Updated home in great location with spacious living & outdoor features
About this house rental
Located in Fire Island, this charming house for $675 per night is a great option for your next break. Cayuga Escape Our calendar is updated in real-time & our nightly rates are accurately displayed. Simply enter your desired dates and click 'Book Now!' Welcome to the perfect home base in Ocean Bay Park for your next Fire Island vacation! Ideally located a short walk from the beach, ferry, and restaurants, this home is convenient to all the nearby attractions. Ferry service from Bay Shore lands you in the heart of the Ocean Bay Park commercial district, which gives off a bohemian and breezy vibe. Downtown Ocean Bay Park features bay-front dining, a grocery store, and a bicycle rental shop. The kitchen features white cabinetry, and stainless steel appliances. Fully equipped for your use, there is also a coffee maker, microwave, dishwasher, toaster, dishware, glassware and pots & pans. The indoor dining table accommodates six guests and there is comfortable living room seating with room for the whole family to relax. The four bedrooms can easily accommodate ten people; two have queen- sized beds, and the other two each have three single beds. In addition, there are two newly renovated full bathrooms, both with spacious standing showers. THINGS TO KNOW This home is only accessible via ferry. There are strict noise and no party restrictions at this home. If you feel this may be an issue for your group, please select a different property. This property is managed by Susan Scanlon, Principal Real Estate Broker with Vacasa New York, LLC If you are bringing a dog on your trip, the nightly pet fee is already included in your quote when selecting "Yes" to pets. If you would like to add more dogs, please contact us. The nightly fee ranges between $150 and $200, depending on the bedroom count, and will apply for each additional dog. Parking notes: No parking available. Damage waiver: The total cost of your reservation for this Property includes a nightly damage waiver fee, plus tax if applicable (the “Damage Waiver”). (A discount may be applied for stays of 28 nights or longer, if permitted.) The Damage Waiver covers you for up to $3,000 of accidental damage to the Property or its contents (such as furniture, fixtures, and appliances) as long as you report the incident to the host prior to checking out. The Damage Waiver fee eliminates the need for a traditional security deposit. More information can be downloaded from the "Rental Agreement" on the checkout page. Due to local laws or HOA requirements, guests must be at least 30 years of age to book. Guests under 30 must be accompanied by a parent or legal guardian for the duration of the reservation.
Amenities
Air conditioner
Pets allowed
Kitchen / Kitchenette
Internet / Wifi
Balcony / Patio
Dishwasher
TV
Map of Fire Island, NY
Reviews
4.5/5.0
Excellent(49 Reviews)
3.0
We got to the house and it was a lovely house, in a great location. The garbage outside had meat and other garbage not in bags. The storm door was broken which we fixed ourselves, the floor was full of sand, the air conditioner in the kitchen didnt blow cold air and the fan in the ktchen didnt work either, the remote was nowhere to be found.
I think some of our money should be refunded.
5.0
Too convenient for beach, ferry and market access. So close to all
3.0
There were many parts of this property that were very nice but it has some significant drawbacks. There is a strong musty smell in the back bedrooms and there is standing water under the house. I would not stay here if you have any kind of lung sensitivity or smell sensitivity. If you don’t, there are many nice parts of the house and amenities (bikes, wagon, nice beach chairs) that can make it a very nice stay.
We had some trouble with checking in (code did not work) but on site staff was very helpful and fixed the issue within a couple hours.
5.0
The home has been updated and is even nicer than the pictures. Very roomy and well equipped. Location is great.
4.0
Everything was great. The only thing that really put a damper on our trip was the oven and microwave not working.
5.0
The house is clean, simple and just enough.
4.0
Great house. Oven and microwave did not work.
Everything was great. The only thing that really put a damper on our trip was the oven and microwave not working.
5.0
Cayuga Vacation
The house is clean, simple and just enough.
1.0
Dishwasher, microwave, dryer, convection oven, shower door, closet door, storm door and one of the air conditioners all broken. When we raised this with the management company, we received absolutely no response despite calling and texting multiple times. DO NOT RENT if you care about getting what you pay for.
4.0
Really like this house!
I would give this house 4.5 stars if I could. It was a bit of a rocky start as the dishwasher and convection oven were not working and there was no wagon upon our arrival. However the house as a whole is great. There were upgrades from our stay last year which we loved. The beds are comfortable, it’s well equipped in the kitchen and everything you need for the beach. There were 2 bikes that got a lot of use. We’ll most likely be back next year!!
4.0
I would give this house 4.5 stars if I could. It was a bit of a rocky start as the dishwasher and convection oven were not working and there was no wagon upon our arrival. However the house as a whole is great. There were upgrades from our stay last year which we loved. The beds are comfortable, it’s well equipped in the kitchen and everything you need for the beach. There were 2 bikes that got a lot of use. We’ll most likely be back next year!!
