House in North Eleuthera
4 guests · 2 bedrooms · 2 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Well priced for this locationPriced under area average
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
This charming hillside home is located in Rainbow Bay, directly across from the beautiful & secluded Rainbow Bay beach, Eleuthera. This private and fully furnished 2 bedroom, 2 bathroom cottage is situated on 1/3 acre of land surrounded by lush and mature island vegetation with beautiful sea views from the large verandah. The cottage has central air-conditioning and satellite TV, landline phone, very fast Starlink WIFI, a cozy living room, dine-in kitchen, dishwasher, charcoal grill, and an outdoor shower. The master bedroom has a queen bed. The guest bedroom has twin beds which can be converted to a king bed.
Key Lime Cottage is ideal for families, couples and honeymooners, and is situated literally across the small road (a minute's walk) from Rainbow Bay's private beach. The beach itself offers sparkling white sand and crystal clear azure waters perfect for shelling, snorkeling and fishing and is a naturally protected cove. Convenient picnic benches, secluded tiki huts on the beach are included as part of the rental. Rainbow Bay also has a private tennis court.
Rainbow Bay offers one of the best snorkeling spots on the island. From the above pictures you can see a small peninsula which juts out into the Caribbean. It is home to many of the island's tropical fish and rays. If you are a snorkeler, you will not be disappointed. From Key Lime cottage, you also have easy access to the Atlantic Ocean beaches.
It is just a mile to the acclaimed Rainbow Inn, which offers some of the best food on the island and live music many evenings. The nearest market for supplies is located just a few minutes away by car if you choose to cook at home in the fully-equipped kitchen. There is also now an organic vegetable farm five minutes to the north from the villa.
Centrally located on Eleuthera, Key Lime cottage is the is the perfect location for exploring the whole island north to south, from Harbor Island to Lighthouse Point, 100 miles of beaches, beauty and history. It is only 15 minutes from Governor's Harbor airport and 25 minutes from Governor's Harbor.
Eleuthera is a very friendly and safe island. It is a beautiful, relaxed destination with turquoise seas, and beautiful sunny weather. Once you come, you will definitely want to return.
Key Lime Cottage is ideal for families, couples and honeymooners, and is situated literally across the small road (a minute's walk) from Rainbow Bay's private beach. The beach itself offers sparkling white sand and crystal clear azure waters perfect for shelling, snorkeling and fishing and is a naturally protected cove. Convenient picnic benches, secluded tiki huts on the beach are included as part of the rental. Rainbow Bay also has a private tennis court.
Rainbow Bay offers one of the best snorkeling spots on the island. From the above pictures you can see a small peninsula which juts out into the Caribbean. It is home to many of the island's tropical fish and rays. If you are a snorkeler, you will not be disappointed. From Key Lime cottage, you also have easy access to the Atlantic Ocean beaches.
It is just a mile to the acclaimed Rainbow Inn, which offers some of the best food on the island and live music many evenings. The nearest market for supplies is located just a few minutes away by car if you choose to cook at home in the fully-equipped kitchen. There is also now an organic vegetable farm five minutes to the north from the villa.
Centrally located on Eleuthera, Key Lime cottage is the is the perfect location for exploring the whole island north to south, from Harbor Island to Lighthouse Point, 100 miles of beaches, beauty and history. It is only 15 minutes from Governor's Harbor airport and 25 minutes from Governor's Harbor.
Eleuthera is a very friendly and safe island. It is a beautiful, relaxed destination with turquoise seas, and beautiful sunny weather. Once you come, you will definitely want to return.
Amenities
Non-smoking
No pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of North Eleuthera
Ratings and reviews
Summary of reviewsGuests were highly impressed with the property's cleanliness, helpful staff, ideal location near Rainbow Bay Beach, and well-maintained condition. They appreciated the amenities provided and the excellent communication with the caretakers and owners.
8 / 10Excellent·Feb 2026
Great location Nice amenities Beautiful beachSereneGreat snorkel equipmentToilet seat was broken upon arrival
10 / 10Outstanding·Jul 2025
Wonderful, central location.We enjoyed being able to walk out the door and have one of the islands most beautiful beaches at our access.
8 / 10Excellent·Jul 2025
Even though there were a few hicups, the stay was nice. Plenty of towels, snorkling gear, floats, I left some new ones in pkgs. Parking was not the best. I would stay there again or reccomend it to someone else.
6 / 10Average·May 2022
Rating Details:
The property manager was somewhat unhelpful.
The vacation rental was clean.
I was happy with the location.
I was somewhat dissatisfied with the condition of the vacation rental.
Overall, I recommend this vacation rental.
Reviewer Comments:
Nice location across the street from rainbow bay. Could use decluttering- difficult to keep track of own things with so much stuff on tables/counters.needs updatingnice outdoor showercan see rainbow bay if out on front porch- no view from inside homeplenty of towels, beach chairsGood if one couple or a couple with 1-2 kids- not for 4 adults- as one bedroom just has twin beds.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.8Outstanding
(63 Ratings)
Guests were highly impressed with the property's cleanliness, helpful staff, ideal location near Rainbow Bay Beach, and well-maintained condition. They appreciated the amenities provided and the excellent communication with the caretakers and owners.
From real guest reviews summarized by AIDon't miss out! Price and availability may change
