House in Keuka Lake, NY
6 guests · 3 bedrooms · 2 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
High-end valueWell priced for this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
Escape to the sparkling shores of Keuka Lake and discover The Irish Cardinal, your private, year-round retreat nestled in the heart of New York’s Finger Lakes. With panoramic lake views, four private permanent docks, and a cozy, fully furnished lake house, this is where memories are made.
Whether you're casting a line, gliding across the lake on our paddleboard or kayaks, or simply rocking gently on the glider bench on our upper deck, life moves slower here.
This is more than a place to stay , it's a private waterfront estate experience, ideal for couples, families, and small groups seeking a refined lakefront getaway in the Finger Lakes wine country.
Location: Just minutes from over a dozen Finger Lakes wineries and breweries, with downtown Hammondsport's restaurants and shops a short walk or drive away, ideal for wine-tasting day trips or a quiet evening out.
House rules: This is a quiet, private retreat intended for relaxing lakefront stays, please no large parties or gatherings, and be respectful of neighboring properties and the shared serenity of the lake.
Year-round availability: Whether you're visiting for summer lake days or a cozy off-season escape, The Irish Cardinal is available and ready to host you in every season.
Access: The home sits 45 steps down from the road to the water, offering 100 feet of private waterfront and complete privacy and quiet from the road above. Please plan accordingly if stairs are a concern for anyone in your group. Our home home is not handicapped or wheelchair accessible.
Cleaning fee: A $200 cleaning fee applies to every stay to ensure the home and dock area are maintained to a high standard for each guest.
Access to entire home except the owners closet on the first floor and the closet in the basement.
Whether you're casting a line, gliding across the lake on our paddleboard or kayaks, or simply rocking gently on the glider bench on our upper deck, life moves slower here.
This is more than a place to stay , it's a private waterfront estate experience, ideal for couples, families, and small groups seeking a refined lakefront getaway in the Finger Lakes wine country.
Location: Just minutes from over a dozen Finger Lakes wineries and breweries, with downtown Hammondsport's restaurants and shops a short walk or drive away, ideal for wine-tasting day trips or a quiet evening out.
House rules: This is a quiet, private retreat intended for relaxing lakefront stays, please no large parties or gatherings, and be respectful of neighboring properties and the shared serenity of the lake.
Year-round availability: Whether you're visiting for summer lake days or a cozy off-season escape, The Irish Cardinal is available and ready to host you in every season.
Access: The home sits 45 steps down from the road to the water, offering 100 feet of private waterfront and complete privacy and quiet from the road above. Please plan accordingly if stairs are a concern for anyone in your group. Our home home is not handicapped or wheelchair accessible.
Cleaning fee: A $200 cleaning fee applies to every stay to ensure the home and dock area are maintained to a high standard for each guest.
Access to entire home except the owners closet on the first floor and the closet in the basement.
Amenities
Non-smoking
No pets allowed
Map of Keuka Lake, NY
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Jul 2026
Loved our stay!! The lake is so peaceful and docks are amazing. We walked into town several times. Kayaked and swam our hearts out. We would love to visit again! Thanks for everything, Kelly!
10 / 10Outstanding·Jul 2026
It was the perfect place on the water for us to all get together! We never wanted to leave! We ended up skipping going to a winery just to hang out on the dock!
10 / 10Outstanding·Jun 2026
Irish Cardinal was such a pleasant stay! The place is even nicer in person than the photos give it credit for. Kelly was a dream to work with, and was so attentive to any questions we had. The place is immaculate and has everything you could need and more! We were even greeted with fresh flowers and extra toiletries. The little touches did not go unnoticed.We had amazing weather and spent most of our time on the lower dock. Highly recommend!
$$$$
Top rated by guests
10Outstanding
(4 Ratings)
"Loved our stay!! The lake is so peaceful and docks are amazing. We walked into town several times. Kayaked and swam our hearts out. We would love to visit again! Thanks for everything, Kelly!"
Lauren B.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
