House in Cayuga Lake, NY
10 guests · 5 bedrooms · 4 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Top-tier experienceA high end property in this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
THE BEST PLACE TO STAY ON OWASCO LAKE! Welcome to Baymont Mansion, LOCATED AT 59 BROOK HOLLOW DRIVE, OWASCO, NY 13021 - this property is a turn of the century brick revival completely renovated inside and out! It is located in the heart of the finger lakes; 5 miles from Skaneateles, 25 miles from Syracuse, and 45 miles from Rochester.
This spacious home is great for weekend retreats, small weddings, bridal parties, family reunions, hunting and fishing outings, winery weekends, corporate getaways, and bike tours.
The home includes a newly renovated gourmet kitchen and dining room with beautiful views of the lake. There is a large great room that separates each wing of the house and holds an antique billiards table great for entertainment. Two of the bedrooms are on the West side of the house with a king size bed and each offer a large, full bathroom off each room. The other 2 bedrooms are located in the East wing of the house and share an additional 3rd large bathroom. The back of the house includes an expansive deck overlooking the view and there is a covered gazebo for outdoor dining.
This is one of the most beautiful spots on the lake, nestled in a cove, often calm, and great for swimming. Additionally, there is a boundless back yard, and a bonfire pit down by the water. There are so many features of this home that will make for a perfect getaway with a loved one, family or friends!
• Public Water, Sewer & Natural Gas.
• 1st Floor Bedroom Suite with Bath & Fireplace.
• 1st Floor Laundry Room.
• Central Air Conditioning.
• Hi-Speed Internet WiFi in the Home and Internet Service Works even on the Lakefront Beach!
This spacious home is great for weekend retreats, small weddings, bridal parties, family reunions, hunting and fishing outings, winery weekends, corporate getaways, and bike tours.
The home includes a newly renovated gourmet kitchen and dining room with beautiful views of the lake. There is a large great room that separates each wing of the house and holds an antique billiards table great for entertainment. Two of the bedrooms are on the West side of the house with a king size bed and each offer a large, full bathroom off each room. The other 2 bedrooms are located in the East wing of the house and share an additional 3rd large bathroom. The back of the house includes an expansive deck overlooking the view and there is a covered gazebo for outdoor dining.
This is one of the most beautiful spots on the lake, nestled in a cove, often calm, and great for swimming. Additionally, there is a boundless back yard, and a bonfire pit down by the water. There are so many features of this home that will make for a perfect getaway with a loved one, family or friends!
• Public Water, Sewer & Natural Gas.
• 1st Floor Bedroom Suite with Bath & Fireplace.
• 1st Floor Laundry Room.
• Central Air Conditioning.
• Hi-Speed Internet WiFi in the Home and Internet Service Works even on the Lakefront Beach!
Amenities
Non-smoking
No pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Cayuga Lake, NY
Ratings and reviews
8 / 10Excellent·Sep 2025
Kitchen could be better equipped.Garbage pail in bathroom would be nice..
10 / 10Outstanding·Aug 2025
Property and house were exactly as listed only cozier. Perfect for a family from Nana&Papa to 3 month old grandchild...everything we needed and plenty of space. Access to water was perfect for younger children and not too far from house/deck. Owner responded immediately when there was a small issue with kitchen sink. Enjoyed our stay immensely and hope to return.
8 / 10Excellent·Jun 2025
This house served as the perfect place for my family and I when we were in town for a funeral. Incredible view we just wished it was warmer so we could have enjoyed the lake and backyard more.
6 / 10Average·Aug 2023
The location of the home is perfect! Great neighborhood with an easy drive to grocery stores and activities!
We arrived at the home at 4:00 pm and the property owner was there to meet us and give a tour of the home. The bedrooms and bathrooms were freshly painted. One bedroom did not have central air and the window unit had black mold. Because my children have allergies to mold, we had to purchase a new window unit. The owner did agree to reimburse us.
The glass cooktop in the kitchen was cracked which created some challenges for dinner prep. The refrigerator was filthy and I had to scrub it prior to adding our food. Additionally, we would recommend investing in an exterminator as there were many ants in the kitchen that were beyond what one would normally expect.
Lastly, while the great room has beautiful wood, the room had a musty smell that was not helped with open windows.
Overall, the home could be beautiful if there was investment made! Compared to other like homes we have rented on the lake, the cost did not align with the condition of the house.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.5Outstanding
(98 Ratings)
"Property and house were exactly as listed only cozier. Perfect for a family from Nana&Papa to 3 month old grandchild...everything we needed and plenty of space. Access to water was perfect for young..."
Dorothy D.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