1.0
Terrible
Dishwasher, microwave, dryer, convection oven, shower door, closet door, storm door and one of the air conditioners all broken. When we raised this with the management company, we received absolutely no response despite calling and texting multiple times. DO NOT RENT if you care about getting what you pay for.
5.0
Great house to rent- would recommend or do it again!
5.0
Perfect Beach Cottage
Prime location, host was responsive and hospitable, and we loved the outdoor shower!
4.0
My husband and I stayed here as the final week of our COVID honeymoon and the place/location was everything we wanted! Our biggest complaint and the reason we gave 4 stars instead of 5 is because we specifically chose this rental for the bikes and grill. Out of the 4 adult bikes at the house, none were in working order and the grill was perfect, but despite a full propane tank, would not stay lit (even when we used a grill lighter to ignite it).
4.0
This is a traditional Fire Island house - simple construction, great room, small bedrooms, narrow hallways. Very nice deck and outdoor shower. It was end of the season, but there were a number of small maintenance issues - a number of missing screens, which forced us to use the air-conditioning, even though it was cool. 7 or 8 bikes, none of which had air (no air pump) or were rideable (busted seats, bent frame, etc.). But, overall, still a nice house.
5.0
This was a great weekend getaway house! All our needs were met- response from Vacasa team was very
Great house to rent- would recommend or do it again!
4.0
This house was great. The only reason it gets 4 stars instead of 5 is for a few small things: there was a weird smell in the two large bedrooms (it may have went away or we got used to it), no real oven (i'm really not at all familiar with how to operate a convection/microwave oven hybrid so we just used stove top and grill), the grill igniter button was broken (so i had to light the grill with a lighter), the lock was super finicky, the internet kept dropping (and we had two super rainy days), and the shower near the two full sized bedrooms was missing one of it's doors so there was always a puddle outside of the shower on the bathroom floor. Other than that, the beds were comfortable! The house was clean! So many towels and blankets and linens. Great location. Very simple house, which is all we needed. Would stay at this house again.
4.0
Great Property
My husband and I stayed here as the final week of our COVID honeymoon and the place/location was everything we wanted! Our biggest complaint and the reason we gave 4 stars instead of 5 is because we specifically chose this rental for the bikes and grill. Out of the 4 adult bikes at the house, none were in working order and the grill was perfect, but despite a full propane tank, would not stay lit (even when we used a grill lighter to ignite it).
4.0
First Week of Post-Season
This house was great. The only reason it gets 4 stars instead of 5 is for a few small things: there was a weird smell in the two large bedrooms (it may have went away or we got used to it), no real oven (i'm really not at all familiar with how to operate a convection/microwave oven hybrid so we just used stove top and grill), the grill igniter button was broken (so i had to light the grill with a lighter), the lock was super finicky, the internet kept dropping (and we had two super rainy days), and the shower near the two full sized bedrooms was missing one of it's doors so there was always a puddle outside of the shower on the bathroom floor. Other than that, the beds were comfortable! The house was clean! So many towels and blankets and linens. Great location. Very simple house, which is all we needed. Would stay at this house again.
4.0
Traditional Fire Island house but needs some love
This is a traditional Fire Island house - simple construction, great room, small bedrooms, narrow hallways. Very nice deck and outdoor shower. It was end of the season, but there were a number of small maintenance issues - a number of missing screens, which forced us to use the air-conditioning, even though it was cool. 7 or 8 bikes, none of which had air (no air pump) or were rideable (busted seats, bent frame, etc.). But, overall, still a nice house.
4.0
rant great place with plenty of room. Kitchen could have been stocked a bit better but was still clean and neat. Bicycles at the house do not work so you have yTo rent for sure. Plenty of beach chairs for guests, but umbrellas did not work and outdoor table had no umbrella. Aside from these small easy fixes, location was great, recently renovated bathrooms great and the house is small but feels way more s p across them other FI rentals.
4.0
Nice place
rant great place with plenty of room. Kitchen could have been stocked a bit better but was still clean and neat. Bicycles at the house do not work so you have y
To rent for sure. Plenty of beach chairs for guests, but umbrellas did not work and outdoor table had no umbrella. Aside from these small easy fixes, location was great, recently renovated bathrooms great and the house is small but feels way more s p across them other FI rentals.
5.0
Would stay at 10 Cayuga again!
This was our first time on Fire Island (5 adults, 2 teenagers, 1 infant, 2 dogs). Close to store and restaurants, close enough to walk to Ocean Beach. House held us all comfortably. No complaints at all. Plenty of towels, beach chairs, umbrella, sand toys. Would definitely recommend and we would stay here again!
4.0
10 Cayuga
The property wasn’t as nice as the pictures and the cleanliness off the place was subpar. The area was outstanding though and the overall stay was fabulous. The convenience of the property to store,bars ,beach, and ferry were amazing.
