House in New York
8 guests · 3 bedrooms · 1 bath
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
High-end valueWell priced for this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
2027 Booking Update
Reservations for 2027 are not yet available as we complete planned waterfront improvements, including the installation of a permanent dock. We expect to open the 2027 calendar in early 2027 and look forward to welcoming guests once these exciting upgrades are complete.
Escape to the peaceful side of Fair Haven at our charming 3-bedroom waterfront cottage nestled on the shores of Blind Sodus Bay. Tucked away, this hidden gem offers the perfect blend of relaxation, boating, fishing, and family fun.
What truly sets our cottage apart is the privacy. Mature trees line both sides of the property, creating a secluded retreat where you can enjoy the beauty of the bay without feeling crowded by neighbors.
Waterfront Paradise
Step outside to your own private waterfront oasis featuring:
• Easy entry into the water
• Beautiful bay views from the backyard
• Kayak and paddle boat available for guest use
• Large waterfront yard perfect for yard games and outdoor gatherings
Spend your days boating, fishing, paddling, swimming, or simply watching the sunrise over the bay with your morning coffee.
Outdoor Living
The backyard is designed for making memories, featuring:
• Spacious waterfront lawn
• Oversized fire pit for evening campfires and s'mores
• Propane grill on the porch
• Plenty of room for family activities and outdoor dining
Comfortable Cottage Living
This family cottage has been lovingly enjoyed by our family for over 20 years, and we're excited to share it with yours.
The cottage includes:
• 3 comfortable bedrooms
• Fully equipped kitchen with stove, refrigerator, microwave, air fryer, coffee maker, cookware, and utensils
• High-speed internet
• Roku streaming devices (log into your own streaming accounts)
• Window air conditioner in the main living area (July-September)
• Ceiling fans and additional fans throughout the home
Included Water Toys
Guests are welcome to enjoy:
• Paddle boat
• Kayak
• Air compressor for inflatables and lake floats
Life jackets should always be worn when using watercraft.
Good to Know
• High-speed Wi-Fi is available throughout the cottage.
• Cell service can be limited at the property, adding to the peaceful getaway atmosphere. Text messages generally work, and service improves a short walk up the road.
• A security camera is installed on the front exterior of the home for guest and property security.
Why Guests Love Staying Here
Private waterfront location
Direct private water access
Large waterfront yard
Beautiful bay views and sunsets
Family-friendly atmosphere
Peaceful, secluded setting surrounded by trees
Kayak and paddle boat included
Minutes from Colloca Winery/Wedding Venue
Whether you're planning a family vacation, fishing trip, boating weekend, or simply looking for a quiet place to unwind by the water, our Fair Haven cottage offers the kind of waterfront experience that's becoming harder and harder to find.
Reservations for 2027 are not yet available as we complete planned waterfront improvements, including the installation of a permanent dock. We expect to open the 2027 calendar in early 2027 and look forward to welcoming guests once these exciting upgrades are complete.
Escape to the peaceful side of Fair Haven at our charming 3-bedroom waterfront cottage nestled on the shores of Blind Sodus Bay. Tucked away, this hidden gem offers the perfect blend of relaxation, boating, fishing, and family fun.
What truly sets our cottage apart is the privacy. Mature trees line both sides of the property, creating a secluded retreat where you can enjoy the beauty of the bay without feeling crowded by neighbors.
Waterfront Paradise
Step outside to your own private waterfront oasis featuring:
• Easy entry into the water
• Beautiful bay views from the backyard
• Kayak and paddle boat available for guest use
• Large waterfront yard perfect for yard games and outdoor gatherings
Spend your days boating, fishing, paddling, swimming, or simply watching the sunrise over the bay with your morning coffee.
Outdoor Living
The backyard is designed for making memories, featuring:
• Spacious waterfront lawn
• Oversized fire pit for evening campfires and s'mores
• Propane grill on the porch
• Plenty of room for family activities and outdoor dining
Comfortable Cottage Living
This family cottage has been lovingly enjoyed by our family for over 20 years, and we're excited to share it with yours.
The cottage includes:
• 3 comfortable bedrooms
• Fully equipped kitchen with stove, refrigerator, microwave, air fryer, coffee maker, cookware, and utensils
• High-speed internet
• Roku streaming devices (log into your own streaming accounts)
• Window air conditioner in the main living area (July-September)
• Ceiling fans and additional fans throughout the home
Included Water Toys
Guests are welcome to enjoy:
• Paddle boat
• Kayak
• Air compressor for inflatables and lake floats
Life jackets should always be worn when using watercraft.
Good to Know
• High-speed Wi-Fi is available throughout the cottage.
• Cell service can be limited at the property, adding to the peaceful getaway atmosphere. Text messages generally work, and service improves a short walk up the road.
• A security camera is installed on the front exterior of the home for guest and property security.
Why Guests Love Staying Here
Private waterfront location
Direct private water access
Large waterfront yard
Beautiful bay views and sunsets
Family-friendly atmosphere
Peaceful, secluded setting surrounded by trees
Kayak and paddle boat included
Minutes from Colloca Winery/Wedding Venue
Whether you're planning a family vacation, fishing trip, boating weekend, or simply looking for a quiet place to unwind by the water, our Fair Haven cottage offers the kind of waterfront experience that's becoming harder and harder to find.
Amenities
Non-smoking
No pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of New York
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Jul 2026
Blind Sodus Bay is a well kept secret as it is often overlooked in favor of neighboring Little Sodus Bay. However, during the 4th of July timeframe, Little Sodus Bay can be overwhelmed with boats. Blind Sodus Bay never got crowded. In addition, this property has one of the largest fire pits I've ever seen in a backyard. The chairs and circumference accommodated our group well as did the bedrooms, common rooms, bathrooms, and kitchen. Very clean with great instructions and communication. We hope to stay there again someday. Thank you to our hosts!
8 / 10Excellent·Jun 2026
Nice basic lake house. Great shower. Beautiful sunsets and lightning storms.
10 / 10Outstanding·Jun 2026
We enjoyed our stay. The home has a great view of the lake and is very close to the winery.
6 / 10Average·Sep 2025
Great location, beds were comfortable. Cob webs everywhere inside and out. Top of the fridge and celling fans have never been cleaned.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.4Outstanding
(71 Ratings)
"Blind Sodus Bay is a well kept secret as it is often overlooked in favor of neighboring Little Sodus Bay. However, during the 4th of July timeframe, Little Sodus Bay can be overwhelmed with boats. B..."
Heather R.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
