Hotel in Sister Bay, WI
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
High-end valueWell priced for this area
About this hotel
Featuring an indoor pool and hot tub, Open Hearth Lodge is located in Door County’s Sister Bay. The town center and access to Lake Michigan are 3 minutes’ drive away. Free WiFi access is available.
Amenities
Golf course (within 2 mi)
Free WiFi/internet
Free Parking
Air conditioning
Pool
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
Gym
Heating
Wheelchair accessible
Balcony/Terrace
WiFi/Internet
Hot tub/Jacuzzi
Shared living spaces
Ski in/Ski out
Garden
Laundry services
Sauna
Accessible Parking
Fireplace
Outdoor Cooking
Family friendly
Smoking allowed
Toilet with grab rails
Accessible by lift
Key card access
Contactless check-in/out
Housekeeping available
Fire alarm
Fire extinguisher
Cleaning products
Map of Sister Bay, WI
Available Rooms
Ratings and reviews
100% verified reviews9 / 10Outstanding·Oct 2026
Well maintained family operation. Clean , quiet and a friendly staff.
Bed was soft.
10 / 10Outstanding·Oct 2026
The Open Hearth is an amazing gem in Door County. We have been coming up for many years but just never stayed here. We had a small group for my 50th birthday and it was perfect! Breakfast included a great selection, coffee was great. Loved the honor system for grabbing things like bottles of wine, frozen pizzas. The fire pits in front and back were great to meet up around. Hot tub was great. The grounds were impeccable. The owner's daughter who works here as well sang and played guitar one night and had us all in tears. The owner is amazingly friendly, helpful, resourceful. The entire place screams COZY! I can't say enough great things about this place - just book it! Great location as well and one of the stops on the free Sister Bay shuttle that runs on weekends. Across from the Peach Barn too - you can just walk across the street. I will be returning for sure!!!
There is nothing I didn't like. The only thing that could sway us staying elsewhere would be an outside pool in the summer. Our kids are still younger and they like the option of the indoor and outdoor pool. But honestly, this was so great that maybe we'd overlook the outdoor pool and just use the nearby beach which is equally amazing in the summer months.
10 / 10Outstanding·Oct 2026
Fire places
Space for everyone
All good
9 / 10Outstanding·Oct 2026
Super cute lodge. Love music. Fire pits. Great views!
Shower tension rod was broken.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
Most favorited
9.4Outstanding
(417 Ratings)
"The Open Hearth is an amazing gem in Door County. We have been coming up for many years but just never stayed here. We had a small group for my 50th birthday and it was perfect! Breakfast included a g..."
Verified guestDon't miss out! Price and availability may change
