Cozy Shelter Island Cottage, walk to beaches and Mashomack Preserve

About this house rental

Located in Shelter Island, this charming house for $559 per night is a fantastic choice for your next trip. 3 bedroom, 2 bath house in Shelter Island offers many amenities including pool, dock, private beach access and great coastal hiking in the 2,000 acre Mashomack Preserve. Close to the south ferry with easy access to Sag Harbor and the Hamptons. It is the perfect house to get away from the hustle of the city to relax, soak in the sun and enjoy the gourmet chef’s kitchen and herb garden and 2 grills. The open plan house has a granite eating counter, dining room and a large deck overlooking the pool with an outdoor dining and lounging. The large property comes with a paddle board and 4 bikes to explore the beautiful island. There are 3 bedrooms, including a master en suite.

Amenities

Pool

Air conditioner

Kitchen / Kitchenette

Internet / Wifi

Fireplace

Parking

Laundry

Balcony / Patio

Dishwasher

Hot Tub / Spa

Garden

Map of Shelter Island, NY

Nearby attractions

Montauk Point State Park

22.97 miles

Mystic Aquarium

29.29 miles

Gillette Castle State Park

26.27 miles

Montauk Lighthouse Museum

24.13 miles

Cozy Shelter Island Cottage, walk to beaches and Mashomack Preserve

4.8

Outstanding(17 Reviews)

House in Shelter Island, NY

6 guests · 3 bedrooms · 2 baths

Reasons to book

People love it hereGuests give this property a top rating

Includes essentialsGarden, Pool, Kitchen / Kitchenette and more

Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental

$$$$

About this house rental

Amenities

Pool

Air conditioner

Kitchen / Kitchenette

Internet / Wifi

Fireplace

Parking

Laundry

Balcony / Patio

Dishwasher

Hot Tub / Spa

Garden

Map of Shelter Island, NY

Nearby attractions

Montauk Point State Park

22.97 miles

Mystic Aquarium

29.29 miles

Gillette Castle State Park

26.27 miles

Montauk Lighthouse Museum

24.13 miles

Reviews

4.8/5.0

Outstanding(17 Reviews)

5.0

Sep 2022

Good location. Spent most of our time in the Hamptons. Ferry travel was easy and quick. House was super clean. Would stay again.

3.0

Sep 2022

property was fine but we are avid tennis fans and were unable to view the US Open because there is no cable TV and the streaming service does not accept ESPN. I offered to pay for any upcharge to enable this and the property owner said this would not be necessary and we would able to see the US Open. Nope!

5.0

Sep 2022

We had such a great time staying there. Little gem. We’ll be back!

4.0

Aug 2022

It was a lovely home with a great deck and leading to a beautiful pool. Great fauna all the way around. Nice for families.

5.0

Aug 2022

We loved our stay so much. The pool was refreshing, love the furnishings and layout and kitchen and home was well stocked. A great Shelter Island cottage. Thank you!

5.0

Aug 2022

Soa is a wonderful host and her house makes for an amazing Shelter Island get away. The kitchen is well appointed, the beds very comfortable, the pool divine, and location close to Wades Beach and the South Ferry are wonderful. We spent several wonderful afternoons at Wades Beach and Sagg Main beach (which is less than a 30 minute ride including Ferry). We really enjoyed our stay at this house.

5.0

Jul 2022

Loved it inside and out and great location. We enjoyed riding the bikes around the lush island and exploring the Hamptons and Greenport. Owner was very responsive.

5.0

Jun 2022

Loved the location and the property. No complaints!

10.0

Jun 2022

Loved the location and the property. No complaints!

5.0

Oct 2021

This lovely, clean property is in a quiet neighborhood a short drive from Wade’s beach. You can bike to the Mashomack Preserve. Adult bikes are provided. Neighborhood has some nice hills if you enjoy a morning run. Sadly we were here in the fall and couldn’t enjoy the pool, but we loved hanging out on the comfy deck furniture. Note that there are two houses w the same address on the island. Ask for the intersection to get you to the right spot. Thanks for a great birthday weekend!