1.0
Not worth the money.
The location was excellent.
After waiting a few days for a return call, the contact was polite and helpful
After waiting a few days for a return call, the contact was polite and helpful
5.0
Great vacation home
1) House was extremely clean and well kept.
2) Outdoor shower was amazing
3) Grill was huge to cook for my large family.
4) Location perfect for beach, grocery store, restaurants, bar, pizza, and ice cream.
5) I will definitely rent this home again!
2.0
Needs some serious TLC
From the listing and price our expectations of the property were high. We’ve rented in Fire Island for over a decade and are well aware of what a true beach house is. However, things like broken appliances, broken furniture, uncomfortable mattresses and dirty linens are simply not typical of a beach house. The barbecue was not working even though we attempted to get help twice to fix it. There are plenty of beds and overall the house has great potential the problem is is that it’s not properly maintained. A little TLC would go along way and make this a much more enjoyable property. Unfortunately, we would not rent this location again in its current condition. The upsides? Location, a good deck, lots of beach chairs and outdoor shower.
4.0
Great Place for the Price
Loved the amount of beds provided. Very close to Flynn’s and the grocery store. Just a few minute walk to the beach. Bikes and a wagon were provided as well as Tommy Bahama beach chairs. The BBQ was large, clean and plenty of propane. The Air conditioners kept the house nice and cool. Having two newly renovated bathrooms helped out especially when you have teenage boys tagging along. Plenty of towels were provided. The deck area was private and had plenty of seating. The washer and dryer worked fine. Plenty of storage space in the kitchen as well as the bedrooms. Overall we loved 10 Cayuga.
4.0
Nice and Easy Home in Ocean Bay Park
Stayed here for a weekend with some friends. Home is very close to the beach and the ferry, which was great. Home was clean and generally as promised.
I thought the kitchen could've been better appointed (we had no dishwasher tablets) and beach towels would've been nice. All in all though, this is a great base camp for a weekend at the beach.
I thought the kitchen could've been better appointed (we had no dishwasher tablets) and beach towels would've been nice. All in all though, this is a great base camp for a weekend at the beach.
5.0
July 2018 Stay
Everything was great. The house was clean and there were tons of nice touches to make our stay better, like beach towels, nice beach chairs, and a wagon that made lugging our stuff much easier. Thanks for everything!
5.0
June 2018 Stay
This house was better than we thought- clean and updated. I hadn’t rented in years (and not through VRBO) and was pleasantly surprised that all linens, towels etc were cleaned and on the beds!!! I called several times with questions and everyone was so pleasant. The sun shined the whole time - perfect vacation
5.0
Great stay!
Rating Details:
The property manager was very helpful.
The vacation rental was spotless.
I was very happy with the location.
I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental.
Overall, I recommend this vacation rental.
Reviewer Comments:
The listing was just like the pictures and description. My friends and I had a great time staying there.
5.0
The listing was just like the pictures and description. My friends and I had a great time stayin...
The listing was just like the pictures and description. My friends and I had a great time staying there.
5.0
10 Cayuga stay.
Rating Details:
The property manager was very helpful.
The vacation rental was spotless.
I was very happy with the location.
I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental.
Overall, I recommend this vacation rental.
Reviewer Comments:
Very easy and helpful company managing the property. It's Exactly what you want from a fire island rental. Close to beach, bay, ocean Beach for dining/night life and accommodations were perfect for the price. Would recommend this property to anyone
5.0
Very easy and helpful company managing the property. It's Exactly what you want from a fire islan...
Very easy and helpful company managing the property. It's Exactly what you want from a fire island rental. Close to beach, bay, ocean Beach for dining/night life and accommodations were perfect for the price. Would recommend this property to anyone
5.0
2nd Stay with A2 & I’ll be back!
Rating Details:
The property manager was very helpful.
The vacation rental was very clean.
I was more than happy with the location.
I was more than satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental.
Overall, I recommend this vacation rental.
Reviewer Comments:
The new app made things better this year! This is my second year renting with A2- always professional and some nice property offerings. My last house was a littler newer than this rental but I’m the one who books and understands that. Generally the house was clean and in a great location for OBP. I’ll be back next year!
1.0
Disappointed
Rating Details:
The property manager was adequately helpful.
The vacation rental was somewhat dirty.
I was happy with the location.
I was very dissatisfied with the condition of the vacation rental.
Overall, I do not recommend this vacation rental.
Reviewer Comments:
My biggest complaint was that there was no functioning TV. There was one on the wall but did not work. I called several times. It was not stated anywhere in the contract that it wasn't included? Also the deck furniture was horrible and that's where you want to spend time. It was surface cleaned but all cabinets and interior was very dirty. I felt for the price & what the description it was disappointing! Definitely would never rent it again
FAQs
How much does this house cost compared to others in Fire Island?
