Coconut Mallory Resort and Marina

Coconut Mallory Resort and Marina Hotel in Stock Island

About this hotel

Nestled in Stock Island, this attractive hotel for $191 per night is a great choice for your next vacation. This Key West resort is 2 miles from historic Duval Street and 1 mile from the Key West International Airport. The property features 2 outdoor pools, a hot tub, and apartments with fully-equipped kitchens.

Amenities

Pool

Air conditioner

Kitchen / Kitchenette

Internet / Wifi

Parking

Balcony / Patio

Hot Tub / Spa

Map of Stock Island, FL

Nearby attractions

The Key West Butterfly and Nature Conservatory

3.18 miles

Mallory Square

3.60 miles

Southernmost Point of the Continental U.S.A.

3.25 miles

The Hemingway Home and Museum

3.31 miles

Coconut Mallory Resort and Marina

4.2

Excellent(281 Reviews)

Hotel in Stock Island, FL

3-Star Hotel

Reasons to book

Includes essentialsPool, Kitchen / Kitchenette, Air conditioner and more

Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental

$$$$

About this hotel

Amenities

Pool

Air conditioner

Kitchen / Kitchenette

Internet / Wifi

Parking

Balcony / Patio

Hot Tub / Spa

Map of Stock Island, FL

Nearby attractions

The Key West Butterfly and Nature Conservatory

3.18 miles

Mallory Square

3.60 miles

Southernmost Point of the Continental U.S.A.

3.25 miles

The Hemingway Home and Museum

3.31 miles

Reviews

4.2/5.0

Excellent(281 Reviews)

100% verified reviews

10.0

Apr 2024

Love it!!

Very nice ,quiet place, relaxing, we enjoy it !!

Very clean, quiet, family friendly.

9.0

Jul 2023

Nice place to stay but wear earplugs to sleep.

The unit was clean and spacious. Bathrooms were clean and well supplied. Beds were comfortable and windows had blackout curtains but there was still light bleeding due to no blinds. Kitchen was well stocked with dishes, silverware, pots, pans, and cooking utensils. Laundry appliances were close and easy to use but was only coin operated.

Our unit was the closest to the street. Sounds from the street or parking lot were very loud. The other thing is we weren't expecting to clean the place before checking out. Maybe that should be included in the notes or description to the place. We didn't mind minor cleaning and pulling sheets off the beds but would have appreciated the notice before booking.

10.0

Jul 2023

Exceptional

Spacious room with kitchenette.

1.0

Jun 2023

Do not stay here - read reviews on their site from other guests.

My husband and I stayed at Coconut Mallory Resort and Marina at the end of May. I found that the wifi was difficult at times to connect to and the TV/cable would lose sound. We didn't bother mentioning it to the front desk, b/c we were on vacation and disconnecting. Also, there were a few cockroaches that we had to get rid of each day that we stayed there, but as a Floridian and being on an island that happens. The day before we're leaving (in the afternoon) there was a knock on our door and a man said "maintenance" and opened the door to our room with his key. My husband and I were in the bedroom and my husband went out into the living area as the man was entering our room and started moving the curtain. My husband told him to leave and he said he wanted to get something, but my husband told him to leave the room. Btw, we were never informed that "maintenance" would be coming by and for what reason. We went out that same day around 6PM and when we walked by the room next to us, we saw a can of "roach bomb" inside the front door. When we came back that night at midnight, we walked into dead cockroaches all around the room and on the night stand. After the extermination from the room next us. I wanted to leave and find another hotel to stay in because we were obviously disgusted, but it was late at night and we were checking out the next morning. My husband removed all of the dead cockroaches himself. How do we know what we inhaled and what medical issues it may cause? It's incredibly disappointing because we had stayed there twice when we first met 8 yrs ago and there were issues that were shady back then, but nothing like this. The person(s) who decided that it was fine to spray the room next to our room, (most likely knowing that the dead cockroaches would be dispersed all over the floor) should be fired! We were checking out the next AM. We emailed the Mgmt Company about this and never heard back.

2.0

Jun 2023

Never again

Nothing. I’ve been 3 times in the last 5 years, and each time it’s progressively gotten worse.

Arrived at 9pm to find our 1st room FULL of German cockroaches (at least 50-60). Took 3 hours to get ahold of staff for a room change. While changing rooms at midnight, i had forgot a brand new pair of shoes in the old room. Shoes were left at front door. By the time i could get the staff to let back in the following day, my shoes were missing. The only people in the room after me were staff, yet no one can tell me where they went.

10.0

May 2023

I will stay there again.

I stayed in a bungalow and it was very clean, bed was comfortable. The pool was sparkling and the surrounding area was very clean. Pool toys were provided. The resort was quiet and I feel I received good value for the charges,

I liked everything. I am looking forward to my next stay at Coconut Mallory. the tropical lanscaping and mature trees are a welcome respite from the bright sun,

6.0

Apr 2023

Staff was nice but rooms could use a little work.

Nice balcony, clean grounds

Roach in unit, leaky soap dispenser in tub that made bathtub very slippery and unsafe, tv did not work downstairs, new pool gate lock installed with no notification of how to get in

10.0

Mar 2023

Too short.

Very clean. Friendly staff. Beautiful property.

8.0

Feb 2023

Will stay again

My room was very clean and spacious. Loved the bar by the water. Bar tenders were very nice.

King bed was not comfortable. Wish it had a comforter, just sheet and thin coverlet. Little cool at night.

9.0

Feb 2023

property was beautiful!

the property was really nice and clean! it was very spacious too! one BIG plus, honest staff! my daughter misplaced her Apple Watch during our stay.. we searched all over the room before we left! days later we recieved a call from property, they found the watch!

property is at the beginning of the island… opposite from Duval Street and Mallory square.. our room was at the entrance at the property, we heard all the traffic and ambulances all day and night… next time we will not get a room near the entrance!

