre island just 5 minutes by boat from iconic Harbour Island, Eleuthera. We are just a 30-minute flight from Florida. Fly into North Eleuthera Airport (ELH) via American, United, or Delta. Our team handles your swift transfer to Middle Cay, and you'll be relaxing on your own private island 15 minutes from landing.
Accommodations
Middle Cay features two open-concept villas with stunning Caribbean views from every room—perfect for multi-family escapes, groups, and milestone celebrations.
Main House
Bedroom 1 (Master): King bed, ensuite bath, dual vanity, walk-in shower, oceanfront terrace
Bedroom 2: Two full beds, ensuite bath with rain shower
Bedroom 3: Two twin beds (convertible to king), access to hallway bath with walk-in shower
Bedroom 4: King bed, ensuite bath with walk-in shower
Cottage
Bedroom 5: King bed, ensuite bath with rain shower, private balcony
Bedroom 6: Two double beds, ensuite bath with rain shower
Bedroom 7: Twin bunk + trundle, access to hallway half-bath, balcony, suitable for children only
Island Highlights:
Private sand beach
Oceanview heated pool (optional upgrade)
Two private docks
Multiple indoor & outdoor lounge areas
Alfresco dining for 16
Fire pit, BBQ grill, terrace, and beach volleyball
Giza cotton European cooling sheets
Crystal-clear waters with vibrant sea life (watch for turtles!)
Adventure Awaits
Your stay includes use of:
3 kayaks
2 paddleboards
3 underwater sea scooters
Snorkeling gear
22 ft Pursuit power boat with captain (fuel extra). Our experienced boat captains are available day or night to take you to Harbour Island, 5 minutes away, for shopping, dining, and nightlife. Transportation to and from Harbour Island at any time is included at no charge except for fuel. Boat excursions to other destinations are available for an additional charge, including sandbars, pig beach, turtle cove, fishing trips, and island hopping.
Services & Staffing Included:
Daily light-touch housekeeping (4 hours)
Boat captain
Concierge support
Available at Extra Cost:
Private chef
Butler service
Grocery provisioning
Laundry
Heated pool
Baby Sitting
Extra Housekeeping
Massages
Book Your Escape
Whether you're planning a reunion, birthday, or just need a next-level escape, Middle Cay delivers exclusivity, freedom, and tropical luxury like no other.
NOTE: Rates are for the first 6 guests. Additional guests are $150 per night per guest. If you enter your dates and number of guests, this website will calculate the total rent correctly. We set this way to make the house affordable to smaller groups which use less utilities and create less wear and tear.
Welcome to Middle Cay, a private 2-acre island just 5 minutes by boat from iconic Harbour Island, Eleuthera. We are just a 30-minute flight from Florida. Fly into North Eleuthera Airport (ELH) via American, United, or Delta. Our team handles your swift transfer to Middle Cay, and you'll be relaxing on your own private island 15 minutes from landing.
Accommodations
Middle Cay features two open-concept villas with stunning Caribbean views from every room—perfect for multi-family escapes, groups, and milestone celebrations.
Main House
Bedroom 1 (Master): King bed, ensuite bath, dual vanity, walk-in shower, oceanfront terrace
Bedroom 2: Two full beds, ensuite bath with rain shower
Bedroom 3: Two twin beds (convertible to king), access to hallway bath with walk-in shower
Bedroom 4: King bed, ensuite bath with walk-in shower
Cottage
Bedroom 5: King bed, ensuite bath with rain shower, private balcony
Bedroom 6: Two double beds, ensuite bath with rain shower
Bedroom 7: Twin bunk + trundle, access to hallway half-bath, balcony, suitable for children only
Island Highlights:
Private sand beach
Oceanview heated pool (optional upgrade)
Two private docks
Multiple indoor & outdoor lounge areas
Alfresco dining for 16
Fire pit, BBQ grill, terrace, and beach volleyball
Giza cotton European cooling sheets
Crystal-clear waters with vibrant sea life (watch for turtles!)
Adventure Awaits
Your stay includes use of:
3 kayaks
2 paddleboards
3 underwater sea scooters
Snorkeling gear
22 ft Pursuit power boat with captain (fuel extra). Our experienced boat captains are available day or night to take you to Harbour Island, 5 minutes away, for shopping, dining, and nightlife. Transportation to and from Harbour Island at any time is included at no charge except for fuel. Boat excursions to other destinations are available for an additional charge, including sandbars, pig beach, turtle cove, fishing trips, and island hopping.
Services & Staffing Included:
Daily light-touch housekeeping (4 hours)
Boat captain
Concierge support
Available at Extra Cost:
Private chef
Butler service
Grocery provisioning
Laundry
Heated pool
Baby Sitting
Extra Housekeeping
Massages
Book Your Escape
Whether you're planning a reunion, birthday, or just need a next-level escape, Middle Cay delivers exclusivity, freedom, and tropical luxury like no other.
NOTE: Rates are for the first 6 guests. Additional guests are $150 per night per guest. If you enter your dates and number of guests, this website will calculate the total rent correctly. We set this way to make the house affordable to smaller groups which use less utilities and create less wear and tear.
Amenities
Air conditioning
Pool
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
TV
Coffee/tea maker
Refrigerator
Kitchen
WiFi/Internet
Private pool access
Microwave
Dishwasher
Washing machine
Dryer
Kitchenware
Garden
Oven
Laundry services
Ocean front
Beach front
Waterfront
Shower
Outdoor Cooking
Family friendly
Dining area
Towels
Linens
Toilet
Contactless check-in/out
Fire alarm
Fire extinguisher
Carbon monoxide detector
Cleaning products
Map of North Eleuthera
Things to know
Check-in: 4:00 PM
Check-out: 10:00 AM
Early check-ins and late check-out requests will be accommodated upon request and based upon availability. Unauthorized early check-ins and late checkouts will incur a penalty fee.House rules
- Pets allowed, fees apply
- Kids allowed, fees apply
- No parties or events allowed without prior approval, fees apply
- Must be 25 or older to rent
Additional fees to expect
Cleaning & other feesWe include all stay related fees in the Cleaning Fee line, which may include cleaning, property manager, resort, tourism and other stay related fees. All RedAwning properties are professionally cleaned after each stay. In addition, RedAwning includes $3,000 USD of damage waiver coverage in the cleaning fee price in place of traditional damage deposits so you can have a carefree stay.
Booking feeNo booking fees, easy credit card payments.
Service feeThis helps RedAwning provide a safer and more secure booking experience.
TaxesTaxes on accommodation such as Occupancy Tax, VAT, or GST. May also include tourism fees.
Customer support
Customer support is handled by our partner RedAwning
- RedAwning is a trusted partner with over 1 million guests served.
- Contact RedAwning customer service 24/7 via live chat.
- No booking fees, with easy credit card payments.
About our partner
This property is managed by RedAwning - a trusted partner that has served over 1 million guests
7,000+
5-star reviews on TrustPilot
14+
Years of service
15,000+
Vacation rentals across 1,000 destinations
Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