The average price for a rental in Fire Island is $735 per night. This rental is $60 less expensive than the average.
Is parking included with this house?
Parking is not specified as an available amenity at Updated home in great location with spacious living & outdoor features. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.
Is there a pool at this house?
We didn’t find pool listed as an amenity for this house. It may be worth double checking if a pool is important for your stay.
Is Updated home in great location with spacious living & outdoor features pet friendly?
Yes! This house is pet-friendly. For more information, we recommend contacting the booking provider about animal policies.
What amenities are available at Updated home in great location with spacious living & outdoor features?
We found 7 amenities for this rental. This includes air conditioner, pets allowed, kitchen / kitchenette, internet / wifi, and balcony / patio.
Explore similar vacation rentals in Fire Island
Explore all rentals in Fire IslandFire Island travel inspiration
Read our blogGuides
Ski Trip Packing List: What to Bring Skiing or Snowboarding
Trends
VacationRenter Holiday Travel Trends 2023
Featured Rentals
Architectural Vacation Rentals: Experience the Beauty of Unique Properties
Featured Rentals
Sustainable and Eco-Friendly Vacation Rentals Around the World
Featured Rentals
Our Favorite Vacation Rentals With Unique Experiences
Featured Rentals
Amazing Cabin Rentals Across the Globe
Featured Rentals
Have You Ever Wanted to Stay in a Dome Rental? Now You Can
Featured Rentals
Jaw Dropping Treehouse Rentals All Over the World
Keep exploring
- Lake Tahoe Cabins
- Ruidoso Cabins
- Blue Ridge Cabins
- Estes Park Cabins
- Lake George Cabins
- Eureka Springs Cabins
- Branson Cabins
- Lake of the Ozarks Cabins
- Lake Arrowhead Cabins
- Lake Texoma Cabins
- Canyon Lake Cabins
- Sevierville Cabins
- Flagstaff Cabins
- Colorado Springs Cabins
- Hot Springs Cabins
- Bass Lake Cabins
- Buffalo River Cabins
- Possum Kingdom Lake Cabins
- Chattanooga Cabins
- Nashville Cabins
- Wears Valley Cabins
- Cloudcroft Cabins
- Deep Creek Lake Cabins
- Mammoth Lakes Cabins
- Anna Maria Islands Rentals
- Outer Banks Vacation Rentals
- Rosemary Beach Rentals
- Holden Beach Rentals
- Hilton Head Vacation Rentals
- Topsail Beach Rentals
- Kiawah Island Rentals
- Panama City Beach Rentals
- Ocean Isle Beach Rentals
- Folly Beach Rentals
- Dauphin Island Rentals
- Rehoboth Beach Rentals
- Bethany Beach Rentals
- Cape Cod Rentals
- 30A Rentals
- Seaside Florida Rentals
- Edisto Beach Rentals
- Fort Myers Beach Rentals
- Miramar Beach Rentals
- Port Aransas Rentals
- Emerald Isle Rentals
- Orange Beach Rentals
- Surfside Beach Rentals
- Hampton Beach Rentals
- Assateague Island Rentals
- Jacksonville Beach Vacation Rentals
- North Shore Vacation Rentals
- Ogunquit Vacation Rentals
- North Redington Beach Rentals
- Lido Key Vacation Rentals
- Sea Colony Rentals
- Pass A Grille Vacation Rentals
- Blue Ridge Mountain Rentals
- Vail Lodging
- Jackson Hole Lodging
- Winter Park Lodging
- Telluride Lodging
- Big Sky Rentals
- Aspen Lodging
- Park City Rentals
- Steamboat Springs Lodging
- Breckenridge Rentals
- Lake Tahoe Rentals
- Copper Mountain Lodging
- Mammoth Mountain Lodging
- Beech Mountain Rentals
- Crested Butte Rentals
- Sun Valley Lodging
- Keystone Lodging
- Taos Lodging
- Sugar Mountain Cabins
- Beaver Creek Lodging
- Deep Creek Lake Rentals
- Smith Mountain Lake Rentals
- Ocean Lakes Rentals
- Lake Anna Rentals
- Torch Lake Rentals
- Lake Winnipesaukee Rentals
- Norris Lake Rentals
- Lake Gaston Rentals
- Canyon Lake Rentals
- Lake Oconee Rentals
- Lake Wallenpaupack Rentals
- Lake Martin Rentals
- Lake Havasu Rentals
- Lake of the Ozarks Rentals
- Lake Michigan Vacation Rentals
- Lake Chelan Rentals
- Finger Lakes Rentals
- Lake Keowee Vacation Rentals
- Lake Conroe Rentals
- Lake Erie Vacation Rentals
- Lake Austin Vacation Rentals
- Sebago Lake Rentals
- Lake Tillery Rentals
- Keuka Lake Rentals