10.0

Feb 2023

Fun

Your people made me feel welcome. Always helpful. A Jewel

I like it all

9.0

Feb 2023

Hang loose place :-)

Spacius rooms, quiet. We liked the bar and the marina.

Some cockroaches found on the floor.

10.0

Feb 2023

marvelous

no breakfast at resort

everything was perfect

9.0

Feb 2023

Great location, private feeling property!

We loved the pool area, lots of seating options, it was very clean and close to many of the rooms! The pool was seen from our balcony as well. The condos were larger than we expected, easy to park and hop on the elevators! These condos weren't too far from everything. We MAINLY loved how the property felt private and was on a coast line!

My main concern was the mattress protectors, when I took the sheets off our bed to help housekeeping, I was shocked to find the mattress covers were covered in human hair of all kinds and colors and lots of it!! Some stains on the matress covers as well. A bit disappointing considering how much we enjoyed the property and the overall stay!

8.0

Jan 2023

resort feel without the high price

stayed in a studio. it was perfect for the 2 of us. the bar on the water is what sold us the place and it was exactly our kind of place. cold beers and all the bar games

the bathroom was not the greatest. the vanity was too small and the door was in the way and had to be propped open. could use a full length mirror in the room

1.0

Jan 2023

crap

Place is very nice

The ownership was very rude because we parked our boat in a area they didn't like, they never gave us a slip number so we pulled up and the bar tender said i would put it here, so we did. We then get a call from jenni at 9 pm on the way to dinner after traveling all day, and she demanded us to move the boat or she will have our boat towed. She was very rude. Then our guys packed up there stuff Saturday before we left for our fishing day. I have check out date of Sunday at 10 am. They went in our room and took everything out. went in my underwear drawer and took them as long as my wife medicine. i then went and got my fishing poles and stuff. They didn't tell me about my wife medicine and underwear and 3,000.00 dollars i went back to room and found out that was gone and went right back to office they had it in a safe and they put it in a box and duct taped the box with duct tape where it took me 10 minutes to open. I then stayed the night Saturday night and was getting dressed in the living room at 9am and a maid walked in with no knock and unlocked the door and saw me in my boxers. I feel it was very unprofessional to go in our room Saturday when we left and Sunday before my check out time. The dock master also threatened us with his attorneys and would have us towed also. I feel i deserve a complete refund, i have never been treated this way at a hotel in my life it might of had something to do with our boat that sayS LETS GO BRANDON I will never stay here again

8.0

Jan 2023

Comfortable stay with plenty of room.

spacious rooms

9.0

Jan 2023

Superb

The staff was amazing. So helpful and accommodating to our every need. Went out of their way to get us what we needed. The bar was open on weekends which was a nice bonus. Give them a try, we enjoyed our stay.

Floors were very dirty and the jacuzzi was not working the entire week.

10.0

Dec 2022

we will definitely come back

it was everything we expected

The only thing we didn’t like was having to leave

8.0

Oct 2022

I enjoyed my stay & the property very much. I would return but be very careful not to lock myself out again! I felt

The property was beautiful, very tropical. I stayed in a studio condo; it was clean & nicely appointed. Bed was comfortable but pillows flat & not so great. Pool was beautiful, very clean.

Unfortunately one evening I sat on the porch at my room & locked myself out. It was about 6pm when I realized I didn’t have a key with me & I’d closed the door. The office was closed. No personnel were available to open my door. I called the property manager 3 times over the course of an hour before she returned my call. Because it was during Fantasy Fest she said it would be awhile before anyone could get to me. No one ever came & at about 9:30pm I called the manager back & she came to let me into my room. She was very apologetic. This incident pretty much messed up my plans that night. So just be aware staff are not on site in the evening if you need something.

8.0

Sep 2022

Beautiful place to stay!

Great property, beautiful grounds. I would have liked to relax at the little bar on the dock but it seemed to be closed the whole time. Otherwise a great stay!

We liked our whole stay.

10.0

Sep 2022

Exceptional

I loved everything about my stay. I will be coming back!

I did not dislike anything about my stay.

10.0

Aug 2022

Exceptional

everything

FAQs

How much does this hotel cost compared to others in Stock Island?

The average price for a rental in Stock Island is $332 per night. This rental is $141 less expensive than the average.

Is parking included with this hotel?

Yes, parking is listed as an amenity at Coconut Mallory Resort and Marina. For more information, we encourage you to contact the property about where to park.

Is there a pool at this hotel?

Yes, a swimming pool is available for use at Coconut Mallory Resort and Marina. Enjoy the water!

Is Coconut Mallory Resort and Marina pet friendly?

Unfortunately, this hotel is not pet-friendly. Try searching again and filter for "Pets Allowed"

What amenities are available at Coconut Mallory Resort and Marina?

We found 8 amenities for this rental. This includes pool, air conditioner, kitchen / kitchenette, internet / wifi, and parking.

Explore similar vacation rentals in Stock Island

Explore all rentals in Stock Island

3.9

Good(714 Reviews)

Coconut Mallory Resort and Marina

About this hotel

Amenities

Map of Stock Island, FL

Nearby attractions

Coconut Mallory Resort and Marina

Hotel in Stock Island, FL

Reasons to book

About this hotel

Amenities

Map of Stock Island, FL

Nearby attractions

Reviews

FAQs

How much does this hotel cost compared to others in Stock Island?

Is parking included with this hotel?

Is there a pool at this hotel?

Is Coconut Mallory Resort and Marina pet friendly?

What amenities are available at Coconut Mallory Resort and Marina?

Explore similar vacation rentals in Stock Island

Stock Island travel inspiration

Related vacation destinations

Keep exploring