10.0

Oct 2021

5.0

Sep 2021

Great location, pleasant design, lovely host.

10.0

Aug 2021

Great location, pleasant design, lovely host.

5.0

Aug 2021

My family and I enjoyed two weeks at this lovely little bungalow. The house was comfortable and we felt very relaxed especially being so close to the beach. Spa is a lovely host and very responsive. Hope to return to SI again!

5.0

Jun 2021

A lovely Memorial Day/week on Shelter Island. Soa/Trevor and team provided a seamless experience.

5.0

May 2021

Lovely serene neighborhood - the house is older in actuality in person but very comfortably laid out. Backyard and pool was really what we had booked this location for and boy no regrets there! It was warm enough to swim too. The one thing people should know about Shelter Island landfill/recycling is that it’s pretty persnickety and requires 30min of time.

5.0

Apr 2021

Had a wonderful time. A lovely place and responsive, friendly owner. Genuinely enjoyed ourselves.

5.0

Jan 2021

My family enjoyed our stay in Shelter Island. The house had a very nice kitchen, well stocked with utensils, pots/pans, sharp knives (we brought our own pantry staples), a very cozy living space with wood stove and three good size bedrooms with comfortable beds. The property was great for running around the yard and easy access to nature reserve and South Ferry. We enjoyed our stay and would book this property again.

5.0

Jul 2018

Lovely modern house with three comfortable and stylish bedrooms, gourmet chef’s kitchen, and beautiful outdoor space. Loved the the bikes, the hammock, and the pool! A little far from the action on the north end of the island but within walking distance of Wades Beach.

5.0

Jun 2018

FAQs

How much does this house cost compared to others in Shelter Island?

The average price for a rental in Shelter Island is $783 per night. This rental is $224 less expensive than the average.

Is parking included with this house?

Yes, parking is listed as an amenity at Cozy Shelter Island Cottage, walk to beaches and Mashomack Preserve. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.

Is there a pool at this house?

Yes, a swimming pool is available for use at Cozy Shelter Island Cottage, walk to beaches and Mashomack Preserve. Enjoy the water!

Is Cozy Shelter Island Cottage, walk to beaches and Mashomack Preserve pet friendly?

Unfortunately, this house is not pet-friendly. Try searching again and filter for "Pets Allowed"

What amenities are available at Cozy Shelter Island Cottage, walk to beaches and Mashomack Preserve?

We found 12 amenities for this rental. This includes pool, air conditioner, kitchen / kitchenette, internet / wifi, and fireplace.

Explore similar vacation rentals in Shelter Island

Explore all rentals in Shelter Island

4.5

Excellent(1 Review)

Inn

in Shelter Island Heights

The Chequit

Garden · Pets allowed · Air conditioner

This Inn for $102 in Shelter Island, is perfect for your next (business stay, family stay, couples stay, getaway vacation, etc.)

$$$$

Cozy Shelter Island Cottage, walk to beaches and Mashomack Preserve

About this house rental

Amenities

Map of Shelter Island, NY

Nearby attractions

Cozy Shelter Island Cottage, walk to beaches and Mashomack Preserve

House in Shelter Island, NY

Reasons to book

About this house rental

Amenities

Map of Shelter Island, NY

Nearby attractions

Reviews

FAQs

How much does this house cost compared to others in Shelter Island?

Is parking included with this house?

Is there a pool at this house?

Is Cozy Shelter Island Cottage, walk to beaches and Mashomack Preserve pet friendly?

What amenities are available at Cozy Shelter Island Cottage, walk to beaches and Mashomack Preserve?

Explore similar vacation rentals in Shelter Island

Shelter Island travel inspiration

Related vacation destinations

Keep exploring