Bed and Breakfast in Shelter Island, NY
4-Star Bed & Breakfast
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
High-end valueWell priced for this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this bed and breakfast
Elegant Accommodations
Amenities
Golf course (within 2 mi)
Free WiFi/internet
Free Parking
Air conditioning
Non-smoking
Heating
Balcony/Terrace
WiFi/Internet
Garden
Fire alarm
Fire extinguisher
Map of Shelter Island, NY
Available Rooms
Ratings and reviews
100% verified reviews10 / 10Outstanding·Sep 2026
The location was magical and made me feel very calm and happy.
Nothing, it was all good
10 / 10Outstanding·Apr 2026
The house is old and has been restored. I appreciate that the owners kept and reused the original wood trim. The room is beautifully decorated and appointed. The location is great; I could walk to most of what I wanted to do.
Absolutely nothing. I wouldn’t change a thing.
8 / 10Excellent·Aug 2023
Breakfast is no longer served which the host told me when I confirmed my reservation. The location is beautiful, quiet and peaceful. The host, Bill, was friendly, kind and full of recommendations for dining and sights to see on the island. We stayed in Room #1 which was very large with a king size bed and a view of the creek. The best thing was just relaxing on the porch swing and enjoying the quiet and stillness. I highly recommend staying here and I plan on going back again.
I didn't notice any smoke detectors.
5 / 10·Nov 2021
Quaintness, porch area,location with view of lk and nearby village
Not told in advance, no breakfast, I love breakfast. Very disappointing. Host was not very gracious or friendly
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.3Outstanding
(11 Ratings)
"The location was magical and made me feel very calm and happy."
Verified guestDon't miss out! Price and availability may change
