House in Tisbury, MA
9 guests · 4 bedrooms · 4 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Top-tier experienceA high end property in this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
Pirate’s Cove is a quintessential Martha’s Vineyard vacation home tucked away on a quiet lane in East Chop, just minutes from the charm, restaurants, beaches, harbor, and energy of Oak Bluffs. Walk to town, the beach, or the harbor in about 15–18 minutes, or get there in less than 5 minutes by car or bike.
This young Victorian-style home is designer-decorated, air-conditioned, and thoughtfully set up for families and groups looking for a relaxed island getaway. Enjoy slow mornings on the front porch rocking chairs, beach days in Oak Bluffs, cookouts on the back deck, and cozy evenings together after a full day exploring the Vineyard.
Inside, the newly renovated eat-in kitchen features fresh cabinetry, dark gray quartz countertops, and a white subway tile backsplash. Between the eat-in kitchen, separate dining room, and outdoor dining areas, there is plenty of space for your group to gather comfortably for meals, morning coffee, cookouts, and relaxed evenings together. The living room offers a comfortable gathering space with a 43-inch Samsung SmartTV and charming beach-stone fireplace.
The home includes 4 bedrooms and 4 bathrooms. Upstairs, the spacious primary en suite features warm blue décor, a 58-inch Samsung SmartTV, and an attached bonus room that works beautifully as an office, sitting room, or nursery. The first-floor bedroom includes a queen bed, 58-inch Samsung SmartTV, and easy access to a fully renovated bathroom with new flooring, a new vanity, and a floor-to-ceiling tiled zero-entry shower. Two additional upstairs bedrooms each include twin beds.
The finished basement gives everyone extra room to spread out, with a full bathroom, laundry room, 48-inch SmartTV, and arcade machine—perfect for rainy days, movie nights, or keeping the kids entertained.
Outdoor living is one of the best parts of Pirate’s Cove. The home features a large deck, Weber gas grill, patio furniture, backyard, hammock, and outdoor shower for rinsing off after the beach. There is driveway parking for two cars, plus blazing-fast 1,200 Mbps (1+ gigabyte) WiFi for streaming, remote work, or staying connected during your stay.
Whether you are coming for beach days, family time, Oak Bluffs, or the classic Martha’s Vineyard experience, Pirate’s Cove is a stylish and comfortable home base for an unforgettable island getaway.
Minimum age to rent is 25 years old.
No pets and no smoking. Please do not move the furniture.
The cleaning fee covers cleaning, linens, towels, and laundering. Guests may be charged an additional $250 cleaning fee if the grill is not cleaned adequately after use.
Pirate’s Cove is a Getaway Society vacation rental home. Ask us about our portfolio of homes in Hilton Head, Orlando, Gatlinburg, and Broken Bow (Oklahoma). Our homes are thoughtfully located and stylishly designed to help guests create memorable experiences on every getaway.
This young Victorian-style home is designer-decorated, air-conditioned, and thoughtfully set up for families and groups looking for a relaxed island getaway. Enjoy slow mornings on the front porch rocking chairs, beach days in Oak Bluffs, cookouts on the back deck, and cozy evenings together after a full day exploring the Vineyard.
Inside, the newly renovated eat-in kitchen features fresh cabinetry, dark gray quartz countertops, and a white subway tile backsplash. Between the eat-in kitchen, separate dining room, and outdoor dining areas, there is plenty of space for your group to gather comfortably for meals, morning coffee, cookouts, and relaxed evenings together. The living room offers a comfortable gathering space with a 43-inch Samsung SmartTV and charming beach-stone fireplace.
The home includes 4 bedrooms and 4 bathrooms. Upstairs, the spacious primary en suite features warm blue décor, a 58-inch Samsung SmartTV, and an attached bonus room that works beautifully as an office, sitting room, or nursery. The first-floor bedroom includes a queen bed, 58-inch Samsung SmartTV, and easy access to a fully renovated bathroom with new flooring, a new vanity, and a floor-to-ceiling tiled zero-entry shower. Two additional upstairs bedrooms each include twin beds.
The finished basement gives everyone extra room to spread out, with a full bathroom, laundry room, 48-inch SmartTV, and arcade machine—perfect for rainy days, movie nights, or keeping the kids entertained.
Outdoor living is one of the best parts of Pirate’s Cove. The home features a large deck, Weber gas grill, patio furniture, backyard, hammock, and outdoor shower for rinsing off after the beach. There is driveway parking for two cars, plus blazing-fast 1,200 Mbps (1+ gigabyte) WiFi for streaming, remote work, or staying connected during your stay.
Whether you are coming for beach days, family time, Oak Bluffs, or the classic Martha’s Vineyard experience, Pirate’s Cove is a stylish and comfortable home base for an unforgettable island getaway.
Minimum age to rent is 25 years old.
No pets and no smoking. Please do not move the furniture.
The cleaning fee covers cleaning, linens, towels, and laundering. Guests may be charged an additional $250 cleaning fee if the grill is not cleaned adequately after use.
Pirate’s Cove is a Getaway Society vacation rental home. Ask us about our portfolio of homes in Hilton Head, Orlando, Gatlinburg, and Broken Bow (Oklahoma). Our homes are thoughtfully located and stylishly designed to help guests create memorable experiences on every getaway.
Amenities
Non-smoking
No pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Tisbury, MA
Ratings and reviews
Summary of reviewsThe property received glowing reviews for its spaciousness, convenient location, responsive owner, well-equipped amenities, and comfortable accommodations.
8 / 10Excellent·Sep 2025
Property was overall very good with plenty of space for the family. My one issue was the condition of the toilet seats. The white paint was rubbed off of almost all the toilets, exposing the pressboard underneath. This is extremely unhygenic and my family had to buy toilet covers just to use the restroom. For the thousands of dollars we spent, I would have expected better hygiene and maintenance.Another side note - there is not a single full body mirror in the entire home. We had formal dinners planned and had to take pictures of ourselves just to get ready. Half of our family were women so you.can imagine that did not make them happy. Other than this - the home is nice, the basement is fun, the BBQ space was great, and the kitchen was well stocked. We would stay there again.
10 / 10Outstanding·Sep 2024
Beautiful home on quiet street within walking distance to Oak Bluffs. Well equipped kitchen and comfy family room. Beautiful primary suite with huge modern bathroom. Carrington was an excellent host and very responsive to anything that came up.
10 / 10Outstanding·Aug 2024
We loved the house and the listing was exactly as written. The hosts were very responsive to any issues. The location was great for us as our kids could bike to the beaches and downtown.
We would love to return next year!
Thanks so much!
6 / 10Average·Sep 2025
We stayed at this home during a visit to Martha’s Vineyard with our two young kids. While the location was great and the host, Carrington, was responsive and polite, we were disappointed with the cleanliness and condition of the interior of the property. There’s a beautifully done porch and retaining wall making the outdoor area ideal. There were several maintenance and housekeeping issues that we reported upon arrival. Carrington acknowledged them and said they would be addressed with the team, which we appreciated.Overall, the communication was great, location was great, but the home needed improvements in terms of readiness and upkeep.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.6Outstanding
(57 Ratings)
The property received glowing reviews for its spaciousness, convenient location, responsive owner, well-equipped amenities, and comfortable accommodations.
From real guest reviews summarized by AIDon't miss out! Price and availability may change
